Search results

The fragmentation stems from saudi & spreads throughout rest of world. Despite their differences esp spubs & madinah college (London) they have a lot more in common yet this fails to bring about any sort of unity between them. Salafi dawah has been largely on the decline esp in the west as...

I knw sxb but do you know that he was kicked out of sacuudiga because of his views ? Funny enough al madkhali was one of his pupils & he criticised him for his excessiveness & even called out the extremism in the early salafi/najdi dawah.

Exactly & it’s the reason why they keep on dividing themselves. Today it’s this shaykh tomorrow he’s dropped for another who’s in agreement with what they want & the cycle goes on. The first targets of madkhalis is always fellow salafis look at how they talk about salafi sheikhs imprisoned by...

I know sxb laakin it goes beyond that for those who can speak arabic. It’s been elevated to a core point of creed that they use as a standard to establish views, critique others etc.

Thanks for the explanation, it was an interesting read tbh never expected it at all. The more you research on issues the clearer things get May Allah increase us in knowledge and keep us steadfast Ameen

The reason is quite simple really, this is the brand of salafism that’s been propagated by the Saudi ruling family as it’s serves their interests. The other ruling families in the gulf copied the Saudis and started to spread it as well. It’s not limited to somalis, it the same across all ethnic...

@Omar del Sur I’ve been meaning to ask you what led to your change of position with regards to madkhalis. I mean prior to this madkhali was nothing more than a hoax, an ikhwani propaganda term as you called it.

@Zob sxb like I stated earlier i understand your concerns & frustrations laakin this shouldn’t be a reason to accuse others of committing serious sins like zina. Diinta has placed a high evidence threshold for sins like it so it’s not something to lightly. You demand others to apologise...

waa caadi sxb as I completely understand what you’re saying laakin we all have our shortcomings sometimes it takes time & effort to rectify them as such it’s better to be patient. Discussion are meant to be just that, at the end of day we can’t force people to accept our views. It’s a learning...

Sxb we both agree that it could’ve been handled differently & to be fair she did acknowledge the concern so let’s leave it at that. Portraying her as having khawarij characteristics is a grievous accusation & I would recommend you don’t do that. I’ve had many discussions with her about a...

It’s a good point to note as well, even if we assume that majority go beyond the limit why should those who adhere to what diinta says be barred from practicing it. The sins of others shouldn’t have a bearing on what any individual is allowed to do islamically. Furthermore why negate the...

Our arguments most certainly didn’t start when I hinted at ideology issues, it started way before that. You had already made up your mind about me being guilty, this is why you accused me of defending pagan circumcision in your response to mohmed at # 16 even though I never made such claims. It...

What was being claimed was factually incorrect & despite my attempts to clarify, it never ceased hence my insistence to read up on it. Now that argument & the one where similarity was drawn in removing part of the male genitalia are what i call "shock" arguments that are utilised to shut down...

Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi rajicun May Allah forgive them for their shortcomings and grant them jannatul firdaws. May Allah grant victory to our brothers against their oppressors Ameen thumma Ameen Qiyaamo is waiting for them

@Angelina There's no benefit in doodaan, so for both our sakes let's just stop here

On what grounds ? at least explain yourself sxb, moreover our discussion & disagreements had nothing to do with whether female circumcision is wajib, sunnah, noble etc. It revolved around the differential treatment between fgm & fgcs, ridicule & vilification of fellow muslim women etc.

Engaging in fatwa shopping, i can do that too. Mind you the pic is from the same fatwa you posted a few days ago & guess what from the same website islamqa.org.

Who says a word by itself is racist ?? i stated that the term fgm is racist as it's ONLY utilised to describe non-white body modifications despite the overlapping similarities to white body modifications. It makes distinctions based on the colour of those carrying out the procedures, hence why i...

@Berke has already answered the first part regarding the stances of madhabs, so i will focus more on the latter question that you raised. Just to emphasize, medical health benefit has never been a reason why people carried out circumcision in the past. It's only in our times that this has been...

Why ? because I’m telling you to stop insulting fellow muslim women who don’t share your views regarding female circumcision. This knee jerk response is typical for people who put up a charade acting like they care about women’s issues when in reality they couldn’t be bothered at all. Do you...