Why are Somalis so xenophobic ?

[Banadiri Warrior]

What is the foundation of our unity then?
It's not the language since maxaa tiri iyo af maay are quite different, not ethnicity wise since all the clans have no one common ancestor.

If it is the culture, that is a very weak foundation for unity since culture changes over time.
We don't have a one idea that unites us all, nor are we claiming that all the land belong to all somalis, every man for themselves.

This is why I scoff at any nationalist trying to create a somalia based on inhabited land. Somalia, Ethiopia and all other mentally weak nations will never thrive without a solid base of unity.

Italians created somalinimo if you didn't know

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Non somali Ppl can't just come to live in somali lands and just claim it because they live in it which somali ppl allow them to live in it that is disrespectfull

Nobody was allowed, there's no need for permission, these are banadiri towns , lamagoodles were the ones allowed into the city during the day and had curfews. It's disrespectful to see Somalis from baadiya claiming cities their grandparents were guests in

 

[SizzleSomali]

That makes me wonder, what exactly is a Somali?
If it's not an ethnic identity then is it a cultural one like Arabs??

Why are somalis not arabs then if its cultural

 

[Haragwaafi]

That's only qoorbajoog kids with identity crisis kkk

 

[Khaem]

Being ethnically somali isn't relevant, it shouldn't even be brought up, barawa is in Somalia currently so that makes them somali

It is relevant.

The Somali ethnicity is the central part of the Somali nation.

 

[Khaem]

We'll send you back to Ethiopia

Is that what you taught yourself??
Somalis originated in somaliland you bastard child.

You won't send anyone back. Bastard fishermen smaller than a sub clan we'll dump you into the indian ocean.

 

[adventurequestworlds1.0.2]

Nobody was allowed, there's no need for permission, these are banadiri towns , lamagoodles were the ones allowed into the city during the day and had curfews. It's disrespectful to see Somalis from baadiya claiming cities their grandparents were guests in

You non somalis don't own cities in somalia you live in somali cities which you are quest to our lands don't insult people that let you ppl live in their lands
Never call me or somali ppl lamagoodles you fking big I can be racist 2 and call you racist slurs if you want
You quest in somalia act like one

 

[AdoonkaAlle]

Where were all those 50 hut villages? Did they just happen to all be buried in sand? how come there's no mention of hawiyes in manuscripts or oral history of the region. Where they not Muslim? Why aren't there any masjids built by them?

You just read 3 arab geographers being referenced mentioning a somali qabil & appearance of somalis ie "black Berber" yet go on ahead to completely brush it aside & ask irrelevant questions that have no bearing whatsoever on the issue at hand simply because it doesn't fit your narrative of somalis being outsiders ie non-natives to the city of merca & region etc

Are you trying to claim that 3 arab geographers from 3 different periods of time somehow all colluded with one another to distort and suppress your history ?

 

[Khaem]

You non somalis don't own cities in somalia you live in somali cities which you are quest to our lands don't insult people that let you ppl live in their lands
Never call me or somali ppl lamagoodles you fking big I can be racist 2 and call you racist slurs if you want
You quest in somalia act like one

Somalia is a Somali nation.

No such thing as "lamagoodles" only Somali, the minorities & the foriengiers

 

[Khaem]

You just read 3 arab geographers being referenced mentioning a somali qabil & appearance of somalis ie "black Berber" yet go on ahead to completely brush it aside & ask irrelevant questions that have no bearing whatsoever on the issue at hand simply because it doesn't fit your narrative of somalis being outsiders ie non-natives to the city of merca & region etc

Are you trying to claim that 3 arab geographers from 3 different periods of time somehow all colluded with one another to distort and suppress your history ?

Didn't ibn Battuta visiting Mogadishu in the 1300s say that those of Mogadishu to Zelia were of the same stock?

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

It is relevant.

The Somali ethnicity is the central part of the Somali nation.

There isn't even a consensus on what makes someone ethnic somali I've seen over 5 definitions of it that shows alot

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Is that what you taught yourself??
Somalis originated in somaliland you bastard child.

