Somalis did not migrate from the north though. It's their homeland and northern Somalis were the majority and rulers of Adal Sultanate admitted by most scholars. Afars and Harari people were simply part of the kingdom but with a minority status. Nothing offensive about it but that is a historical fact whether you like it or not.
Now we can go back to Ifat period and it will still tell you it was dominated by Somalis.
Here is an authentic source stating that Ifat Sultanate was a Somali Sultanate.
Source: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=Q0pZPp032c0C&pg=PA43&dq=Ifat+Sultanate+was+a+Somali+Muslim+Sultanate&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwilsrTC8bDcAhVQZlAKHZrABV4Q6AEILDAB#v=onepage&q=Ifat Sultanate was a Somali Muslim Sultanate&f=false
Ifat Sultanate capital called Zeila was also predominantly Somali.
Here is a 13th century historian called Ibn Sa'id that stated Zeila was predominantly Somali.
Source: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=GWjxR61xAe0C&pg=PA139&dq=ibn+sa'id+zeila&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjR0Zew7-3cAhWFfMAKHbAfD8AQ6AEIKTAA#v=onepage&q=ibn sa'id zeila&f=false
So what migration are you talking about?
What the f*ck are you talking about? Sanaag and whole of northern Somalia is the ancestral homeland for Somalis. Since when did Hararis even live in Sanaag? You guys migrated from Shewa to Hararghe, chill the f*ck out!
I'm sorry but the Darood myth says an Arab man from Yemen married a local Dir woman in Sanaag which gave birth to the Darood clan. That is what the myth says and it's been debunked since genetically Darood are pure Somalis. Why are you denying science for? Darood are not Jeberti, you're talking about Tigrays and Hararis are genetically different from Somalis so don't bother claiming them.
If you're going to speak with nonsensical bullshit. Please back it with sources like me and by the way, your sources are talking about Harar Imamate and I agree we Somalis have nothing to do with it.
What you missed reading from my last post was you can deny Somali presence in the north all you want. But just remember Somalis also established a kingdom in Hararghe known as Dawaro Sultanate in the 10th century. Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sultanate_of_Dawaro
They also established a small kingdom in the north which was the preceded state of Ifat Sultanate called Adal kingdom centred in Zeila. According to Al-Yaqubi in the 9th century, it was dominated by the Dir clan.
Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adal_Kingdom
What the f*ck are you talking about? Sanaag and whole of northern Somalia is the ancestral homeland for Somalis. Since when did Hararis even live in Sanaag? You guys migrated from Shewa to Hararghe, chill the f*ck out!
I'm sorry but the Darood myth says an Arab man from Yemen married a local Dir woman in Sanaag which gave birth to the Darood clan. That is what the myth says and it's been debunked since genetically Darood are pure Somalis. Why are you denying science for? Darood are not Jeberti, you're talking about Tigrays and Hararis are genetically different from Somalis so don't bother claiming them.
If you're going to speak with nonsensical bullshit. Please back it with sources like me and by the way, your sources are talking about Harar Imamate and I agree we Somalis have nothing to do with it.
What you missed reading from my last post was you can deny Somali presence in the north all you want. But just remember Somalis also established a kingdom in Hararghe known as Dawaro Sultanate in the 10th century. Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sultanate_of_Dawaro
They also established a small kingdom in the north which was the preceded state of Ifat Sultanate called Adal kingdom centred in Zeila. According to Al-Yaqubi in the 9th century, it was dominated by the Dir clan.
Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adal_Kingdom
What you need to understand is northern Somalia was the ancestoral homeland for Somalis. Oromos never in their entire history ever existed in northern Somalia. Are you telling me Zeila and Berbera were originally Oromo?
Look at this medieval map. You'll see northern Somalis, Afars and Hararis sharing a kingdom called Adal Sultanate and Oromos were not seen on the map. They are very recent that came during the 16th century after the Oromo expansion.
As for Gaalkacyo, it's believed to be named after the resistance against the Italians when Omar Samatar and his forces kicked the Italian forces out. That's why it's called "Gaal Kacyo".
Changing the subject as usual once you're debunked. This is basic 101 Somali history, their origins are from the north. I don't know why we should expand on that? You might get different theories but they have all been rejected by most scholars. I don't have time for your trolling.
This is the truth. This source is from Making Sense of Somali History: Volume 1
Your quote is the worst sort of BS, on a par with " History of the First Million Years BC". Check out someone who has actually thought about the issue:
https://www.academia.edu/248346/The_Origins_of_the_Galla_and_Somali
View attachment 52385
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nineteen of 21 Eastern Cushitic languages are found in southeast Etjhiopia, at the headwaters of the Dawa and Genale rivers, which were used as migration routes into Somalia by V32 Somalis. There is other evidence that T1a arrived earlier, having come down the coastal strip from the Red Sea hills. The Hawiyye reached the Shabelli basin near the Indian Ocean coast by 1100, and the northern clans form in the 12th-13th centuries. Gurey 25 of Somnet estimated there were only 1000 Isaaq, total, in 1200. They were called Simur by the Harla, Somalis only become Somalis in the early 15th century.
Care needs to be taken when identifying groups before the early 1500s. Prior to that the clans thought of themselves as Marehaan, Harti or Dir. Many groups were just "proto something." , as you saw with the Jarso, not yet set in their identities and subject to change. In 900 there were no Somali clans in the North as such.
My sources came from Abdullahi Abdurahman who is one of the greatest Somali historians. He quotes from other scholars and archaeologist so the debate is over. That book the origin of Somali and Galla is outdated, bullshit and refuted by most historians. I knew you was going to pick up some bullshit debunked sources, you have nothing better to do but take sources that were already thrown away.
Let me debunk every bullshit you stated.
1. Grant said "The northern clans form in the 12th-13th centuries". Ughh post a source because Jarso clan were mentioned in the 10th century for establishing Dawaro Sultanate in the 10th century. Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sultanate_of_Dawaro
Al-Yaquubi mentioned ethnic Somalis in the 9th century and he also mentioned the Dir clan ruling the early Adal Kingdom. Here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adal_Kingdom
In fact, in the 7th century Dir were mentioned for converting to Islam during Hijra. Source: The Cambridge History of Africa, Volume 3
Just remember that some scholars claim that the Somali identity is more three thousand years old. Oldest Somali mentions is in the 9th century and Somali clans have been mentioned since the 1st century so your theory on 15th century has been utterly debunked.
2. Grant gets his sources from a user from Somnet that stated there were 1000 Isaaqs in 1200. Where is the source for that bullshit? So 1000 became millions today? Yeah, alright. Keep exposing your stupidity.
3. Grant said Harla call Isaaq "Simur". According to Ethiopian sources, they referred Somalis as Simur. You've exposed your lack of knowledge about Somalis again.
I think we're done @Grant, you're proving me day by day that you don't have a freaking clue what you're talking about.
