kafir I head you got a sister... is she available for marriage?
Entertainment.I really couldn't careless what someone's religion is but at the same time why work to make people regret a religion you left? @Kafir
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
My iman has nothing to do with your question. I simply said in an elaborate way that your question was dumb, because literally your questions get answered in the same verse you mentioned, and in the verses the brother showed you. You asked "why am I being punished for not following something I can't follow, because I've been covered with a veil?"Responses that are passages of the Quran either remaking the same statement or passages about how Allah is magnificent is not an answer to my question. Even in this thread after question your response about surah 6 verse 25 you responded by referencing the same verse again with zero elaboration.
Is this really the foundation of your iman? No wonder you mentioned having doubts multiple times. You need better reasons.
The verse clearly states that Allah is purposefully making it so that the unbelievers will not believe. The verse is telling you that there is no point to trying to convince unbelievers because Allah himself made them immune to believing. The verse goes on to say that because of their unbelief Allah is going to punish them. The verse is saying that Allah is going to punish unbelievers because of something he did.My iman has nothing to do with your question. I simply said in an elaborate way that your question was dumb, because literally your questions get answered in the same verse you mentioned, and in the verses the brother showed you. You asked "why am I being punished for not following something I can't follow, because I've been covered with a veil?"
I answered by telling you, you had many opportunities, but never listened, and you still have an opportunity but can't even see the answer when it's right in your face. Don't complicate something simple bro.
Everything adds up perfectly man. You're just not seeing the answer. Plus you totally forgot the previous verses before that talk about the 6 requirements a individual should uphold. You don't need to be a Muslim to uphold some of those requirements. Let me refresh your dying memory with verses you forgot to analyze.The verse clearly states that Allah is purposefully making it so that the unbelievers will not believe. The verse is telling you that there is no point to trying to convince unbelievers because Allah himself made them immune to believing. The verse goes on to say that because of their unbelief Allah is going to punish them. The verse is saying that Allah is going to punish unbelievers because of something he did.
Read that over and over again until it clicks. Notice how something doesn't add up?
(2:6) As for those who have rejected (these truths),9 it is all the same whether or not you warn them, for they will not believe.The verse clearly states that Allah is purposefully making it so that the unbelievers will not believe. The verse is telling you that there is no point to trying to convince unbelievers because Allah himself made them immune to believing. The verse goes on to say that because of their unbelief Allah is going to punish them. The verse is saying that Allah is going to punish unbelievers because of something he did.
Read that over and over again until it clicks. Notice how something doesn't add up?
Kut kudilIn order to say Allahu Akbar to that I would probably have to believe in Allah first. I want to know more about your belief in Allah.
U keep on saying that everyday. You are very sad and lonly manI'll do my part to ensure the rest of his descendants leave Islam. But don't want any other Somali to feel left out. I'll plant seeds of doubt in their minds too.
Beautifully said. Mashalla Alle fahamka haa kuu badiyo(2:6) As for those who have rejected (these truths),9 it is all the same whether or not you warn them, for they will not believe.
9. That is, those people who do not meet these six requirements, or reject all or any one of the fundamentals set out above.
(2:7) Allah has sealed their hearts10and their hearing, and a covering has fallen over their eyes. They deserve severe chastisement.
10. This does not mean that their rejection of the Truth is a consequence of God sealing their hearts. What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith, of their deliberate choice of a path divergent from that charted out by the Qur'an. Anyone who has worked for the dissemination of the Truth often finds that if, after full consideration, a person decides against a doctrine, his mind begins to move in a completely opposite direction so that he fails to appreciate anything that is explained to him. His ears become deaf, his eyes are blinded to the merits of that doctrine, and one gets the distinct impression that the person's heart has indeed been sealed.
What you are arguing here is that:Everything adds up perfectly man. You're just not seeing the answer. Plus you totally forgot the previous verses before that talk about the 6 requirements a individual should uphold. You don't need to be a Muslim to uphold some of those requirements. Let me refresh your dying memory with verses you forgot to analyze.
(2:3) for those who believe in the existence of that which is beyond the reach of perception,4 who establish Prayer5 and spend out of what We have provided them,6
4. This is the second prerequisite for deriving benefit from the Qur'an. Ghayb signifies the verities which are hidden from man's senses and which are beyond the scope of man's ordinary observation and experience, for example the existence and attributes of God, the angels. the process of revelation, Paradise, Hell and so on. 'Belief in the ghaib' means having faith in such matters, based on an absolute confidence in the Messengers of God and despite the fact that it is impossible to experience them.
