WHY YOU LEFT THE DEEN

I’ll watch it soon, thank you.

But even if the Syriac story came after this Surah was revealed, there were still other versions that date centuries prior. I remember reading about Josephus’ version in the first century containing the story of Alexander, Yajuj and Majuj and the wall between a valley. All within the story of Dhul Qarnayn.

Dhul Qarnayn also means “Two Horned one”
And coins of Alexander have been found depicting him with horns like these:

View attachment 261569

Not to mention tafsirs like al-Jalalayn also believed it was Alexander
It could also mean the possessor of two nations so that’s why many people believed he was Cyrus or Darius they were also monotheist and Josephus and the Bible talks about dhulqarnain see Daniel 8 and Josephus was known to hellenise Jewish history and the Greeks and romans hated the Persians.
 

killerxsmoke

2022 GRANDMASTER
THE PURGE KING
VIP
I was told recently that during wars your allowed to rape the female prisoners of wars, I need you guys to tell me if that is true or not because that is one of my major doubts
 

Barni

⚠️ EPILEPTIC WARNING ⚠️
I was told recently that during wars your allowed to rape the female prisoners of wars, I need you guys to tell me if that is true or not because that is one of my major doubts
Yeah it true they r called what the right hand possesses. It was one of the reason y left islam for the first time
 

Barni

⚠️ EPILEPTIC WARNING ⚠️
I’d say I have doubts though am still practicing. Most pressing one is the story of Dhul Qarnayn and how eerily similar it is to older Alexander the Great myths that were floating around those times.
I also heard that the prophet SAW night journey to the heavens was inspired by a zoroastrian story but I tried looking around for it but couldn’t find it so I guess it isn’t true.
 

Garaad diinle

 
Cuz u support khaniisnimo
I don't think it's helpful to call people kafir if they themselves didn't do so. The ruling in islam is very clear and we don't shy away from stating the obvious. We're not compromising the diin we're simply trying to clear things out so that their iman would strengthen and become firm.
 

Barni

⚠️ EPILEPTIC WARNING ⚠️
Cuz u support khaniisnimo
All i said was khanis ppl deserve the right not to be killed, & that khanisnimo isnt a choice. Not once did I say that it was allowed in islam. All I was hoping was for muslims is to be sympathetic towards lgtbq muslims who abstain for the sake of allah.
 

killerxsmoke

2022 GRANDMASTER
THE PURGE KING
VIP
All i said was khanis ppl deserve the right not to be killed, & that khanisnimo isnt a choice. Not once did I say that it was allowed in islam. All I was hoping was for muslims is to be sympathetic towards lgtbq muslims who abstain for the sake of allah.
I used to be one of those guys that had the mentality of saying to kill all LGBT on sight, right now I think we should leave then alone. Although we do have to stop them from promoting it but just leaving them alone is the answer
 

Garaad diinle

 
I don't mean this as a slight but i'm simply surprised at the number of people with weak iman. I mean it's not much but i don't thing that everyone with weak iman will come forward. If this is the state of the current generation what about the next generation? I'm now convinced that teaching arabic to the next generation is essential to keep the diin especially since a lot of people here with weak iman can't read or write arabic. Then they'll be more familiar with their religion or at least this is the plan.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
I was told recently that during wars your allowed to rape the female prisoners of wars, I need you guys to tell me if that is true or not because that is one of my major doubts

Of course not. One of the biggest sins in Islam is hurting prisoners of war, cutting the trees and burning places of worships like churches and synagogues
 
He chose the wrong time. He started on a Monday night instead of Friday evening. Getting a platinum requires planning.
The key to getting plat threads is by setting it up to get derailed and turned into a chat room. You do this by targeting either argumentative users or kids with free time. Idk how to pull it off.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
The key to getting plat threads is by setting it up to get derailed and turned into a chat room. You do this by targeting either argumentative users or kids with free time. Idk how to pull it off.

It should either be entertaining or triggering. No in between, rationality has no place here.
 

Garaad diinle

 
@Garaad diinle can you answer this for me
I don't know if i'm qualified to answer this question one must admit their lack of knowledge but i'l share what i know. First of there isn't anything about this in quran and sunnah as far as i know. The rules of war in islam is as follows.

"You will find a people who claim to have totally given themselves to God. Leave them to what they claim to have given themselves… Do not kill women or children or an aged, infirm person. Do not cut down fruit-bearing trees. Do not destroy an inhabited place. Do not slaughter sheep or camels except for food. Do not burn bees and do not scatter them. Do not steal from the spoils, and do not be cowardly"

As you can see there is no such thing as the r word included. What your talking about is most likely is slavery in islam. The prisoner of war if not ransomed or freed by he who caught them are sold as slaves. Islam didn't have prisons so what they did with the captive is sell them to people were they worked under their master or prisoner much like prison labour.

What about the women. As i said i'm not very knowledgeable so you may read further on the topic. I read that the men must ask for permission to engage in intercourse and i read in another place that the women are seen as have been forcefully married to their master so they are considered a pseudo wife with less right for example they don't get maher but her children are free and not slaves where as in other cultures the children would also be seen as slaves.

conclusion.

So slavery is capitalism where prisons are privatized where everyone can get a prisoner for a price and the prisoner would do prison labour unless the prisoner wanna free himself at that point he would have to sign a contract with the master to free himself. Same goes for women with the sole exception that they're seen as pseudo wife with less rights than a free wife but her children if they're the children of the master are free children. Keep in mind slavery wasn't introduced by islam and was practiced by every single culture out there including christianity and judaism. Islam infact curbed down on many forms of slavery such as kidnap slaver, debt slavery or simply selling a free person.

There are rules as to how to treat a slaves in islam the prophet ﷺ said.

They are your brothers whom Allah has put under your authority, so if Allah has put a person’s brother under his authority, let him feed him from what he eats and clothe him from what he wears, and let him not overburden him with work, and if he does overburden him with work, then let him help him.” [Bukhari 6050]

Slaves in islam became statesmen sultans and military commanders at some point. Many early esteemed muslim scholars that are respected were slaves themselves.
 
Last edited:

Trending

Latest posts

Top