Is Pland region GDP Per capita higher than Sland region?

[Bohol]

Poverty is very high across Somalia. Your bias is clearly showing.

What bias. There is a big difference between $347 and $1000. Sure the entire Somalia is poor but there is no excuse for regions (specially in northern Somalia) that had peace for decades to be so under-performing.

 

[DR OSMAN]

What bias. There is a big difference between $347 and $1000. Sure the entire Somalia is poor but there is no excuse for regions (specially in northern Somalia) that had peace for decades to be so under-performing.

@Bohol I trust ur judgment who is stronger dhulos or hy? cuz hy cud handle maryalool in 96. So arap-hj-ha-ayub all combined is=HY. Isaaq is basically TWO HY, one HY and the rest combined being HY strength.

Can dhulos handle 2 HY? or wud they need warsan help? I think it would be close or even. Dhulos/Warsan vs 2 HY sized clans combined? the awood qaybsi in sl is bullshit.

 

[IstarZ]

What bias. There is a big difference between $347 and $1000. Sure the entire Somalia is poor but there is no excuses for regions (specially in northern Somalia) that had peace for decades to be so under-performing.

Your obvious agenda against SL. It was pointed out to you many times in this thread, those figures cannot be classed as accurate because there’s no real data on GDP for Somali regions. However, of course you don’t let that get in the way of taking a dig at SL once again.

 

[Bohol]

Your obvious agenda against SL. It was pointed out to you many times in this thread, those figures cannot be classed as accurate because there’s no real data on GDP for Somali regions. However, of course you don’t let that get in the way of taking a dig at SL once again.

Hence the question mark in the thread title. I never said it was 100% accurate it is a open question to everyone that have reliable sources on the matter, don't get your knickers in a twist.

 

[IstarZ]

Hence the question mark in the thread title. I never said it was 100% accurate it is a open question to everyone that have reliable sources on the matter, don't get your knickers in a twist.

Yes, start with a question but proceed to talk matter-of-factly.

 

[Bohol]

Yes, start with a question but proceed to talk matter-of-factly.

Like I said marwo don't jump into conclusions.

 

[Fiidmeer]

GDP $5 billion??

 

[Puntlandtheglorious]

@Bohol I trust ur judgment who is stronger dhulos or hy? cuz hy cud handle maryalool in 96. So arap-hj-ha-ayub all combined is=HY. Isaaq is basically TWO HY, one HY and the rest combined being HY strength.

Can dhulos handle 2 HY? or wud they need warsan help? I think it would be close or even. Dhulos/Warsan vs 2 HY sized clans combined? the awood qaybsi in sl is bullshit.

Dhulos can handle 1 hy by there selves they have all the Soviet era equipment

 

[Reer-Bari]

I don't believe GDP figures from Somalia. It's actually insanely difficult to accurately calculate GDP, even developed countries can't get it right and people in the econ/trading community question China's.

Your right but the average salary in bosaso compared to hargaisa is not even close. Also no puntlander lives in a refugee camp. Isaaq are heavy in refugee camps all over somaliland. Al the refugee camps in puntland consists of reer konfuur, reer somaliland and Oromo.

 

[Reer-Bari]

All the waiters in restaurants in bosaso and garowe are either dhullos or isaaq

 

[DR OSMAN]

All the waiters in restaurants in bosaso and garowe are either dhullos or isaaq

You called me a madhiban anigo 9 ku taga hassan yusuf son of yusuf cisman. Adiga imisa ku tagta ismail ali and u will see who is langaab. Don't include yourself in the abtirsi, it starts from your 'abbe' and on-wards. If your landheere you would be 20 to ismail ali as u wud have had more males then me.

 

[Farah072]

Straight from Pirateland gov website. Another fake news thread

 

[Reer-Bari]

You called me a madhiban anigo 9 ku taga hassan yusuf son of yusuf cisman. Adiga imisa ku tagta ismail ali and u will see who is langaab. Don't include yourself in the abtirsi, it starts from your 'abbe' and on-wards. If your landheere you would be 20 to ismail ali as u wud have had more males then me.

Walahi so ceeb. You just exposed how small your tribe is. But why would I identify myself on this website. Ur sitting comfortably in your mental asylum in Australia. While I’m in garowe. And stop following me to other threads you weirdo.

