why do some xalimo's pick caribbean/west african reverts

[ibn Yahya Al-Sooli]

yeah, Shirshore Habrwa

Bro is the yahya clan even respected back home, I swear its so small

My dad apparently tells me we used to be king of dhulbahante and then alot of us died fighting for inna abdullah hassan LOOL idk how true that is but I'm skeptical

 

[Mehdi Hassan]

They are Somali.

Nope.

 

[World]

Wacays abdulle

There was another poster who was wacays abdulle as well but he’s not as active anymore @Starscream

 

[Mehdi Hassan]

They are Somali.

If they are then why are they discriminated against?

 

[ibn Yahya Al-Sooli]

There was another poster who was wacays abdulle as well but he’s not as active anymore @Starscream

Out of curiosity whats your subclan?

 

[Caaro]

Nice, Both my paternal and maternal grandmather are wacays abdulle. They are also in the same subclan within wacays abdulle. I think its ahmed wacays

I'm not sure, I had my abtirsi in my notes on my Iphone but can't access it rn. But I'm 80% sure off memory that after wacays abdulle we had muse abdulle.

 

[Caaro]

If they are then why are they discriminated against?

They are nationally and culturally somali, but Somali is also an ethnic group. Which they're not apart of.

Similar to arab, you can be an arab culturally and nationally but not ethnically.

 

[Mehdi Hassan]

You're only Somali if you're ethnically Somali. @ibn Yahya Al-Sooli @911 What's so hard to understand about that? You need to be part of one of the four major clans. It's not racist, it's just the honest truth.

 

[Mehdi Hassan]

They are nationally and culturally somali, but Somali is also an ethnic group. Which they're not apart of.

Similar to arab, you can be an arab culturally and nationally but not ethnically.

You can only be Arab if your father is. There's no such thing as a linguistic, national or cultural Arab.

 

[World]

Bro is the yahya clan even respected back home, I swear its so small

My dad apparently tells me we used to be king of dhulbahante and then alot of us died fighting for inna abdullah hassan LOOL idk how true that is but I'm skeptical

It’s true, they used to be a much larger sub clan before the Darawiish wars.

I am Xasan Ugaas.

 

[Caaro]

You can only be Arab if your father is. There's no such thing as a linguistic, national or cultural Arab.

We're speaking legally here and technicalities. A chinese man can come and get a somali passport and legally speaking, he'd be a Somali national. That doesn't mean he's Somali.

I get what you're saying though, how come somalis living in ethiopia aren't considered "ethiopian". Which means that the identity of "Somali" lies within ethnicity and not borders.

I was simply answering your questions on why someone would call somali bantus, somali. No need to qashin me

 

[Advokaten]

Which one is the biggest subclan of dhulbahante. Nur axmed and Naleye axmed i was told was one of them?

 

[farax]

View attachment 119625

Ah yes

 

[Advokaten]

I'm not sure, I had my abtirsi in my notes on my Iphone but can't access it rn. But I'm 80% sure off memory that after wacays abdulle we had muse abdulle.

I think you mean muse wacays, Both my grandmothers are abdi wacays i was mistaken with ahmed wacays which dont ever exist. Wacays abdulle are composed of abdi wacays,muse wacays, maxamed wacays, samakab wacays and naleye wacays. Farmajos mother is wacays abdulle and he still helps out with his reer abti

 

[ibn Yahya Al-Sooli]

Which one is the biggest subclan of dhulbahante. Nur axmed and Naleye axmed i was told was one of them?

I heard it’s jamaac siyad. It’s definitely either jamaac siyad or naleye axmed

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Advokaten]

I heard it’s jamaac siyad. It’s definitely either jamaac siyad or naleye axmed

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Jamac siyad cant be even compared with naleye. Since jamac siyaad would be a naleye ahmed great grandfathers brother. Naleye Ahmed Abdulle samakab ugadygan siad maxamud, Which means ugadyahan is jamac siyaads brother which also means that they were 3 generatiions inbetween jamac and naleye and still naleye axmed is significantly more then the jamac siyad

 

[World]

I think Baharsame are the largest Dhulbahante sub clan.

 

[Bossanova]

Ah yes

Your display pic

 

[farax]

Your display pic

yes, there will be a new era for Somalia after that traitor farmaajo resigns

 

[Caaro]

I think you mean muse wacays, Both my grandmothers are abdi wacays i was mistaken with ahmed wacays which dont ever exist. Wacays abdulle are composed of abdi wacays,muse wacays, maxamed wacays, samakab wacays and naleye wacays. Farmajos mother is wacays abdulle and he still helps out with his reer abti

Oh yeahh now I remember, maxamed muse wacays abdulle samakab. Now it makes sense, My brain is in a bunch with these few generations because literally all those names are either the names of my cousins or brothers.

I literally only know my dad's abtirsi, I have no idea what my mom's subclan is. All I know is that she's dhulbahante.