Capitalism vs Socialism

Which Economic System

  • Capitalism

  • Socialism


Results are only viewable after voting.

Helios

Certified Liin Distributor
AQOONYAHAN
VIP
You cant believe in complete free market capitalism and still be Muslim, change my mind
Im not a communist, but i do agree with a lot of socalistic policies
Obviously yes but the prophet Muhammad himself was a merchant for a long time and Uthman and other sahabbis were ridiculously rich which shows that Islam has no qualms with private enterprise. As long as it's being conducted ethically and there is an appreciation for the unfortunate.
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
Private property. Like you can own large swathes of land and what you do with it is your business not the state's?
I think all public property should be owned by the government and highly regulated, meaning it should be leased and not sold as a freehold land. They should also not be inheritable to offspring who did not work the land themselves and can sell it at a profit. Personal property and goods is yours but all means of production particularly land should be publicly owned.
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
Go to China and then take a train to the north east. When you get to your destination you will see the fruits of socialism. True socialism. Mind you watch out from the south. They be playing loud kpop
That's a country that has been under sanctions for most of its existence. You can argue the only reason it has survived till now is cause they work as a collective, however brutal it may be.
 
Somalis can't function in a socialist society for sure.

They just scam the welfare state and find ways of cheating. That's why Somalis can only exist in pure capitalism.
 
That's a country that has been under sanctions for most of its existence. You can argue the only reason it has survived till now is cause they work as a collective, however brutal it may be.
There's a reason the US and EU are rich and can sanction poor communists on a whim. They're just better.
 
Obviously yes but the prophet Muhammad himself was a merchant for a long time and Uthman and other sahabbis were ridiculously rich which shows that Islam has no qualms with private enterprise. As long as it's being conducted ethically and there is an appreciation for the unfortunate.
Obviously regulated capitalism, but thats why i said complete free market capitalism.
I think its litteraly impossible to be a Muslim and still believe in that kind of system, especially how easy it is to exploit the system and workers when you are at a certian wealth status
 

Helios

Certified Liin Distributor
AQOONYAHAN
VIP
I think all public property should be owned by the government and highly regulated, meaning it should be leased and not sold as a freehold land. They should also not be inheritable to offspring who did not work the land themselves and can sell it at a profit. Personal property and goods is yours but all means of production particularly land should be publicly owned.
Bruh you're rejecting private property ie land ownership ??? That's against Islamic principles lol. Why should the state own the land in your opinion?
 
Somalis can't function in a socialist society for sure.

They just scam the welfare state and find ways of cheating. That's why Somalis can only exist in pure capitalism.
What was Somalia before the war? With MSB, there was free healthcare, free education. No welfare ofc, but it wasn’t pure capitalism. I think Somalis do best with a dictator, it’s the only way we’ll listen.
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
There's a reason the US and EU are rich and can sanction poor communists on a whim. They're just better.
Yeah they are better at war cause they practice a system that allows for the exploitation of the working man. :russsmug:
 

Helios

Certified Liin Distributor
AQOONYAHAN
VIP
Yeah they are better at war cause they practice a system that allows for the exploitation of the working man. :russsmug:
Socialism is just an inefficient management of the working man by bureaucrats instead of capitalists by your reasoning then
 
Somalis can't function in a socialist society for sure.

They just scam the welfare state and find ways of cheating. That's why Somalis can only exist in pure capitalism.
You could make the exact same argument against capitalism, the fact that somalis only care about their only family and qabil would make it so only a certian group of people would hold the power , we see it right now, there is barely any goverment in somali and complete free market, somalis dont give a f*ck about qualification and only hire their close family and qabil.
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
Bruh you're rejecting private property ie land ownership ??? That's against Islamic principles lol. Why should the state own the land in your opinion?
All private property should be under the state. It should be leased on a temporary basis for instance during a lifetime but it should not be hereditary property. I think the state should own it cause it lessens the profit motive people have. There's less room for price manipulation, exploitation such as wage theft. The average worker would get their fair share.
 
All private property should be under the state. It should be leased on a temporary basis for instance during a lifetime but it should not be hereditary property. I think the state should own it cause it lessens the profit motive people have. There's less room for price manipulation, exploitation such as wage theft. The average worker would get their fair share.
What do you think the state is? You know theyre just some humans right? Why should we let a few individuals control all the private property?
 

AdoonkaAlle

Ragna qowl baa xira, dumarna meher baa xira.
Socialism already failed while capitalism is on it's way there so why bother i say ?

Doonimayno hab dhaqanka gaalada iyo fikradooda

Ha burburaan dhamaantood

giphy.gif




source.gif
 
All private property should be under the state. It should be leased on a temporary basis for instance during a lifetime but it should not be hereditary property. I think the state should own it cause it lessens the profit motive people have. There's less room for price manipulation, exploitation such as wage theft. The average worker would get their fair share.
Prvate proberty aside, do you believe in personal proberty?
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
What do you think the state is? You know theyre just some humans right? Why should we let a few individuals control all the private property?
The state is all of us, the beneficiaries of the production. We who voted in the people that represent our interest and can remove them through the ballot.
 

416

Lmao
Capitalism discriminates against the working class while socialism puts a ceiling on wealth. How much you make depends on what you side you support :manny:
 
Top