 

[Crow]

There is a huge misconception in this thread about the meaning of the GDP. Gross Domestic product is the aggregation of the value of all final product (goods) , that are produced during a year, within the boundaries of country. In other words it is a measurement for the productivity of a country.

1) The first misconception is that the GDP per capita is a measurement for the average income of the country. The GDP has literally nothing to do with the income of the state, nor does the GDP per capita tells what the average person earns as an income. A simple example: A company produces cars and sells them and the annual sales are 20 Million dollars. If this is the only company of the country and the country has 1000 inhabitants, the GDP is 20 Million dollars and the GDP per capital is 20,000 dollars. So the GDP per capita is the productivity of the inhabitants per average, NOT the average income.

France has a GDP per capita of 35,100 Euro and the average income is something around 3000 Euro. Two completely unrelated things.

As a footnote @Bohol the decentralization of Puntlands economy has no inevitable connection to a higher GDP or GDP per capita. One big company can be more productive than 1000 other small companies combined.

2) Now to the core statement of the thread: That Puntland has a higher GDP than Somaliland is impossible and doesn't make sense at all. The only produced goods of both states that matter are livestock and services, since both don't have an industry. As for livestock we all know that the Berbera port exported three times the size of Bosaaso, before the livestock ban. As for services, without any doubt, there are more services provided in Somaliland and it isn't even close at all, since Somaliland has more than two times more inhabitants. The services provided in Hargeysa and Burco alone with a combined population bigger than Puntland are even higher.


3) MAYBE Puntland has a higher GDP per capita, but this wouldn't surprise me due to their lower population. As @Apollo correctly pointed out, there is no reliable estimation for this.

Warya @Teeri-Alpha come in, this is a debate for you. Correct me if i'm wrong.

View attachment 78644 Straight from Pirateland gov website. Another fake news thread

Read the thread title again. It says GDP per capita.

 

[Timo Jareer and proud]

Instead of fighting over desert in Sanaag/Sool over tribal lines that mean nothing in the grand scheme of things and worrying about what tribe the president is, how about we handle the real issues?

Somalia has a GDP of $6 billion and is $5 billion in debt. Let that sink in.

Our politicians are shit. We need young people in government not the same dumbasses who put us in this mess 31 years ago.

 

[Farah072]

Read the thread title again. It says GDP per capita.

Read the Pirateland website they don’t examine any type of GDP whether it be overall or per capita

 

[Abdurahman_somali]

I must apologize to the people of this thread for spreading one misinformation. I am currently reading a book about economics and read today something about GDP. After reading i remembered this thread and realized that i made a crucial mistake in my first post in this thread. Yes BIP is the productivity of the country, BUT it is also the income of a country, because both are in the economical sense the same. In the theory companies invest the money they get from their producted goods, in the salaries of their employees, hence income=production (economical cycle).

@Bohol was actually right, when he said the average person income is the GDP per capita.

@Timo Madow and proud @Gucci mane @Factz @Lordilord @PhySom you guys either liked my post or rated it as informative. The rest was correct, but i had to correct and admit this mistake. Not that anything i wrote here is relevant for any person of this thread, but i had to salve my conscience. Misinformation is indeed a dirty tactic.

 

[Timo Jareer and proud]

I must apologize to the people of this thread for spreading one misinformation. I am currently reading a book about economics and read today something about GDP. After reading i remembered this thread and realized that i made a crucial mistake in my first post in this thread. Yes BIP is the productivity of the country, BUT it is also the income of a country, because both are in the economical sense the same. In the theory companies invest the money they get from their producted goods, in the salaries of their employees, hence income=production (economical cycle).

@Bohol was actually right, when he said the average person income is the GDP per capita.

@Timo Madow and proud @Gucci mane @Factz @Lordilord @PhySom you guys either liked my post or rated it as informative. The rest was correct, but i had to correct and admit this mistake. Not that anything i wrote here is relevant for any person of this thread, but i had to salve my conscience. Misinformation is indeed a dirty tactic.

for being truthful. People dont like to admit that they are wrong, for you to correct yourself in this matter is very mature. It makes you a more truth worthy person in the future on this forum.