This is the story of the founding of Mogadishu in the Arabic book and banadri books

[Banadiri Warrior]

This is a lie. Ibn Battuta called his grandson a barbaric name

Ibn Battuta didn't encounter Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani's grandson

 

[killerxsmoke]

Banaadir is plural of Bandar which in this context means coastal city it's word of Persian origin frequently used in Arabic, there aren't any ancient reer samaale tombs in xamar ,none of the gibil madow reer xamar clans or families that claim to be from samaale clans in the interior claim any of the ancient graves, all the ancient graves are of Arabs and persians .

Didnt I already proved to u that I have a forefather that is buried in Mogadishu

 

[ibrahym]

Ibn Battuta didn't encounter Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani's grandson

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Al-hilwani and Banu Harith, never existed

Banu Harith is a tribe that exists till this day in arabia ,you can't declare a tribe to be non-existent for your own interest.

If you didn't know about hilwani dynasty, you can read on it here.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Didnt I already proved to u that I have a forefather that is buried in Mogadishu

That's not ancient and I've been told by reliable sources that his body was brought to xamar recently

 

[killerxsmoke]

That's not ancient and I've been told by reliable sources that his body was brought to xamar recently

Show it to me then?

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

View attachment 284788

Which century did ibn Batuta encounter Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar and which century did Abubakar bin Fakhruddin rule? You'll find your answers when you find out the answers to those two questions

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Show it to me then?

Show what?

 

[killerxsmoke]

Which century did ibn Batuta encounter Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar and which century did Abubakar bin Fakhruddin rule? You'll find your answers when you find out the answers to those two questions

Abubakar is a somali

 

[killerxsmoke]

Show what?

Prove it to me that his body was brought to xamar??

 

[ibrahym]

Banu Harith is a tribe that exists till this day in arabia ,you can't declare a tribe to be non-existent for your own interest.

View attachment 284789
If you didn't know about hilwani dynasty, you can read on it here.

Sharif Aidour's book is not a source

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Prove it to me that his body was brought to xamar??

I don't need to prove it , thats what's known amongst reer xamars

 

[ibrahym]

Which century did ibn Batuta encounter Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar and which century did Abubakar bin Fakhruddin rule? You'll find your answers when you find out the answers to those two questions

 

[Khaemwaset]

Who are those coastal Somalis? What tribe do they belong to , who are their modern day descendants?

Coastal somalis.
Literally just somalis who live on the coast. You think somalis were allergic to water and only stayed in arid lands instead of setting towns in the coastline? You lot are ridiculous

 

[killerxsmoke]

I don't need to prove it , thats what's known amongst reer xamars

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Sharif Aidour's book is not a sourceView attachment 284790

You're claiming shariif Caydaruus book isn't a source when you're using his sons book, and that page just further proves my point, there were two centuries in-between Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani and Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar. Also if you actually read my source you'd see that shariif Caydaruus mentions at the beginning that he found it in a manuscript written by Shaykh Muhyiddin bin Mu'allim Mukarram which was in the library of his son Shaykh Abubakar bin Shaykh Muhyiddin.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Coastal somalis.
Literally just somalis who live on the coast. You think somalis were allergic to water and only stayed in arid lands instead of setting towns in the coastline? You lot are ridiculous

I didn't say they're not, there's groups like jaaji and certain daroods that fish ,you didn't provide a sufficient answer to my question

 

[ibrahym]

I sent you four pages explaining that the dynasty of Fakhr al-Din continues until the fall at the hands of a Portuguese or al-Muzaffar.
The coins agreed on this also that Mogadishu had two ruling dynasties: Fakhr al-Din and al-Muzaffar.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

View attachment 284791View attachment 284792View attachment 284793View attachment 284794

Those aren't banadiri sources, them claiming Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar to be descendant of Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani is merely based upon assumptions

 

[ibrahym]

Those aren't banadiri sources, them claiming Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar to be descendant of Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani is merely based upon assumptions

Banadri sources is biased manuscripts written in the Omani era