Why is puntland the most Prosperous state in Somalia?

[repo]

Sincity is triggered and I love it

some early data from the new report

View attachment 147216

man I love this report already I can’t wait to see the full thing. Brokeland with its hyper inflation will finally get exposed

The fact that $1 = 45k pirate shillings is further proof PL economy is all the way in the qashin

You love it already cause you are not intelligent enough to comprehend it.

"Despite methodological innovations, field team training, and a stringent security protocol (section 3.2), some challenges with data collection persisted in certain geographic areas. These were mainly related to human resource capacity constraints and remote monitoring to ensure the quality of the data. Specifically, in the Jubbaland and rural North‐East regions, the information collected turned out to be only representative of a very small, idiosyncratic part of the population or did not consistently meet the survey’s high‐quality standards."

 

[Baboon]

Not at all, the study you posted is not successor to the comprehensive Somali Poverty Profile 2017. It's one that didn't provide enough sufficient or reliable data. If you bothered reading it;

"Despite methodological innovations, field team training, and a stringent security protocol (section 3.2), some challenges with data collection persisted in certain geographic areas. These were mainly related to human resource capacity constraints and remote monitoring to ensure the quality of the data. Specifically, in the Jubbaland and rural North‐East regions, the information collected turned out to be only representative of a very small, idiosyncratic part of the population or did not consistently meet the survey’s high‐quality standards."


Even with his comeback he is shooting himself in the foot, they couldn’t get enough data because their region is remote, dangerous and is void of capable Human Resources.

 

[repo]

Not at all, the study you posted is not successor to the comprehensive Somali Poverty Profile 2017. It's one that didn't provide enough sufficient or reliable data. If you bothered reading it;

"Despite methodological innovations, field team training, and a stringent security protocol (section 3.2), some challenges with data collection persisted in certain geographic areas. These were mainly related to human resource capacity constraints and remote monitoring to ensure the quality of the data. Specifically, in the Jubbaland and rural North‐East regions, the information collected turned out to be only representative of a very small, idiosyncratic part of the population or did not consistently meet the survey’s high‐quality standards."


Even with his comeback he is shooting himself in the foot, they couldn’t get enough data because their region is remote, dangerous and is void of capable Human Resources.

No. They were actually careful given that the results defied their expectations:

"The results from Wave 1 of the SHFS indicate that the North East region has lower poverty incidence that in the other surveyed pre-war regions. Contrary to this finding, anecdotal evidence and expert assessments raised the expectation that Somalis in North East regions would be among the poorer parts of the population. Thus, the findings presented in this report related to North East have been analyzed particularly carefully to assess their validity in a number of ways."

To ensure that findings are not artificial due to some idiosyncrasies of the data collection in North East, scrutiny was directed at whether low poverty incidence was driven by (i) consumption quantity per core item, (ii) the number of core items consumed, or (iii) prices. Households in NorthEast consume a higher quantity per capita per item (13 percent more than the overall average) and more items per household (9 percent more than average; Table B.1).

No notable price trends emerged, as prices for food items are deflated. In addition, household consumption profiles of North East, North West, and Mogadishu in terms of the most consumed items, both by quantity and value, are similar (Table B.2). Lower poverty incidence further does not seem to be driven by household size, as the average household size in North East is 5.2, compared to 5.7 in North West and 4.5 in Mogadishu (Table B.1). Finally, the rate of replacement of enumeration areas (due to inaccessibility, missing structures or security) is similar in all three regions (Table B.1). Overall, then, North East’s lower poverty incidence appears to be the result of genuinely higher recorded consumption. "

I wish one of you at least had the ability to understand what you are reading, it could have been interesting.

 

[FBIsomalia]

This is an outdated 2017 study. The new 2019 World Bank study presents an entirely different picture. Puntland has one of the worse poverty profiles in the Horn:

View attachment 147203



"Poverty is also heterogeneous across space. Based on estimates from satellite imputation, the highest levels of poverty are clustered in south‐western Somalia, and several districts in northern Somalia (Figure 7)."

Beyond topping the poverty charts, lack of population density was another area of concern for Puntland. Owing to its barren landscape and suboptimal climate, population density in Puntland is one of the lowest in the entire region:

View attachment 147204

View attachment 147205

Puntland's high incidence of poverty is described by climate & arid landscape + lack of resources + lack of population density, a trifecta ensuring the region remains poor. Some of the indicators published in the study include:

Distance to cultivated areas, Puntland (North-East zone) performs worst:

View attachment 147206

Average annual precipitation, where Puntland was also dealt a shit card:

View attachment 147207

Distance to major roads, this one is understandable, with lack of population density, building major roads and connecting settlements becomes much more expensive:

View attachment 147208

Study link:

http://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/509221549985694077/pdf/WPS8735.pdf

Most are IDP.

 

[Mr.Haggis]

Bosaso is one of the safest cities in Puntland

Check this video

 

[Mr.Haggis]

It used to be dangerous.

 

[Manafesto]

It used to be dangerous.

Stop lying waryaa,one of the most peaceful cities in the country with the least conflicts, aren't you half Scottish half Puntite,stop spreading misinformation on your commercial capital neef yahow daaqa.

 

[Yukon_Niner]

Stop lying waryaa,one of the most peaceful cities in the country with the least conflicts, aren't you half Scottish half Puntite,stop spreading misinformation on your commercial capital neef yahow daaqa.

Puntland is where pirate's emerged from ninyahow, in what universe is that place safe?

The only place in Somalia classed as even visitable is Hargeisa

 

[Shmurda]

Puntland is where pirate's emerged from ninyahow, in what universe is that place safe?

The only place in Somalia classed as even visitable is Hargeisa

Bosaso has a lot of cadaan tourists that walk around no security

 

[Yukon_Niner]

Bosaso has a lot of cadaan tourists that walk around no security

Saaxiib cadaan people have shot videos in SL with locals and have even given random cadaan bloggers presidential welcomes, what in god's name makes you think you can compete with them?

 

[Calaf]

Saaxiib cadaan people have shot videos in SL with locals and have even given random cadaan bloggers presidential welcomes, what in god's name makes you think you can compete with them?

Not the best thing to boast about..........