Should Sex Work Should Be "Decriminalized"?

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

Warning: Political Thread and in the West (United States) this is one of the topics at hand with the Democrats and Republicans.

As long as they're consenting adults, I say go for it. I'd want them to try to get out of it and get into a lucrative career/trade. The U.S. and Canadian government should make a way out for them.

As adults, we all have choices. I'd never get into sex work however.

Some women do it for liberation.

P.S. I'm NEITHER condoning or dismissive of it. Just being objective and understanding.

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

Also, most of these workers are down to Earth when in dialogue with them. We don't have to agree with their choices. Anyway, let's keep this thread PG-13.

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

P.S. strippers count as sex work.

 

[Internet Nomad]

No, it's a very exploitative business, and if I had to advise from a nonreligious perspective, I'd say don't criminalize it because that would only drive the women who are doing it underground and increase the danger to themselves. But if it were to spread throughout the nation, I would want it to be tightly controlled.

Everyone is aware of the theological perspective on this, of course.

 

[Keep it a boqol]

FOOOOOCK NO. This is a Reddit level brain take. The idea that consent in itself is an virtue and morally good is what’s brainwashed and pushed on to us as a society. @JudgeJoeGorilla do you also support only fans? Would you let your daughter do it? After all it’s her choice

“Yeah bro sell your pu$$y for cash! fight the patriarchy! #freethenip

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

No, it's a very exploitative business, and if I had to advise from a nonreligious perspective, I'd say don't criminalize it because that would only drive the women who are doing it underground and increase the danger to themselves. But if it were to spread throughout the nation, I would want it to be tightly controlled.

Everyone is aware of the theological perspective on this, of course.

That's what decriminalization means bro. Not making it legal, but not sending people to jail for it either. Like I said, the government needs to work with businesses to create more apprenticeships for Sex Workers. They could be useful in a skilled industry, like tech or healthcare. This is after they get therapy.

 

[Waa dhamatay]

I wonder what opinions a 99% Muslim forum would have to offer on this topic.

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

I wonder what opinions a 99% Muslim forum would have to offer on this topic.

There's also Non-Muslims on here and Muslims who vary in view. For example, Moderate and Liberal Muslims.

 

[Hilmaam]

Penalize the guys and pimps. The women are harmless and desperate. Don’t waste jail or court time. The guys buying should get heavy fines and names in paper . Pimps throw book at them

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

Penalize the guys and pimps. The women are harmless and desperate. Don’t waste jail or court time. The guys buying should get heavy fines and names in paper . Pimps throw book at them

The guys buying I say let them buy. However, Pimps should receive a penalty. The Johns are just buying because maybe they are lacking a sex life. As long as everyone is legal, then I see no issue.

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

FOOOOOCK NO. This is a Reddit level brain take. The idea that consent in itself is an virtue and morally good is what’s brainwashed and pushed on to us as a society. @JudgeJoeGorilla do you also support only fans? Would you let your daughter do it? After all it’s her choice

“Yeah bro sell your pu$$y for cash! fight the patriarchy! #freethenip

View attachment 259102

I don't have kids, and yes I have no issues with Onlyfans.

 

[Hilmaam]

The guys buying I say let them buy. However, Pimps should receive a penalty. The Johns are just buying because maybe they are lacking a sex life. As long as everyone is legal, then I see no issue.

I don’t know bro, if society just okays it I feel its morals decay and disease will be rampant

 

[Keep it a boqol]

I don't have kids, and yes I have no issues with Onlyfans.

You’d let your children, sister and wife do work and only fans ?

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

I don’t know bro, if society just okays it I feel its morals decay and disease will be rampant

These are a minority of people. Most of American society goes to work everyday. Also, freedom of choice with the U.S. Constitution (Freedom of Religion).

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

You’d let your children, sister and wife do work and only fans ?

I have no siblings. Also, I'm not married, so these hypotheticals don't work here.

 

[Internet Nomad]

That's what decriminalization means bro. Not making it legal, but not sending people to jail for it either. Like I said, the government needs to work with businesses to create more apprenticeships for Sex Workers. They could be useful in a skilled industry, like tech or healthcare. This is after they get therapy.

Exactly try to get them out of the field. Many people enter the workforce because of abuse or poverty.

 

[Internet Nomad]

FOOOOOCK NO. This is a Reddit level brain take. The idea that consent in itself is an virtue and morally good is what’s brainwashed and pushed on to us as a society. @JudgeJoeGorilla do you also support only fans? Would you let your daughter do it? After all it’s her choice

“Yeah bro sell your pu$$y for cash! fight the patriarchy! #freethenip

View attachment 259102

Consent is a virtue. You cant have consent without having seggs or it would be classified as grape.

 

[GaradShabeel]

In my opinion, s*x work should not be seen as regular work. You simply can not buy someone, even for a x amount of time to use them and change to another term to justify it. Even if it's "consensual", it's still exploitation, as simple as that.

Your moral/ethical judgement, should stand beyond what law and constitution permits you.

 

[Khaemwaset]

I liked where the whole consent thing was bringing us, however sex work should not be legal but I also think that the desperate women in these industries should not be the ones facing jail as they are exploited.
The guys who buy and pimp these girls should face the law and sex work should be cracked down on as it is a sign of moral decay and lures in young poor and gullible women into selling their bodies.

I am not politically active but the type of shit liberals say when It comes to anything regarding sex and gender is absolutely mind boggling. Consent isn't an excuse to pay the 18 yrs old girls down the street for a one night stand, that is a morally degraded society that no longer values sex.

I'm not gonna take the holier than thou stance so If you wanna have fun with girls then go literally anywhere people socialise and meet someone. But don't go around paying for sex like a hopeless incel

 

[JudgeJoeGorilla]

Exactly try to get them out of the field. Many people enter the workforce because of abuse or poverty.

Exactly. Like I said, they need to be placed in an apprenticeship or community college for healthcare like Nursing or something in the field if not tech.