Muslim man who beat his wife says he didn't know it was against the law

[I've spoken]

So lemme get this straight If a woman hit a man , he has NO right to defend himself ..... yeah i sound so irrational call the police.

And the statistics of men and domestic violence was me also being irrational i'm guessing.

I'm not excusing domestic violence , i think its vile and abhorrent but when push comes to shove it shouldn't be called men abusing women but a man defending himself.

Quran (4:34) - "Men are the maintainers of women because Allah has made some of them to excel others and because they spend out of their property; the good women are therefore obedient, guarding the unseen as Allah has guarded; and (as to) those on whose part you fear desertion, admonish them, and leave them alone in the sleeping-places and beat them; then if they obey you, do not seek a way against them; surely Allah is High, Great."
Abu Dawud (2142) - "The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: A man will not be asked as to why he beat his wife."

Rethink what it is you're defending walal

 

[Genie]

Quran (4:34) - "Men are the maintainers of women because Allah has made some of them to excel others and because they spend out of their property; the good women are therefore obedient, guarding the unseen as Allah has guarded; and (as to) those on whose part you fear desertion, admonish them, and leave them alone in the sleeping-places and beat them; then if they obey you, do not seek a way against them; surely Allah is High, Great."
Abu Dawud (2142) - "The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: A man will not be asked as to why he beat his wife."

Rethink what it is you're defending walal

Have you ever wondered why we need Intellects well versed in Islam otherwise i can isolate certain verses without knowing the timeline and historical event that verse was revealed hence why ISIS can quote the qur'an to further their motives they can scout verses revealed during the battle of badr and Uhud they isolate them and proceed to take them out of context to avoid this we have schools of Islam.
I spoke using my own opinion ,scholars say otherwise i'm not defending it but the Qur'an is a divine scripture i see it in a different perspective than you.

I repeat my last point in all instances hitting her is a last resort , hence why when the verse was revealed hitting your wife was mentioned last among other forms of (non physical) punishment i see this as fair judgment (for god is all wise and all knowing) you see it otherwise and thats fine.

 

[ItsHanna]

Deport that animal.

 

[I've spoken]

Have you ever wondered why we need Intellects well versed in Islam otherwise i can isolate certain verses without knowing the timeline and historical event that verse was revealed hence why ISIS can quote the qur'an to further their motives they can scout verses revealed during the battle of badr and Uhud they isolate them and proceed to aka rhyme out of context to avoid this we have schools of Islam.
I spoke using my own opinion ,scholars say otherwise i'm not defending it but the Qur'an is a divine scripture i see it in a different perspective than you.

I repeat my last point in all instances hitting her is a last resort , hence why when the verse was revealed hitting your wife was mentioned last among other forms of (non physical) punishment i see this as fair judgment (for god is all wise and all knowing) you see it otherwise and thats fine.

I'm gonna be honest with you and tell you that I feel like you're too far in, I feel like everything I say will fall on deaf ears. Ima just leave you be and hope one day before you waste your one life away you wake up and realize Islam is just like the other religions. All fake. And that the only reason you believe islam is different/the truth is because you happen to be born into it by pure chance. I wish you nothing but the best walal

 

[Genie]

I'm gonna be honest with you and tell you that I feel like you're too far in, I feel like everything I say will fall on deaf ears. Ima just leave you be and hope one day before you waste your one life away you wake up and realize Islam is just like the other religions. All fake. And that the only reason you believe islam is different/the truth is because you happen to be born into it by pure chance. I wish you nothing but the best walal

Lol , whats funny is that i was contemplating on not replying to your previous comment because i was thinking he is too far gone no point he won't understand, but listen i wish the best for you too , have a good life make this world your paradise at the very least.

 

[I've spoken]

Lol , whats funny is that i was contemplating on not replying to your previous comment because i was thinking he is too far gone no point he won't understand, but listen i wish the best for you too , have a good life make this world your paradise at the very least.

Because an eternity of hellfire is awaiting me right? Ah the merciful Allah. It's funny how we're on 2 ends of the rope, each 100% convinced the other is wrong.

But the thing is I've been where you are, I too believed 100% at one time. It's just that I kept an open mind and looked at both sides of the argument. I didnt believe simply because I was raised to. At the end of the day,it's every man for himself.

 

[Genie]

Because an eternity of hellfire is awaiting me right? Ah the merciful Allah. It's funny how we're on 2 ends of the rope, each 100% convinced the other is wrong.

But the thing is I've been where you are, I too believed 100% at one time. It's just that I kept an open mind and looked at both sides of the argument. I didnt believe simply because I was raised to. At the end of the day,it's every man for himself.

