No it’s older. It’s a Neolithic admixture predating Persians. Your average Persian is 15.2% Anatolian farmer, 12.4 caucuses hunter gatherer, 10.2% eastern hunter gatherer, 20.6 Levant Neolithic, 38% Iran Neolithic, 2.6 East Asian, 1% ancient South Indian.
We had two pure Somalis from different Isaaq subclans and they had the most Arabian and it’s make far more sense for a powerful clan that lives closer to Yemenis and had deep relations with Yemeni Sultanates for centuries than some tiny unknown clan deep in the Horn that lives next to Oromo hordes
94 cushitic?
Yes, most Somalis are in the 90 percentile, i've only seen 1 sample from Somalia (Southern regions) that was 100% Cushitic.The most Arabian Somali samples on average are from SL & PL
I am not Muwallad, I am full isaaq sxb. its actually simple, go through your 23andMe relative list, i went through my 23andMe list of friends, for every 20 friends form the regions of SL and PL there are about 5 to 6 that have arabian/asian mix. Thats about 25% of my list, also I want to mention @Garaad Awal findings that majority who posts their G25 result from the NW regions have slightly less SSA compared to the rest of the regions including Somali K5 region. But its meaningless and insignificant amount, the difference is only between 3% to 5% on average sxb. Personally, i have observed that all pure somalis have roughly the same ratio admixture regardless of their clan, region or affinity. For every clan, region or affinity, there will be outliers, majority on average, few higher SSA than expected others lower SSA than expected.
Are that you that Isaaq that had exceptional above average Arabian? Your definitely an outlier. You can argue about it all you want. Also Hararghe Somalis have higher Arabian. Arguing against this is futile
I wont argue, my result and the Cimraan isaaq guy shows an unusually high Arabian, so i came to accept that our results are uncommon. However, i have a list of NW people who are dir (gadabgursi/samaroon), isaaq, warasangeli, gabooye, yibir and etc that show they have about 2 to 5 percent of Arabian/Asian ancestry on 23andMe. I also have a person who is the same sub clan as me adaraxman sacad sub clan xasan adaraxman with 5% MENA in 23andMe. Twenty five percent of my list is significant, 23andMe gives 100 percent somali ancentry unless you have delectable recent admixture. Majority who took the test came out as 100%, so why does my list show individuals with recent admixture?
That was meHararghe Somalis especially karanle sixaawle and gidir usually have higher eursian than the average somali.
Karanle cluster with other Hawiye. Are they not Hawiye? Show me some genetic tool evidence like GEDmatch or G25.
This girl is only quarter karanle from Hararghe. Her Ethio-Eri would have been much higher if she was full reer Hararghe. With the Ethio-Eri comes elevated Arabian. Her paternal haplogroup also points towards Arabia
'yes they’re hawiye but unlike southern hawiye
Once again how can you say all haiwye is 55-60% SSA cuz we have tested southern Somalis but not Hararghe hawiye ? You can’t expect to get the same result when we both know haiwye in Hararghe lived with hararis
She's got 99.6% east african on 23andMe.This girl is only quarter karanle from Hararghe. Her Ethio-Eri would have been much higher if she was full reer Hararghe. With the Ethio-Eri comes elevated Arabian. Her paternal haplogroup also points towards Arabia
Thread 'I got my 23andme DNA results
https://www.somalispot.com/threads/i-got-my-23andme-dna-results-
Again 23 and me only shows 3-5 generation back.
Not necessarily for example my son plots quiet close to to Nubian Christians and his full Moroccan, further more he plots closer to some Ethiopians and Eritreans then peninsular Arabs
She is a girl, how did she get her paternal haplogroup? Secondly, don't believe unless the person's posts evidence, I could easily post a result and say I got paternal R1b without evidence. She posted her result 99.6% east African but she did not post her paternal haplogroup. Her results is no different to other somali results in fact I would argue I have results that might shock you from warasangle, isaaq, gabooye, yibir and dir.
Unfortunately I did not get 99% somali. I am disappointed, I scored 73.8% somali
@Apollo said he came across some sacads who were more eurasian shifted. I feel like we need to test more hawiyes from the northest to the southest
She is well known on this forum. Those results are her brothers. She is my cousin. It’s not a secret that Hararghe have more elevated levels of Arabian disguised as Ethio-Eritrea.
