what opinion due you hold regarding Sayid Mohamed Abdullah Hassan and is you opinion positive or negative and why?
Sayid Mohamed Abdullah hassan
- Thread starter Trailblazer
- Start date
- Status
*Every Daarod believes he was a Prophet-like warrior that fought for Somali nationalism.
*Prior to 1991, Every Hawiye believed what the Daarod believed. Post-1991, still many Hawiye hold the idea that he was a great man, although you will find some Hawiye that dislike the guy because he simply was a Daarod and he is idolized by almost all Daarods.
*Every Isaaq believes he was a warlord, ruthless scum. They believe he was a terrorist; the father of modern day Al Shabaab.
I just gave you how every Somali would vote.
*Prior to 1991, Every Hawiye believed what the Daarod believed. Post-1991, still many Hawiye hold the idea that he was a great man, although you will find some Hawiye that dislike the guy because he simply was a Daarod and he is idolized by almost all Daarods.
*Every Isaaq believes he was a warlord, ruthless scum. They believe he was a terrorist; the father of modern day Al Shabaab.
I just gave you how every Somali would vote.
SomaliSteel
No dictator can imprison a population forever.
He was leading one of the only main resistance groups to colonial occupation. He and all that fought with him should be respected by all Somalis.
what about the Dir, Rahaweyn, Midhiban etc. I know that he order the assassination of an oppositional shiekh from Barawa. i think he was Brawanis. Each clan has a position steeped in emotionalism, they can't give an objective reason why they hold a positive or negative opinion of the Siyadka. For me he was very complicated and fits into each category list above. furthermore, He define the age with which he was born into, somalis will remember him for the next centuries, he didn't quite reach the highs of Imam Ahmed Guray, but he was the only somalis to come close to this lofty position in 400 hundred years.
not really because some mj's dislike him, he did have clashes with them in the past... and not every isaaq believes that theres quite a few who argue isaaqs were apart of darawish..
He was tunni, not barawani.
Not everyone is qabil minded, even though I'm a direct descendant of people who fought and lost against dervishes, I can still recognise that they were the only force protecting all somalis against euro hegemony. Not everyone is corrupted by qabil.
waraabe
Your superior
I have no opinion in him
On one hand he fought the british which is good, on the other hand he killed so many members of his qabiil because they refused to serve him. He massacred Warsangeli, some dhulo and some mj. The Warsangeli sultanate called the british for help like the mj sultaan.
He certainly was pushed down our throats by the kacaan tho as an ideal somali hero and the biggest somali hero AHMED GURAY was pushed out because he was not darod. Disgraceful and most somalis woke up to him
On one hand he fought the british which is good, on the other hand he killed so many members of his qabiil because they refused to serve him. He massacred Warsangeli, some dhulo and some mj. The Warsangeli sultanate called the british for help like the mj sultaan.
He certainly was pushed down our throats by the kacaan tho as an ideal somali hero and the biggest somali hero AHMED GURAY was pushed out because he was not darod. Disgraceful and most somalis woke up to him
waraabe
Your superior
That is a complete bullshit. some Darods don't like him, mj and Warsangeli being 2 and even some dhulo subs. He killed more darod then anyone else.
Hawiye really didn't know or care about him but they started to dislike him when kacaan pushed him as the biggest somali hero. Ogaden like him because he's cagdheer,
Some Isaaq like him, most don't know him. Some hy and hj were his generals and part of his army
Dir don't know him
Raxanweeyn don't know him
Freebandz
MONEY TEAM
When did that happen
Do the Indian people do polls like about Gandhi? Or Americans do polls about George Washington ? Or british Winston Churchill .....etc only Somalis like to trash everything good in their history for tribalism.
He was a warlord and to make it worse he was a Sufi.
We broke his back on many occasions. My forefathers karbaashed him so bad the nigga spent half his time writing poetry.
Wrong Warsangeli liked him especially after he married the Warsangeli sultan sister even the sultan fought with him which led to the lost his power and British send the Warsangeli sultan to island Seychelles. The sayid' daughter lives till in our village.
ina cabdulla xasan wasn't very intelligent at all. It's okay to be power hungry but it's not okay to fail in the quest for power.
waraabe
Your superior
instead of making up stories how about check the reality. I swear somali hate the truth,
straight from the horses mouth
http://warsangeli.org/in-depth/sultanate-shire.htm
What make you say that? What would you've done in his place?
waraabe
Your superior
united the somalis around him under islam, played down the qabyaalad (he was a qabiilest, listen to his poems),
Basically act like the true somali hero Ahmed gurey
S
Was he the only one in his time with those type of poems, no. He was though, the only one in his time to stand against the invaders of our country.,
Straight of the horse read this, do not let your tribalism blind and think as Somali not of your tribe
Attachments
- Status
Trending
-
-
-
A Black American Calls A Somali "Black jesus" And She Thinks He Is Cute- Started by killerxsmoke
- Replies: 58
