Al-Shabaab capture Geriley, Jubbaland base ATMIS left last month

[Sheikh Kulkuli]

why u keep claiming beesha Sab as samaale, this is crazy

There is no hawiye in middle Jubba.

 

[World]

I've already addressed this in detail. JL has very few farmers.
If you take livestock and farming together as agriculture, farmers in JL produce something like 6% of agricultural GDP. It is basically impossible to have ~ 500,000 farmers in JL producing $25 million worth of crops.

https://www.somalispot.com/threads/how-much-of-jubalands-agricultural-gdp-is-generated-by-nomads-vs-farmers.138527/#post-3430441

Damn, the entire Jubbaland only produces enough sorghum to feed like 30,000 people in a year.

 

[Sheikh Kulkuli]

Damn, the entire Jubbaland only produces enough sorghum to feed like 30,000 people in a year.

Because of weed production supercedes it with Jilib being the top growing region.

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

Damn, the entire Jubbaland only produces enough sorghum to feed like 30,000 people in a year.

These people want to convince us there are millions of Bantu & Raxanweyn farming in JL like it is Thailand!

FAO takes a few high resolution satellite imagery and immediately knows what crop is being grown, and what the expected yield will be that year. JL does not produce much in the way of farmed goods and that is easily proved because it can be seen from space.

https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/10/11/1726#

 

[Removed]

If Nomadic and Urban are separate categories, where do you think all the farmers were put?

Also, you ain’t the only cow herders

View attachment 283173

You havent addressed the output point bc you would be forced to prove Bantus/RX are herding most of the livestock

We haven’t lost an inch of territory to anyone mate. Abgaal and Xawaadle came to a peace agreement and a clear border will soon be drawn. But feel free to drop your sources and I’ll refute every single one.

Go respond to the million Xawaadle threads we’ve seen your 48 hour humiliation ritual.

Are Caramale not in Buulo Xaaji? Are Sheekhaal/other Hiraab not in Hoosingow, Tardho, Jilib and Haramka? Are Gaaljecel not in Ras kambooni and Berhani? Are Ajuran not in Buale? You cannot possibly deny the Samaale presence in Jubaland without straight up lying

None of those are settled by Samaale they are all Darood majority barring the Bantu majority of Jilib and Haramka

The Samaale presence in JL is significantly less then the historic or modern presence of Darood in Xamar/GM and the D&M are far more numerous in Mog/LS then Middle Jubba/Gedo

When Ogaden arrives you have to call upon all Samaale and Sab for random tuulos because we are unparalleled in the peninsula let alone Darood. There are multiple more Warsengali in Jubbaland then Hawiye which is why they are their sheegads take that to the bank

 

[Abaq]

Burgaabo, jamaame, buale, sakow, salagle, jilib, buulohaji, kaamboni, scidlei, biroole, hosingow, galaf, kidi faani, riqala, dabader, tinguduud, kuko, buscbusc, omanspara, uel merer, qoddo, mado, xaaji cali, luglaaw, sheekh xuseen, biyo yare, gobo kibir, mukamaani, jumba, koyaama, beermaasi, qod-qod, licchitore, jiroole, qalaangaley, saydey, cabdi dhore, uur gallo, mola garsey, urungo, qooqaani, magado, solola, aboli, guba geeriya, obsoda or cubsada depends on who you ask, diriye, tabta, dicu, maro daltu, aboli, galabuala, xayo, sooyaac, cuca, camora bali, lebi, xasan-baraki, warqiam, warqiao, balogalool, dilduch, uruai, barako, anium, dirdir muso, baabo, billada, habo gulo, tuweer dama, garsay kuusa, wadajir, obbe, ceel habla, kuusow, garas, canjeel, xaafko, mad caraale, gaduud, juumba, qandal, rassini, juula, canoole, baalgudde, yeedi, booda, waamo, jibey, beey, turdho, muryoole, cadaad geri, billaq.

You literally just plucked these from a map. You have no clue sxb. Kamboni, Buurgaabo SMH. I will refute only one so people can see that I am not biased and actually know the land. Wadajir is a small village on the Badhaadhe Kismaayo border. It is settled by MJ few families. It is near a Makaahiil village called Dalaayad which is less than 10km to the West. And yet you want to tell me Irir live there. Stop misinforming these clueless Hutus from Galguduud who will believe your nonsense

 

[Abaq]

If Nomadic and Urban are separate categories, where do you think all the farmers were put?

Also, you ain’t the only cow herders

View attachment 283173

We haven’t lost an inch of territory to anyone mate. Abgaal and Xawaadle came to a peace agreement and a clear border will soon be drawn. But feel free to drop your sources and I’ll refute every single one.


Are Caramale not in Buulo Xaaji? Are Sheekhaal/other Hiraab not in Hoosingow, Tardho, Jilib and Haramka? Are Gaaljecel not in Ras kambooni and Berhani? Are Ajuran not in Buale? You cannot possibly deny the Samaale presence in Jubaland without straight up lying

Nobody is denying Samaale presence but you guys grossly exaggerate their numbers. There are at most 150 to 200 Gaaljecel families in Ras Kamboni and that’s me being generous. Hoosingow and Berhani are both tiny. Check them on the map

 

[Abdalla]

Do you think we will fight your dirty wars and you sit at the high table and screw us?

Yes.

 

[Calaami]

Are Caramale not in Buulo Xaaji? Are Sheekhaal/other Hiraab not in Hoosingow, Tardho, Jilib and Haramka? Are Gaaljecel not in Ras kambooni and Berhani? Are Ajuran not in Buale? You cannot possibly deny the Samaale presence in Jubaland without straight up lying

Buulo Xaaji is an Harti deegaan (mostly Ciise Maxamuuds). Straight up. Wtf is an Cawrmale. my adeer put them into packs

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.