Is samaale buried in somaliland? Is hawiye buried in somaliland? You need evidence to declare a noble individual like me as bastard therefore that's slander thanks for the ajr

You won't send anyone back. Bastard fishermen smaller than a sub clan we'll dump you into the indian ocean.

Again more slander thanks for the ajr Idrus you're really helping

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

You non somalis don't own cities in somalia you live in somali cities which you are quest to our lands don't insult people that let you ppl live in their lands
Never call me or somali ppl lamagoodles you fking big I can be racist 2 and call you racist slurs if you want
You quest in somalia act like one

What makes the city Somali? It's part of Somalia now it wasn't Somali before, it would be insulting if I was a banadiri from galmudug that claimed galmudug was my land . Reer samaale were welcomed to banaadir and the banadiri samaales acknowledge that and are happy with it.
No need for all the fake emotions use that elsewhere

 

[AdoonkaAlle]

Didn't ibn Battuta visiting Mogadishu in the 1300s say that those of Mogadishu to Zelia were of the same stock?

sax, he even mentions that the sultan of muqdisho spoke the local language and arabic.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

You just read 3 arab geographers being referenced mentioning a somali qabil & appearance of somalis ie "black Berber" yet go on ahead to completely brush it aside & ask irrelevant questions that have no bearing whatsoever on the issue at hand simply because it doesn't fit your narrative of somalis being outsiders ie non-natives to the city of merca & region etc

Yes those questions have everything to do with it, they're not irrelevant, if you had functioning braincells you would admit that you can't answer the questions instead of making a fuss out of it. No mention of the word somali in those sources . Manuscripts and oral history of Marka takes precedence over what those sources say as the manuscripts are written by the natives . Why is it that hawiyes don't have marka in their oral history or any of those 50 hut villages that were supposedly in the region

Are you trying to claim that 3 arab geographers from 3 different periods of time somehow all colluded with one another to distort and suppress your history ?

Two of the geographers contradicted eachother when mentioning the location of hawiyes base and those 50 hut villages. Either way Reer Marka have preserved their history and sources from marka are more than enough

 

[Khaem]

There isn't even a consensus on what makes someone ethnic somali I've seen over 5 definitions of it that shows alot

Cope.

These are just people trying to include others who diverge from the standard which is someone from the Somali Clans.

The Somali ethnicity is one of the most homegenous and largest in East Africa.

 

[Khaem]

Is samaale buried in somaliland? Is hawiye buried in somaliland? You need evidence to declare a noble individual like me as bastard therefore that's slander thanks for the ajr

Again more slander thanks for the ajr Idrus you're really helping

Why do we need graves of mythical patriarchs.
Genetic evidence points towards the ethno genisis of the Somali being in modern somaliland. A Google search is all you need.

I can declare you a bastard all I want.
Take a 23 & me and you'll find out yourself.

You're the one coping so hard by saying there's no such thing as a Somali ethnicity as cope cause you aren't part of it.

 

[Cartan Boos]

we not quite xenophobic if we were we wouldn't had dalits on our land

 

[Khaem]

we not quite xenophobic if we were we wouldn't had dalits on our land

Loot at how Ethiopian ethnic chop up other ethnics on their land and displace them by the 100,000s every few years.

Somalis are not this brutal or hateful. Which is why these tiny Groups have the ability to simply exist. Had they been Ethiopian they would've ended up like the harari who actually had their own state in the region and were the center of Islam in the horn but were destroyed by barbarian solomids.

 

[Cartan Boos]

Loot at how Ethiopian ethnic chop up other ethnics on their land and displace them by the 100,000s every few years.

Somalis are not this brutal or hateful. Which is why these tiny Groups have the ability to simply exist. Had they been Ethiopian they would've ended up like the harari who actually had their own state in the region and were the center of Islam in the horn but were destroyed by barbarian solomids.

we even welcome these tigray and oromo into our land as refugees, we way too kind walahi