ArchBishopofAtheism
Intellectual saqajaan
The hadiths describe the life of the prophet and his actions. I'm not saying hadiths are unverifiable. I'm saying they don't offer proof of his prophethood. They just tell you what he did and ordered others to do. It's like telling someone you're a prophet and them telling others about it. The hadiths are verifiable. They just have zero credibility because they don't prove he was a prophet. The Quran doesn't prove it either because there's no evidence it was divinely inspired. You arrived at your conclusion by looking at evidence that wasn't itself conclusive and reliable. How do you know the Quran is from Allah, without referring me to the Quran?Who said the stories are unverifiable? You're a funny guy to make that claim, you have no idea about isnaad & silsilaat. The quran & hadith were wide spread through unbroken chains of narration.Within these narrations there is no discrepancies yet different narrators living in different regions at different times. Many of these hadith explicitly describe the miracles of the prophet alayhi salaam, which are undeniable due to the rigorous chains of narration all agreeing with one another. This is what happens when you pseudo "thinkers" talk a lot of shit without studying at all. My belief is firm & unshakable because I questioned & found answers in my deen after thorough studying. Nobody compelled me to do this, but I did it for my own contentment.
You lot are the biggest ignoramuses. If you leave the religion, go ahead. But don't come here making outlandish claims without properly studying the deen or you'll be called out and put in your place