Steamdevelopment the most unionist wadani Sspotter

Status
Not open for further replies.

black

live and let die.
I see it as a necessary evil but I'd prefer the Kenyan model of county government and a national government.

I think the Kenyan model work better (This will be the only time you will see me praise them) for three main reasons:

1: It affords the local governance desperate required by Somalis who still have reservation about a over-reaching central government

2: But it avoids the problems that come with Federal states. Federal states are so large that they can be a compete power with a central government and the boundary between Federal government and Federal states is blurry.

3: Allocation of ressource would be more straight-forward and it combines already existing mayor or local governance into an integrated model and would be easier to administrator.

What about you @black?

In an ideal world a unitary government. I think Somalia should aspire for functional federalism, but right now I support the full autonomy of Somaliland and Puntland. TFG cannot be trusted with centralised power, nor can they be expected to resolve local problems. Not to mention we're transitioning from the qabil system which is inherently divisive.
 
In an ideal world a unitary government. I think Somalia should aspire for functional federalism, but right now I support the full autonomy of Somaliland and Puntland. TFG cannot be trusted with centralised power, nor can they be expected to resolve local problems. Not to mention we're transitioning from the qabil system which is inherently divisive.

Disagree, full autonomy usually increases qabil division as every qabil want their own state.

You can't expect a miracle to happen all parts of Somalia has to come together or will eternally be at the bottom.
 

black

live and let die.
Disagree, full autonomy usually increases qabil division as every qabil want their own state.

You can't expect a miracle to happen all parts of Somalia has to come together or will eternally be at the bottom.

That's because the TFG, Somaliland and Puntland are all incompetent governments. 0+0+0
 
That's because the TFG, Somaliland and Puntland are all incompetent governments. 0+0+0

Agreed but a competetion over the crumbs instead of building on the cake leaves us all poor, we've had 26 years with qabil rule and it has left us without a prideful place in the world.

That needs to change and we need to begin trust and pool power beyond clan borders.
 

black

live and let die.
Agreed but a competetion over the crumbs instead of building on the cake leaves us all poor, we've had 26 years with qabil rule and it has left us without a prideful place in the world.

That needs to change and we need to begin trust and pool power beyond clan borders.

What exactly has the federal government provided to merit its authority over a region it can't or care for? We aren't competing for resources, we're competing for aid which doesn't often get past Mogadishu, and to a similar extent regional authorities. With an incompetent federal government, each region should focus on developing itself and make use of local resources. It makes no sense to shoot yourself in the foot like that.
 

Gibiin-Udug

Crowned Queen of Puntland. Supporter of PuntExit
She's a troll. You don't know where she's going and coming from. She's condemning SFG one day and then praising it the other day.


I believe Puntites are wadanis of Puntland.

Viva la Puntland.
 
She's a troll. You don't know where she's going and coming from. She's condemning SFG one day and then praising it the other day.


I believe Puntites are wadanis of Puntland.

Viva la Puntland.

Maybe one day you will understand

9598172551253890.jpg
 

felloff

FA'CASH GANG BABY
somalia-map2.gif

Somalia should of been like this Devolution of government not federalization Inshallah Jumriyada Somaliland should build upon its orginal 18 administrative regions and not become federalist like its neighbor Somalia even establishing cantons is a better option than the 4 current federal stats of somalia
 
Gotta take medications somalia/somaliland is doomed the diaspora might aswell raise money and buy the countries
brother i know what you mean:mjcry: I myself sometimes want puntland to secede from somalia, every time HG attacks puntland:kanyehmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trending

Top