According to this verse, Qur'anic guidance can prove helpful only to those prepared to affirm the truths of the suprasensory realm. People who make their belief in these questions conditional upon sensory perception of the object of belief, and who are not prepared even to consider the possibility of the existence of things that cannot be weighed or measured, cannot profit from this Book.
5. This is the third requirement. It is pointed out that those to whom belief means merely the pronouncement of a formula, who think that a mere verbal confession of faith is enough and that it makes no practical demands on them, can derive no guidance from the Qur'an. To benefit from the Qur'an it is essential that a man's decision to believe should be followed immediately by practical obedience to God.
Prayer is the first and continuing sign of practical obedience. No more than a few hours can pass after a man has embraced Islam than the mu'adhin calls to Prayer and it becomes evident whether or not the profession of faith has been genuine. Moreover, the mu'adhin calls to Prayer five times every day and whenever a man fails to respond to his call it becomes clear that he has transgressed the bounds of practical obedience. An abandonment of Prayer amounts to an abandonment of obedience. Obviously, if a man is not prepared to follow the directives of his guide, it is immaterial whether or not true guidance is available to him.
It should also be noted that the expression 'establishment of Prayer' has a wider meaning than mere performance of Prayer. It means that the system of Prayer should be organized on a collective basis. If there is a person in a locality who prays individually but no arrangements are made for congregational Prayer, it cannot be claimed that Prayer is established in that locality.
6. This, the fourth prerequisite for a person to benefit from the Qur'an, demands that the person concerned should neither be niggardly nor a worshipper of money. On the contrary, he should be willing to pay the claims on his property of both God and man, and should not flinch from making financial sacrifices for the sake of his convictions.
(2:4) who believe in what has been revealed to you and what was revealed before you,7 and have firm faith in the Hereafter.8
7. The fifth requirement is that one should believe in the Books revealed by God to His Prophets in the various ages and regions of the world, in the Book revealed to Muhammad (peace be on him) as well as in those revealed to the other Prophets who preceded him. The door of the Qur'an is closed to all those who do not consider it necessary for man to receive guidance from God. It is also closed to those who, even if they believe in the need for such guidance, do not consider it necessary to seek it through the channel of revelation and prophethood, but would rather weave their own set of ideas and concepts and regard them as equivalent to Divine Guidance.
This door is also closed to those who believe in Divine books as such, but confine this belief to those books accepted by their forefathers, and spurn Divine Guidance revealed to anyone born beyond their own racial and national boundaries. The Qur'an excludes all such people and is prepared to open the source of its grace only to those who believe that mankind does require Divine Guidance, who acknowledge that this guidance does not come to people individually but reaches them through Prophets and Divine Books and who are not given to racial or national chauvinism but are devotees of Truth alone, and are therefore prepared to submit to Divine Guidance wherever it be found.
8. Belief in the After-life is the sixth and last requirement. The term al-Akhirah embraces a whole set of ideas: (i) that man is not an irresponsible being, but is answerable to God for all his conduct in this world; (ii) that the present order of the world is not timeless, but will come to an end at an appointed hour known only to God; (iii) that when this world comes to an end God will bring into being another world in which He will resurrect, at one and the same moment, all the human beings ever born on earth. He will gather them together, examine their conduct and grant each one just reward for his actions; (iv) that those who are accounted good in God's judgement will be sent to Heaven, and those judged by Him as evil-doers will be consigned to Hell; (v) that the real measure of success and failure is not one's prosperity in the present life, but one's success or failure according to God's judgement in the Next. Those who do not accept this set of beliefs can derive no benefit from the Qur'an. For if a man is merely in a state of doubt and hesitation with regard to these matters - let alone disbelieving them - he cannot advance even one step forward along the path charted out by the Qur'an.
What you are arguing here is that:
People who are predisposed to believing the quran are the only ones who will believe the quran.
I could've told you that one. There's a problem with that. You shouldn't believe in something because you want to believe in it. You believe in something because there is compelling evidence to believe in it. Do you disagree with this?
Practical obedience should not come before belief.
Prayer should not come before belief.
You aren't going to obey the commands of the Quran before you believe the Quran is actually from a god. There is a similar application about prayers.
