Was Zeila originally afar?

[Somali_patriotic]

Saw this guy's account and he got some good arguments tbh

 

[niggaibnh]

Saw this guy's account and he got some good arguments tbh

Nope
They have no sources to claim it that’s the funny thing

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Nope
They have no sources to claim it that’s the funny thing

"As for the region beyond Sawakin until Bad al-Mandab, they belonged to a Black race called Danakil, as well as the areas from Bab al-Mandab til Zeila”.

 

[Somali_patriotic]

@Garaad diinle what do you think about this?
@Hamzza i recall you saying zeila was inhabited by afars before, do you have evidence for that?

 

[ibrahym]

 

[ibrahym]

 

[Step a side]

View attachment 292144
"As for the region beyond Sawakin until Bad al-Mandab, they belonged to a Black race called Danakil, as well as the areas from Bab al-Mandab til Zeila”.

Bab el Mandab is not Zeila. Bab el Mandab is obock region of Djibouti which is Afar territory

 

[Shaafici Mujaahid]

Saw this guy's account and he got some good arguments tbh

Afar wasn’t mentioned was in the futuh nor was Danakhil. The strange thing is that the Afar clans that border Somalis are actually somalis that were assimilated by Afar. The Daroodtu, and the Kabirtu are Harti and Sheekhaal.

 

[Khaemwaset]

View attachment 292144
"As for the region beyond Sawakin until Bad al-Mandab, they belonged to a Black race called Danakil, as well as the areas from Bab al-Mandab til Zeila”.

False second hand account made by a foreigner.
Southern Djibouti and Awdal is and always has been Dir.

Afars have always been confined to their geographic boundaries within the Danakil depression/Desert. At no point in history are they known for going outside that region. In fact we Ciise took over a big chunk of it under Djibouti.

Djibouti is like 90% afar land but we Ciise live in the south which is habitable so we are near 80% of the population.

 

[NidarNidar]

Afar wasn’t mentioned was in the futuh nor was Danakhil. The strange thing is that the Afar clans that border Somalis are actually somalis that were assimilated by Afar. The Daroodtu, and the Kabirtu are Harti and Sheekhaal.

I found 3rd cousin who is 92% Eriterian and carrying T-L208, I asked my dad and he mentioned how my great-great-grandparent couldn't find one of his sons, This mofo survived and became Eriterian, not sure if his Afar, he hasn't got back to me yet.

 

[Al Adnani]

Afars constituted a chunk of the population and served as rulers in Zeila before. This is well documented.

 

[Al Adnani]

False second hand account made by a foreigner.
Southern Djibouti and Awdal is and always has been Dir.

Afars have always been confined to their geographic boundaries within the Danakil depression/Desert. At no point in history are they known for going outside that region. In fact we Ciise took over a big chunk of it under Djibouti.

Djibouti is like 90% afar land but we Ciise live in the south which is habitable so we are near 80% of the population.

First paragraph is cope bro. Multiple accounts record afar activity in Zeila, I could post some if you’d like

 

[Khaemwaset]

First paragraph is cope bro. Multiple accounts record afar activity in Zeila, I could post some if you’d like

Post it then with links to the source

 

[Hamzza]

@Garaad diinle what do you think about this?
@Hamzza i recall you saying zeila was inhabited by afars before, do you have evidence for that?

No bro. But I don't have evidence of Somalis inhabiting the town before the 19th century either. What I was saying was that Ibn Battuta's description of Zeyla could perfectly fit the Afars as well as the Somalis.

 

[Hamzza]

Bab el Mandab is not Zeila. Bab el Mandab is obock region of Djibouti which is Afar territory

Who said Bab al Mandab is Zeyla?

According to those sources the areas between Sawakin in Sudan to Bab al Mandeb belonged to the Beja and the area from the strait down to Zeyla was inhabited by a dark race called Danakils.

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Bab el Mandab is not Zeila. Bab el Mandab is obock region of Djibouti which is Afar territory

You're right, but it's saying they inhabit from bab el mandab till zeila

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Afars constituted a chunk of the population and served as rulers in Zeila before. This is well documented.

That's the ottoman period, i mean prior to it

 

[Somali_patriotic]

No bro. But I don't have evidence of Somalis inhabiting the town before the 19th century either. What I was saying was that Ibn Battuta's description of Zeyla could perfectly fit the Afars as well as the Somalis.

Ibn battuta said the barbars inhabit from mogadishu to Zeila, Then later spoke about the inhabitants of zeila being dark skinned and stuff,
Isn't that an evidence of somalis inhabiting the region?

 

[Step a side]

You're right, but it's saying they inhabit from bab el mandab till zeila

Sorry only read the 1st part.

 

[Three Moons]

View attachment 292144
"As for the region beyond Sawakin until Bad al-Mandab, they belonged to a Black race called Danakil, as well as the areas from Bab al-Mandab til Zeila”.

Is that a direct translation? Another translation from that individual says this:

"As for what is beyond Suakin towards Bab al Mandeb, it belongs to a black race called Dankal and beyond Al-Mandab is Zaylah."

Which changes the entire context. Any Arabic speakers here who can read the original?