I have recently found out

[Afar indhood]

What do you mean i support Somalia as a whole, and Somaliweyn seems a nice concept but we are not ready to make that happpen yes lets focus to build Somalia first and we can talk about somaliweyn later

He's asking if you are Ciise, gudubiirsi, Madhibaan or orom. I believe (I could be wrong) that he's isaaq who claims to be MJ.
I am interested too because If you come clean about your clan, i'll just dismiss anything you have to say and reduce your political views to qabiil.
So, yaa tahay?

 

[Afar indhood]

U will find them teaching ashari books tho

Which ones?
Alshabab differentiate between fiqh and aqeedah. They accept shaafici fiqh books like safına al salat and minhaaj but they still consider ash'arites kuffar (at least their mufti does) and don't teach ash'ari aqeedah.
My thinking is that Somalis (alshabab, ictisaam, sufis, ash'arites, me) don't quite get these contradictory madaahib and we're just winging it.
Shit's confusing.

 

[Guure⁸]

Which ones?
Alshabab differentiate between fiqh and aqeedah. They accept shaafici fiqh books like safına al salat and minhaaj but they still consider ash'arites kuffar (at least their mufti does) and don't teach ash'ari aqeedah.
My thinking is that Somalis (alshabab, ictisaam, sufis, ash'arites, me) don't quite get these contradictory madaahib and we're just winging it.
Shit's confusing.

Exactly, modern salafi scholars don't takfeer asha'ira which makes them different from actual salafis, and whats confusing about these madaahib? Yes they do have ikhtilaf but if you are knowledgeable enough u can just follow the adilah instead

 

[reer]

Exactly, modern salafi scholars don't takfeer asha'ira

the mufti saleh al fawzan literally wrote in his book that asharis are on the manhaj of the polytheists of quraish.
aslo the sheikh sultan al umayri called asharis a kafir sect.

 

[Jaffar]

He's asking if you are Ciise, gudubiirsi, Madhibaan or orom. I believe (I could be wrong) that he's isaaq who claims to be MJ.
I am interested too because If you come clean about your clan, i'll just dismiss anything you have to say and reduce your political views to qabiil.
So, yaa tahay?

why is my qabil so important , i am somali , my opinion are my its not my tribal chief opinion

 

[The Oponian Guild]

He's asking if you are Ciise, gudubiirsi, Madhibaan or orom. I believe (I could be wrong) that he's isaaq who claims to be MJ.
I am interested too because If you come clean about your clan, i'll just dismiss anything you have to say and reduce your political views to qabiil.
So, yaa tahay?

This the sort of slop I’d send back when I was an npc somaliyeeste, before I became politically enlightened:

The same people who used to agree with me on everything are now my biggest detractors on this forum, shit happens I guess.

 

[The Oponian Guild]

why is my qabil so important , i am somali , my opinion are my its not my tribal chief opinion

Are you that much of a pussy niyow, it’s an anonymous forum, markii fulaynimadaadu heerkaas gardho, waxaba kaa shakiya soomaalinimadaada

 

[Guure⁸]

the mufti saleh al fawzan literally wrote in his book that asharis are on the manhaj of the polytheists of quraish.
aslo the sheikh sultan al umayri called asharis a kafir sect.

The two biggest wahhabi scholars in our era btw and bring sheikh Saleh saying such

 

[Afar indhood]

Exactly, modern salafi scholars don't takfeer asha'ira which makes them different from actual salafis, and whats confusing about these madaahib? Yes they do have ikhtilaf but if you are knowledgeable enough u can just follow the adilah instead

If you ask any two sheikhs who claim adherence to the same madhab about caqeedah concepts like takfeer, you will get contradictory opinions. In fact, I have seen many sheikhs who self-contradict within the same argumente.
Caqeedah is like metaphysics - there are no clear lines, so ikhtilaf is inevitable. Except; unlike fiqh, ikhtilaf in aqeedah leads to Takfeering.
Adilah are subject to interpretation and not always grounded in empirical truth.

 

[reer]

@Guure⁸ @Araabi nowadays some of them bury the controversial positions in their books instead of social media.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Araabi]

@Guure⁸ @Araabi nowadays some of them bury the controversial positions in their books instead of social media.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

What they believe in their private circles is different to what they say publicly. We know this. Check out the book الدرر السنية

 

[Misil]

their core aqeedah books are usually the same. madkhali. sururi. hazimi. etc etc etc. what shared aqeedah manhaj does a ashari ikhwani and salafi ikhwani have?

A book they share is aqida tahawiya. You’re exaggerating the difference within these creedal schools. They all agree on most of the usool and furuuc. The problem is they make a big deal out of their tiny disagreements and then excommunicate each other over these subsidiary matters.