Believing in the stories of the old testament is mandatory to being convinced that the Quran is true? I see, so dawah only works on Christians and Jews?
This ultimately comes right back down to that same verse I quoted to you. Why is it that only the people who fit this description (some of them being nonsensical like obeying the Quran before believing in it) are the ones who Allah didn't purposefully prevent from believing. For instance let's say you as a Muslim want to convince an atheist to gain the attributes of a person who Allah isn't preventing from believing. Is this possible?
"If a person believes in the Quran then he must show obedience to the Quran" Please keep in mind that what we're talking about are the conditions required from a person so Allah isn't purposefully sealing their hearts and preventing them from believing. A Muslim will obey the Quran because they already believe in the Quran. We're talking about people who don't believe in the Quran. You're trying to tell me that they have to believe in the Quran first because that is one of the prerequisites so Allah isn't sealing their hearts."People who are predisposed to believing the quran are the only ones who will believe the quran."
This is false. Many ppl who have never heard of the Quran during there childhoods, or came from a non Muslim background are now Muslim due to understanding, and searching for the truth.
"I could've told you that one. There's a problem with that. You shouldn't believe in something because you want to believe in it. You believe in something because there is compelling evidence to believe in it. Do you disagree with this?"
No I don't disagree, and the Quran supports that. There is no compulsion to be in Islam if you don't want to. We all have free will, but the Quran itself is compelling evidence to believe. You haven't even asked a question that's compelling at all yet unfortunately.
"Practical obedience should not come before belief.
Prayer should not come before belief."
That's your subjective opinion. What does belief mean to you? If a person believes in the Quran then he must show obedience to the Quran, and believing, and prayer go together in Islam. You believe in Allah so you only worship, and pray to Allah. Again my brother don't complicate something so simple.
"You aren't going to obey the commands of the Quran before you believe the Quran is actually from a god. There is a similar application about prayers."
Basically you're just repeating what you said before.
"Believing in the stories of the old testament is mandatory to being convinced that the Quran is true? I see, so dawah only works on Christians and Jews?"
This is false. Many athiests, and agnostics have become Muslim. I used to be athiest, and am now Muslim. I don't think you fully read my last comment. Please go read it again.
"This ultimately comes right back down to that same verse I quoted to you. Why is it that only the people who fit this description (some of them being nonsensical like obeying the Quran before believing in it) are the ones who Allah didn't purposefully prevent from believing. For instance let's say you as a Muslim want to convince an atheist to gain the attributes of a person who Allah isn't preventing from believing. Is this possible?"
Again you missed my last comment addressing this. Allah gives you many opportunities, but you the individual who has free will choses to not believe anything given to you so you end up not even believing anything about the topic you wish to not believe in. This answered your question perfectly, but you didn't see, or choose to read it.
(2:7) Allah has sealed their hearts10and their hearing, and a covering has fallen over their eyes. They deserve severe chastisement.
10. This does not mean that their rejection of the Truth is a consequence of God sealing their hearts. What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith, of their deliberate choice of a path divergent from that charted out by the Qur'an. Anyone who has worked for the dissemination of the Truth often finds that if, after full consideration, a person decides against a doctrine, his mind begins to move in a completely opposite direction so that he fails to appreciate anything that is explained to him. His ears become deaf, his eyes are blinded to the merits of that doctrine, and one gets the distinct impression that the person's heart has indeed been sealed.
You are misunderstanding the verse as you haven't read the Tafsir on it.The simplest explanation is that your heart is like a flat sheet , as the sins you partake in the sins cover the heart.At a certain point your whole heart is covered with this sin , at this point the heart is sealed by Allah.For such people Once they reject islam,The verse clearly states that Allah is purposefully making it so that the unbelievers will not believe. The verse is telling you that there is no point to trying to convince unbelievers because Allah himself made them immune to believing. The verse goes on to say that because of their unbelief Allah is going to punish them. The verse is saying that Allah is going to punish unbelievers because of something he did.
Read that over and over again until it clicks. Notice how something doesn't add up?
