Poll and discussion: Pan Arabism vs Pan Islamism

What would you choose


  • Total voters
    23
  • Poll closed .
A pan islamist state would collapse quite quickly and wouldn't last very long where as a pan arabist state would be more likely to work since arabs are already united under 1 language 1 ethnicity etc.

edit: watch this video about pan islamism
Masaman is just a youtuber
 
Pan Africanism i have always wanted to wear this

d2a8c4eee03d1e630933e84f1b427ce4.jpg
 

ibn Yahya Al-Sooli

Anti-Qabiilism & Anti-Nationalism
@ibn Yahya Al-Sooli why did you qashin me pan Islamic state sounds great but there will 100% be a civil war between sects instantly
You could’ve used this argument during the time of the prophet when he called you pledge of allegiance to him. In fact many did use this argument, which is that its impossible to unite all the different tribes of arabia and even if they were united there would be civil war after. In fact they were right, there was civil war after and it’s called the “ridda wars” do some research. But that still didn’t stop the sahabah (May Allah be pleased with them) from going forth with striving to unite the Muslims under one state.
 

Djokovic

Somali Arab
You could’ve used this argument during the time of the prophet when he called you pledge of allegiance to him. In fact many did use this argument, which is that its impossible to unite all the different tribes of arabia and even if they were united there would be civil war after. In fact they were right, there was civil war after and it’s called the “ridda wars” do some research. But that still didn’t stop the sahabah (May Allah be pleased with them) from going forth with striving to unite the Muslims under one state.
Sounds cool but probably won’t happen till isa as is resurrected and Mahdi comes
 
Last edited:

Prettymuslim94

A man trying to be successful
Read up on history. Russia only allies with Iran for geopolitical reasons. They're allies with Israel through blood.
Search Results
Featured snippet from the web
They maintain relations with their relatives and friends in Russia, and this make the interstate relations very special". In a meeting with Netanyahu in June 2016, Putin described Israel and Russia as "unconditional allies" in "efforts to counter international terrorism".



Yeah totally allies :mjlol:
Russia will rescue Russian jews and that's about it.
 

ibn Yahya Al-Sooli

Anti-Qabiilism & Anti-Nationalism
Search Results
Featured snippet from the web
They maintain relations with their relatives and friends in Russia, and this make the interstate relations very special". In a meeting with Netanyahu in June 2016, Putin described Israel and Russia as "unconditional allies" in "efforts to counter international terrorism".



Yeah totally allies :mjlol:
Looool you been wrong twice now. First on the arab-Israeli war and now on Russia and Israel having strong ties and relationship. I think it’s time for you to log off
:pachah1:
 

Prettymuslim94

A man trying to be successful
Looool you been wrong twice now. First on the arab-Israeli war and now on Russia and Israel having strong ties and relationship. I think it’s time for you to log off
:pachah1:
Only problem is all those Moroccans, Tunisians in Israel but yeah im just trolling a bit about Israelis they are too strong right now
 

Trending

Top