Faahiye
Male Male Male Male
Yes exactly
Revenue generated by A grade districts in Somaliland region
- Thread starter Bohol
- Start date
Bohol
VIP
Sacad muse gave kulmiye 130k votes in maroodijeex alone. Waddani got 100k votes in sanaag saaxil and togdheer. The only district they live in hargeisa is gacan libaax were they have the neighbourhood of new hargeisa. Gacan libaax half the vote went to kulmiye. The other half went wadani which was the gabooye and HY vote put together. Let’s give the whole gabooye vote to HY for arguments sake. Waddani got 10k votes in that district. So the HY vote was 110k. Vs sacad muse vote of 130.
No they’re not they’re taxed at burco.
Younes Osman
VIP
I see wadani as a party who is anti HA and HJ. But, somewhat pander towards Arup and HY along with minority non isaaq qabils
HY are completely non stratigic. They promised arap they will hand over the xisbi to them but have now refused. Arab are going to find new pastures and may even be the next kulmiye candidate. HA nor HJ would have stood in there way for the next election however unless they somehow sack everyone at wadani and get new leadership at wadani they will never be in charge.
Bohol
VIP
Yes but the exports are taxed in Berbera. So a lot of the revenue Berbera gets is due to livestock that comes from Burco and elsewhere. If the livestock was exported through Bosaso port for example there would be a big dent in the Berbera annual revenue since the only thing Somaliland region exports is livestock.
Younes Osman
VIP
If I was reer SL I would vote ucid. you know back in 05 when I look back, there were quite a lot of HA were voting ucid because of the vice president was issa musa. what do you think ?
I’ve never really cared. They’re all the same. The wasirs get recycled the only time I’ve ever been against a political party is wadani with how they’ve behaved post muse bixi election. Before that I couldn’t care less if wadani won what difference does it make.
You’ve lost your head. Somaliland or any regional gov doesn’t make money hand over fist for for live stock export. The owners of the livestock make the money. Taxing 10 to 15 markaab or however many it is not that much. Berbera makes the overwhelming majority from the daily container ships that bring everything from clothes to rice.
And who’s going to export from bosaso what gain is that for the individual to export from a far away port? If you’re insinuating HY it would not even make a dent to SL or berbera
And why should ReeR Burco opt for giving money to PL. When they have the power to kick out their local gov and request development. Look what the berbera mayor did for his town & the Laascaanood mayor for his. All the other SL mayor's are useless -Somaliland is further decentralising where the local gov and gobol governor matter more than HGA
Younes Osman
VIP
especially hargeysa mayor "a cat is much safer in hargeysa than in xamar"
That's why they don't want elections to happen - they wanna keep on stealing & you have a diaspora with no political knowledge or experience
Younes Osman
VIP
true its like me who has chachub af somali and becoming the governor of Togdheer. I would need an translator and a person that can sign as well when doing speeches.
That's pretty funny. The secessionists scream about free market on here but the people they cheerlead are closing the customs closest to the hawd where most livestock comes from. That allows some clans can have monopoly on tax collection which means they will get most spending for their district.
It's a nice scam, I will give the Jeegaans that.
It's a nice scam, I will give the Jeegaans that.
That's spreadsheet, they didn't provide their mechanism and formula. I doubt it's even true or else like anything they will show how they collect taxes, number of vehicle and types of vehicles, taxation rate, number of small shop traders, land rates and construction rates for a month, small or medium size company rates. I doubt there is even a company that employs more then 200 workers in SL, so I can work out the 'maximum' tax rate on the companies. Somalis don't know a govt cannot survive on businesses in Somalia or else hamar wouldnt cry for budget support, why? no livestock goes there
There is no tax revenue in 'cities' or 'villages' which is why @Samaalism method of comparing towns is silly, when the whole state revenue is based on 'miyi' meaning this is where the population is. If u took away the 'port' and 'livestock', u essentially took away Somaliland, so using towns/cities as 'gouging' mechanism doesn't work when it can be proven your state collapses without nomads.
There is no tax revenue in 'cities' or 'villages' which is why @Samaalism method of comparing towns is silly, when the whole state revenue is based on 'miyi' meaning this is where the population is. If u took away the 'port' and 'livestock', u essentially took away Somaliland, so using towns/cities as 'gouging' mechanism doesn't work when it can be proven your state collapses without nomads.
If u took away telecoms, water, electricity companies. Your down to businesses with 'small segments' and 'small items' except maybe very few 'shops' with high end items 'phones, laptops' even then those r prolly 'chinese' knock offs and not big money maker. Then you have unemployment rate which is so high, to expect businesses to be rich in Somalia isn't realistic at all if you don't see the environment is like ' soweto' south africa, yeah u can be 'soweto' king but once u step in the r eal world of orders and structures u aint the s ame as bill fuckin gates nigga. Structures/Orders means your business become 'empires' where-as 'soweto' markets live in their own 'third world market' place and somalia is IDENTICAL. A soweto is created due to lack of govt intervention.
Somalia is soweto cause it's got no REAL govt due to political instability which won't allow for a govt to form so the black market continues it's not REAL MARKET that is ' structured and ordered' with currencies managed using best practises, Private banks operating loans to locals to become entrepeneurs, taxes invested into 'infrastructure' to support growth, economists identifying how to segment it's ppl working of 'data' and yearly rolling out a 'segment' of it's population into 'high skilled industries' to generate customer wealth, leading academia institutions focused on innovation and creating 'patents' to sell world wide. U need structure n orders for that shit to happen, without it, your really just in black market not REAL MARKET. U can't create a market that is sophisticated and strong without a government in control of the land, people, territory, and stable governance and strong law n order nigga and your civilians COOPERATING and following GOVT instructions. Somalis hate following govt so the other option is VACUUM since they never have an ALTERNATIVE system soo ma arag, it's not just them it's all LOW IQ nations who are l ike that
Somalia is soweto cause it's got no REAL govt due to political instability which won't allow for a govt to form so the black market continues it's not REAL MARKET that is ' structured and ordered' with currencies managed using best practises, Private banks operating loans to locals to become entrepeneurs, taxes invested into 'infrastructure' to support growth, economists identifying how to segment it's ppl working of 'data' and yearly rolling out a 'segment' of it's population into 'high skilled industries' to generate customer wealth, leading academia institutions focused on innovation and creating 'patents' to sell world wide. U need structure n orders for that shit to happen, without it, your really just in black market not REAL MARKET. U can't create a market that is sophisticated and strong without a government in control of the land, people, territory, and stable governance and strong law n order nigga and your civilians COOPERATING and following GOVT instructions. Somalis hate following govt so the other option is VACUUM since they never have an ALTERNATIVE system soo ma arag, it's not just them it's all LOW IQ nations who are l ike that
Buhoodle under PL iyo Tukraaq has no border. Stop adding false information kid
.
Bohol
VIP
Don't talk out of your ass and embarrass yourself. Most livestock (camels) from Haud and Sland is owned by HY.
HY camels - 270,000
Entire Habar Awal camels - 125,000 plus your Cisse Muse cousins who only owned 15,000
Livestock within British Somaliland protectorate 1944
Trending
-
Faarax from UK moves to Hargeisa and says hes never going back- Started by TekNiKo
- Replies: 64
-
Can AI tell that you’re Somali? Check your phenotype here- Started by empressjamila
- Replies: 131
-
Somali woman stops paying rent to her timojileec landlord, she owes 41 THOUSAND and he can’t evict her lol!
- Started by empressjamila
- Replies: 28