"Please keep in mind that what we're talking about are the conditions required from a person so Allah isn't purposefully sealing their hearts and preventing them from believing. A Muslim will obey the Quran because they already believe in the Quran. We're talking about people who don't believe in the Quran. You're trying to tell me that they have to believe in the Quran first because that is one of the prerequisites so Allah isn't sealing their hearts.""If a person believes in the Quran then he must show obedience to the Quran" Please keep in mind that what we're talking about are the conditions required from a person so Allah isn't purposefully sealing their hearts and preventing them from believing. A Muslim will obey the Quran because they already believe in the Quran. We're talking about people who don't believe in the Quran. You're trying to tell me that they have to believe in the Quran first because that is one of the prerequisites so Allah isn't sealing their hearts.
Belief in the Quran -----> Obeying the Quran --------> Allah not sealing their hearts ------> Belief in the Quran.
Notice the flaw in that chart?
"This is false. Many athiests, and agnostics have become Muslim?"
According to your prerequisites you need to believe in the stories of the old testament before Allah stops sealing your heart from believing. Or at the very least believe in the "revelations" before Muhammad. An atheist does not fit that description. As a result according to you an atheist has their heart sealed and prevented from believing.
f*ck off
Why you so brave for all of a
"What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith""Please keep in mind that what we're talking about are the conditions required from a person so Allah isn't purposefully sealing their hearts and preventing them from believing. A Muslim will obey the Quran because they already believe in the Quran. We're talking about people who don't believe in the Quran. You're trying to tell me that they have to believe in the Quran first because that is one of the prerequisites so Allah isn't sealing their hearts."
Again you seem to be over complicating, and not reading what I post. Please read this, because you keep repeating yourself.
(2:7) Allah has sealed their hearts10and their hearing, and a covering has fallen over their eyes. They deserve severe chastisement.
10. This does not mean that their rejection of the Truth is a consequence of God sealing their hearts. What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith, of their deliberate choice of a path divergent from that charted out by the Qur'an. Anyone who has worked for the dissemination of the Truth often finds that if, after full consideration, a person decides against a doctrine, his mind begins to move in a completely opposite direction so that he fails to appreciate anything that is explained to him. His ears become deaf, his eyes are blinded to the merits of that doctrine, and one gets the distinct impression that the person's heart has indeed been sealed.
"According to your prerequisites you need to believe in the stories of the old testament before Allah stops sealing your heart from believing. Or at the very least believe in the "revelations" before Muhammad. An atheist does not fit that description. As a result according to you an atheist has their heart sealed and prevented from believing."
Yes, and no. Many non Muslims including athiest meet some of the requirements. Many athiests have become Muslim, and this is a fact. They had no knowledge of the Quran before they became Muslim, and once they read it, they decided for themselves to become Muslim. I think you're confusing yourself. I explained to you the verse that made you ask this question, but you seem to be ignoring it. Why is that?
"The fundamentals you're describing was the list of 6 prerequisites needed in order for Allah not to seal a person's heart. Or as you describe those who don't have these 6 prerequisites have their hearts sealed by Allah.""What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith"
The fundamentals you're describing was the list of 6 prerequisites needed in order for Allah not to seal a person's heart. Or as you describe those who don't have these 6 prerequisites have their hearts sealed by Allah.
What does it mean for Allah to seal their hearts?
This quote from you "What is meant is that God sealed their hearts and ears as a consequence of their decision to reject the fundamentals of faith" doesn't answer "what" it answers "why". You're telling me "why" their hearts are sealed rather than saying the implication of a sealed heart.
The most obvious and direct interpretation about what the sealed heart means is that it prevents them from believing. This interpretation is supported by the next verse which says whether your warn them or not they won't believe. This makes it pretty clear what a sealed heart means. Or was the Quran not clear enough? The verse talks about a direct action taken by Allah himself. If the unbelievers inability to believe was purely out of their own actions, there would be no need for Allah to be sealing a heart.
Among the list of 6 prerequisites you mentioned were obeying Allah. Obeying Allah means what exactly? How does a person know what Allah wants? What Allah wants is supposedly in the Quran. Meaning that a person needs to obey the Quran before they meet one of the 6 prerequisites needed for their hearts not to be sealed. If their hearts are not sealed they can believe. If it's not necessary, then don't call it a requirement.
You also mentioned that despite only meeting some of the requirements there have been atheists who were able to believe in the Quran. Since when is meeting only some of the requirements sufficient? The chapter lists the qualities of the people who find the book useful. The people who don't have those qualities have their hearts sealed. Only Muslims will have those qualities. Only Muslims will not have their hearts sealed.