Would a human clone have a soul?

[sigmund]

I wish NOT to participate in this discussion

kk why does it scare you

 

[Apollo]

clones from lab for example let's say i die and wanted to be cloned. How are they going to clone my soul since I'm already dead? that clone is artificial

Most of the neuroscientists are atheists and believe that when you die you are basically gone forever.

 

[Xasusi]

you don't know anything about cloning this thread ain't for you man

My friend, tell me how a clone is made.

 

[Abdi Caato]

Hadith of the Prophet (ﷺ):

Verily the creation of each one of you is brought together in his mother’s womb for forty days in the form of a nutfah (a drop), then he becomes an alaqah (clot of blood) for a like period, then a mudghah (morsel of flesh) for a like period, then there is sent to him the angel who blows his soul into him...

https://sunnah.com/nawawi40/4

soul cannot be "cloned"

 

[sigmund]

Most of the neuroscientists are atheists and believe that when you die you are basically gone forever.

yeah I know but in your opinion does a clone have a soul of a human being or are they soulless beings

 

[Apollo]

yeah I know but in your opinion does a clone have a soul of a human being or are they soulless beings

IMO, they are the exact same person who just experience different events. So if their soul is inherently evil, it will be evil again, if it is wholesome/good it will be like that again.

 

[sigmund]

My friend, tell me how a clone is made.

you joined in 2019 sorry but I'm above newbies to reply back and waste my time na dhaff

 

[sigmund]

Hadith of the Prophet (ﷺ):


https://sunnah.com/nawawi40/4

soul cannot be "cloned"

can you tell that to the weirdos on this thread that think I'm stupid for believing we can't clone souls

 

[Guled111]

cloning is from shaytan he is there to deceive people into believing clones have souls when only Allah can produce a soul. Is an evil invention that's secretly occurring

The souls are actually jins working for him, so there's the answer

 

[sigmund]

The souls are actually jins working for him, so there's the answer

that makes more sense since it is after all shaytan works

[Quran 4:120] He promises them and entices them; what the devil promises is no more than an illusion.

 

[Abdi Caato]

can you tell that to the weirdos on this thread that think I'm stupid for believing we can't clone souls

I know that amazing progress has been made in stem cell research

but what is the evidence that scientists are producing sentient & conscious clones?

 

[sigmund]

I know that amazing progress has been made in stem cell research

but what is the evidence that scientists are producing sentient & conscious clones?

a whistle blower came out https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/ciencia/ciencia_artificialhumans01.htm

 

[Guled111]

that makes more sense since it is after all shaytan works

[Quran 4:120] He promises them and entices them; what the devil promises is no more than an illusion.

I believe you got the answer now

 

[sigmund]

I believe you got the answer now

I don't understand why people believe human clones that are made from a lab using someone elses DNA from the past can have a soul.

 

[Toriye]

This assumes that souls exist, which they definitely do not. A human clone of yourself would just be a very confused you or a clean slate version of you ( because you can't duplicate memories) If it was possible to somehow duplicate memories, a clone would be an exact duplicate capable of replacing you with no problem.

 

[Guled111]

I don't understand why people believe human clones that are made from a lab using someone elses DNA from the past can have a soul.

LOL the is no real soul but the jinn inside the body, who takes orders from Thier boss aka shaitaan

 

[Exodus]

If cloning a human is done in this century, it won't be in the West. Far too many ethical/religious laws that prevent it from being pursued seriously. It would probably be done somewhere in China, but it would be difficult to confirm the validity of any "successful experiments".

I do believe Cloning is very possible to achieve, however.

 

[Toriye]

If cloning a human is done in this century, it won't be in the West. Far too many ethical/religious laws that prevent it from being pursued seriously. It would probably be done somewhere in China, but it would be difficult to confirm the validity of any "successful experiments".

I do believe Cloning is very possible to achieve, however.

That is too naive because governments are an exception to the rule and no one can police them. Besides, the question was whether a clone would have a soul or not

 

[Exodus]

That is too naive because governments are an exception to the rule and no one can police them. Besides, the question was whether a clone would have a soul or not

You underestimate the influence of the people, a genuine attempt to clone a human would not only break international laws but would gain the condemnation of every religious institution on the planet. And what would happen if they failed? The amount of backlash would be crazy, this is genuinely the only reason why the Strongest nations in the world don't pursue Cloning.

To answer your question, however, I think it will have a soul as it's the exact same as the person with the original "soul".

 

[PhySom]

No such thing as a soul.