BANTU
+op MVLI
Let me not be so hyperbolic, certain cities are overrun with Muslims
So, how did you live when you were in those areas? You abstained from meat until you could get halaal meat? That is the extreme behavior
How come Somalis don't eat halal food in some countries?
- Thread starter blackbanana
- Start date
- Status
So, how did you live when you were in those areas? You abstained from meat until you could get halaal meat? That is the extreme behavior
Yes. It DOES have to tell you how to pray (For a quranist). In Islam 5 daily prayers are mandatory. Do you deny this? Tell me how exactly it makes sense for payer to be mandatory but never once mention how it should be done.You're acting as if the Quran has to specifically tell you how to pray. If something is not in the Quran, then it's not necessary. Is the word of Allah not good enough for you? Then again, you guys follow Hadith that say to kill innocent apostates so the word of Allah pretty much holds no importance to you.
But that's besides the point. You do pray Xalimo. Clearly you've learned this from somewhere. Clearly it isn't from the Quran. You're so deep in denial that it's delicious.
xalimathe6
VIP
Admit you're wrong.
What kinda of propaganda is this all these ayat don't mention a specific time except for fajir and website called Quran only really this is what happens when you don't understand the Quran you fall for websiteswebsite like these
xalimathe6
VIP
You have no proof to back that claim.
I rest my case.
First time I agree with you
xalimathe6
VIP
There was no case for you to rest. You have yet to tell me anything that makes sense.
NotAjnabi
Somalilander
I did a post on this before, feel free to read:
"There's a difference between the sunnah and the hadith. The hadith is a so called saying of the prophet which cannot be proven to be authentic or true. The word Hadith is often understood to be a synonym for the word Sunnah. This is not correct. There is a great difference between the two not only regarding the extent of their authenticity, but also their content. So the first thing to understand is, a hadith can be unathentic or false, whilst the sunnah cannot.
This is mainly to do with the difference in transmission. The hadith has been translated by a few individuals, so it usually depends on their character, memory, or intellect, all of which can be affected even if said individual is pious. Whilst the Sunnah has been transfered by a entire generation to the next, the amount of people who practice the sayings of sunnah remove the possibility of the error. The memory of a few people can alter a message, but the memory of a thousand people can weed out the faulty messages.
One more thing to note is that the sunnah is only related to the practical parts of Islam, such as the hajj, prayer, etc. Whilst a hadith is not confined to a certain part of Islam, the contents vary from history, practices, and even explanations to the Quran and sunnah. And lastly, the Sunnah is not based on a hadith. Muslims do not pray, or do hajj in the way they do, because of the narrations of a few indivuals. To end this, the Sunnah is an independant soruce for Islam. A hadith will never be equal to the Sunnah and the Quran. End of story."
What's important to know is that the hadith appeared 180 to 300 years after the prophets death, no steps were used to preserve the actions of the prophet, thus unreliable. The hadith are only there for you to understand a topic deeper, never use the hadith as a reason for claiming something nor should you base anything based on a hadith, use the Quran and Sunnah.
NotAjnabi
Somalilander
The positions of the salat are shown in the Quran, the standing position is in 3:39 and 39:9, whilst the prostrating and bowing are in 2:43, 3:43, 9:112 22:26 22:77. The time to pray are also mentioned in 24:58, 17:78, 2:238, and 11:114.
Random asf, but last Eid I watched my old neighbours' house get raided by the police. They pulled up in a minibus with literally 8 officers. I thought it was a drug bust, but they walked out with three goats
To be quite honest, I didn't live there too long so I suppose it's not comparable to living your whole life in a place like that. What little meat I had was from a far place that charged double or bought online. Whenever I ate out with friends I'd order scusting vegetarian/fish dishes though. So nope, I've never intentionally had non-halal meat. Even before I moved to the UK
I get that there are people with literally no access to halal meat, but that doesn't void the requirement. I can understand why they would do it, but it's not extreme at all
Random asf, but last Eid I watched my old neighbours' house get raided by the police. They pulled up in a minibus with literally 8 officers. I thought it was a drug bust, but they walked out with three goats
no steps were taken by the prophet to preserve the hadith sxb. how reliable do you think are second hand information that was written 200 years later by some nomads.
Jake from State Farm
We pro xalimo all 2019
Random asf, but last Eid I watched my old neighbours' house get raided by the police. They pulled up in a minibus with literally 8 officers. I thought it was a drug bust, but they walked out with three goats
To be quite honest, I didn't live there too long so I suppose it's not comparable to living your whole life in a place like that. What little meat I had was from a far place that charged double or bought online. Whenever I ate out with friends I'd order scusting vegetarian/fish dishes though. So nope, I've never intentionally had non-halal meat. Even before I moved to the UK
I get that there are people with literally no access to halal meat, but that doesn't void the requirement. I can understand why they would do it, but it's not extreme at all
Why the goats. What tf were they doing with the goats
NotAjnabi
Somalilander
Replacing the geel
Why the goats. What tf were they doing with the goats
Why the goats. What tf were they doing with the goats
it was near eid al adha so they were going to slaughter them, but I think you may need some sort of licence to do so. Most people do it anyway though
Honestly, it was mad funny how the they pulled up so serious, next thing you know they're trying to pull goats out of the garden. One of them wallahi urinated on some officer's shoe fully resisting arrest
I always take Hadith with a pinch of salt
if hadiths are 200 years old that means after the prophets death , there has already been 2 or 3 generations gone. The ones who were alive of the time of the prophet and their children. How reliable will information be especially if the ones stating the hadith have not already starting loosing their minds as a result of old age.
if hadiths are 200 years old that means after the prophets death , there has already been 2 or 3 generations gone. The ones who were alive of the time of the prophet and their children. How reliable will information be especially if the ones stating the hadith have not already starting loosing their minds as a result of old age.
- Status