If you knew anything about us muslim you would knows its forbidden to say one is 100% going to hell or one is 100% going to heaven.
And yes i'am very open minded and will continue to look into and study Islam and other world views as best as i can , I'm a critical thinker and i ask a lot of whys? none the less i'm still a muslim. If i change my mind you'll be the first to know.

Quick note , all merciful doesn't mean you deserve that mercy,
Gods mercy is fair and just for example Netanyahu cannot ask for nor receive the same mercy as say a poor fishermen working in Vietnam or something... in which case i would question said mercy of god.

Peace ,

 

[Paladin]

Gaalos insulting the deen.
Don't ever mention the deen when u know very little about it. Why can't u be like ex Christians, just shut up and live ur life. But nope ex Muslims r special. They want to dictate to the believers the contents of their faith. u lost all knowledge of the deen the very day u left it. R u lot not always saying u want freedom from Islam, u know what I give it to u. Stop talking to dangerous and oppressive Muslims, run and live a free life......... Unless of course u would rather spend ur time being a part time islamaphobe and Muslim. These people afur with hooyo and aabo, but then come here to insult the deen both their parents love. In the words of abdijohson, SAD

 

[ItsHanna]

Muslim: Islam is a feminist religion
Me:

Let me see wife beating? Check

Women are inferior to men? Check

More women will be in hell? Check

A man can marry more than one wife but a woman can't marry more than one man? Check

A Muslim man can marry a Jew or Christian, but a Muslim women can't? Check

A wife must have sex with her husband at all times even if she is tried or cooking food(and if she refuses she gets cursed by angels?) Double check

A womans testimony is less equal? Check

A woman must cover up all her body? Check

A woman cannot go outside without a muharm? Check

If you want to live under these unfair rules then you are your own enemy @shan-futo-le

 

[Bahal]

Muslim: Islam is a feminist religion
Me:

Let me see wife beating? Check

Women are inferior to men? Check

More women will be in hell? Check

A wife must have sex with her husband at all times even if she is tried or cooking food(and if she refuses she gets cursed by angels?) Double check

A womans testimony is less equal? Check

A woman must cover up all her body? Check

A woman cannot go outside without a muharm? Check

If you want to live under these unfair rules then you are your own enemy

Prefer Islam to the likes of you tbqh

 

[ItsHanna]

Prefer Islam to the likes of you tbqh

You're a man of course you do. Islam is here to make your life better and mine worse.

 

[EternalLightX]

You're a man of course you do. Islam is here to make your life better and mine worse.

The subjugation of women is evident in the amount of Saudi women who flee their most volatile nation, the shariah law is backwards, women are a cursed to be born into this religion !!! It's so anti women

 

[Bahal]

You're a man of course you do. Islam is here to make your life better and mine worse.

I suck black dick how do I hate blacks?

Alhamdullilah for Islam

 

[MadNomad]

It does say you're allowed to hit your wife in the quran dee

Only lightly

 

[ItsHanna]

Alhamdullilah for Islam

Clearly a joke to annoy racist farah's. I am allergic to black dick.

 

[TekNiKo]

These atheists are truly obsessed with our religion. Why can't they just live their life instead trying to go all militant on us. This shows they are insecure in their disbelief otherwise they wouldnt even care about Islam!.

Just kill yourselves disgusting apostate heathens, you don't even come out to your parents and immediate family showing how cowardly you are, eating hooyos sambuus during iftaar

 

[TekNiKo]

Alhamdullilah for Islam

Eww disgusting hoe, no wonder she left Islam too freely suck cock

 

[Gibiin-Udug]

You're a man of course you do. Islam is here to make your life better and mine worse.

Islam makes the lives of s difficult because they can't have premarital sex, they can't suck anything, they can't touch nonmuhraam men. But God fearing, non- women are given the highest respect they deserve in Islam. So no darling our lives are not made difficult. Islam treats women with dignity, respect and our religion protects us. Go learn the religion and then have an opinion on it.

 

[Bahal]

Clearly a joke to annoy racist farah's. I am allergic to black dick.

Your face + penis

 

[Steamdevolopment]

Islam makes the lives of s difficult because they can't have premarital sex, they can't suck anything, they can't touch nonmuhraam men. But God fearing, non- women are given the highest respect they deserve in Islam. So no darling our lives are not made difficult. Islam treats women with dignity, respect and our religion protects us. Go learn the religion and then have an opinion on it.

They also make the lives of women diffcult trough an honor based system, which forces rape victims to marry their accuser and turns families against their children.

We need fundamental change, and we could start but stopping the -shaming.