How many of you are sufis

[Invader]

Mawlid is shirk

Mawlid was made by the shiites @Advokaten watch the second video.

You guys are following the gaals with this concept.

just like Christmas.


Just accept the defeat


ACTUALLY watch it. Where in the Qu'ran did Allah say celebrate his birthday?

Where did Prophet Muhammad ask for his birthday to be celebrated.

No answer?

Thought so

 

[Invader]

@Advokaten

Even know an Cadaan convert to Islam knows

 

[Faahiye]

Which order do you claim? I recently became sufi back home, I am qadiriyya the northern section of qadiriyya is colloquially named timoweyne

@Advokaten,

I am just a Sunni but I don't have a problem with authentic Sufism (none of the weird cultish, biddah stuff)


Best,

Faahiye

 

[Invader]

Many of the great scholars of the past were Sufis, including ibn taymiyyah. Tasawwuf has always been a a part of classical orthodox Islam

Sufism is pre-Islam sxb.


0:27

 

[Invader]

@Advokaten Why did you stop replying

 

[Faahiye]

Mawlid is shirk

@One Star To Rule Them All,

What an idiotic statement!


Best,

Faahiye

 

[Invader]

@One Star To Rule Them All,

What an idiotic statement!


Best,

Faahiye

it's true.

Just like the ways when Christmas is celebrated.

Tell me when the prophet asked for his birthday to be celebrated.

Never.

This was introduced by the Fatimid Shiites and wasn't in any hadith.

Eid Al Adha and Eid Al Fitr are the only ones to be celebrated.

Best,

One Star

 

[Faahiye]

it's true.

Just like the ways when Christmas is celebrated.

Tell me when the prophet asked for his birthday to be celebrated.

Never.

This was introduced by the Fatimid Shiites and wasn't in any hadith.

Eid Al Adha and Eid Al Fitr are the only ones to be celebrated.

Best,

One Star

@One Star To Rule Them All,

And that is a valid position. What I'm saying is idiotic is to call mawlid shirk. Disagree with it if you must.


Best,

Faahiye

 

[Invader]

@One Star To Rule Them All,

And that is a valid position. What I'm saying is idiotic is to call mawlid shirk. Disagree with it if you must.


Best,

Faahiye

So celebrating something not permitted by Allah is acceptable?

Allah should be worshipped and no celebrations like this should take place.

it's shirk otherwise just like them worshipping graves during this "holy" day.

 

[Invader]

You guys behaving crazy

 

[Marcus]

So celebrating something not permitted by Allah is acceptable?

Allah should be worshipped and no celebrations like this should take place.

it's shirk otherwise just like them worshipping graves during this "holy" day.

It's not shirk mate, you're not assigning partners to God.

Don't be a silly salafi, please

 

[Invader]

It's not shirk mate, you're not assigning partners to God.

Don't be a silly salafi, please

I'm not salafi sxb. I just don't like Sufis.

Not all people who hate Sufis are Salafis.

Their "version" of Islam is disgusting.

Also I was referring about the worship of shrines during the day.

 

[Faahiye]

So celebrating something not permitted by Allah is acceptable?

Allah should be worshipped and no celebrations like this should take place.

it's shirk otherwise just like them worshipping graves during this "holy" day.

@One Star To Rule Them All,

I'm saying your disagreement with it is valid. But to call it shirk is stupid. People just use the day to commemorate the life of the prophet by listening to sermons, qasidahs etc. Ofcoure there are those who do weird stuff but both sides of this debate would agree this is haram. I'm not saying to agree with it just don't call it shirk.


Best,

Faahiye

 

[Invader]

@One Star To Rule Them All,

I'm saying your disagreement with it is valid. But to call it shirk is stupid. People just use the day to commemorate the life of the prophet by listening to sermons, qasidahs etc. Ofcoure there are those who do weird stuff but both sides of this debate would agree this is haram. I'm not saying to agree with it just don't call it shirk.


Best,

Faahiye

I'm talking about the worship of shrines during that day.




Best,

One Star

 

[Faahiye]

I'm talking about the worship of shrines during that day.




Best,

One Star

@One Star To Rule Them All,

Then say that instead of "Mawlid is shirk". You can see how anyone can misunderstood what you meant.


Best,

Faahiye

 

[Advokaten]

I'm talking about the worship of shrines during that day.




Best,

One Star

Most sufis dont do that in somalia, Its more common in the south who are influenced by reer xamar sufism, How many times do we have to explain this to you saxbi?

 

[Invader]

@One Star To Rule Them All,

Then say that instead of "Mawlid is shirk". You can see how anyone can misunderstood what you meant.


Best,

Faahiye

Ok I understand


Best,

One Star

 

[Invader]

Most sufis dont do that in somalia, Its more common in the south who are influenced by reer xamar sufism, How many times do we have to explain this to you saxbi?

I don't care if you're Sufi. There's no point celebrating his birthday if he didn't ask for it

 

[reer]

Most sufis dont do that in somalia, Its more common in the south who are influenced by reer xamar sufism, How many times do we have to explain this to you saxbi?

the base of somali sufism is central somalia

 

[Advokaten]

I don't care if you're Sufi. There's no point celebrating his birthday if he didn't ask for it

I dont celebrate the prophets birthday, And i dont worship saints or venerate at their graves, So i dont understand what you are trying to do