What we should do?

I heard the theory about J being from the Caucasus and that they came after. However all of those theories were essentially conspiracy theories about the "true Arabs". It seems like these brothers did DNA tests and are trying to rationalize why the majority of the people who have it are Somali and other Africans. But hey, when I was in SA, they welcomed me well. So if I ever go back to the Middle East, I'm definitely playing along to the benefits 😂
 

Aurelian

Forza Somalia!
VIP
I heard the theory about J being from the Caucasus and that they came after. However all of those theories were essentially conspiracy theories about the "true Arabs". It seems like these brothers did DNA tests and are trying to rationalize why the majority of the people who have it are Somali and other Africans. But hey, when I was in SA, they welcomed me well. So if I ever go back to the Middle East, I'm definitely playing along to the benefits 😂
Yes, they don’t get that these haplogroups were already there before Arabic language was even born
 
My Puntite ancestors were already in the horn about 5000 years ago and my aabo Darood Jabarti is E-V32 as well, he might not have been Qurayshi to be honest. How does a haplogroup originating from North Africa end up in the horn I wonder. Maybe we wuz kangz?

Egypt Tourism GIF
 
Okay so supposedly E-V12 originates in Egypt 12k years ago then E-V32 forms 9700 years ago in Arabia before going to the Horn of Africa

1662496170176.png


1662496248105.png


How can we be Arab over something 10 centuries ago lol. Maybe we are the product of the mixing of the groups from Arabia and the ones in the horn. Idk I'm not acqainted with this genetics stuff.
 

Jiron

wanaag
NABADOON
VIP
we are all human beings that traveled around and mixed through trades and movements over a long period of time
there are somalis with j haplogroup and arabs/whites with e haplogroup.
it's important to recognize people of the ancient world intermingled a lot.
:)
 

Aurelian

Forza Somalia!
VIP
Okay so supposedly E-V12 originates in Egypt 12k years ago then E-V32 forms 9700 years ago in Arabia before going to the Horn of Africa

View attachment 236792

View attachment 236793

How can we be Arab over something 10 centuries ago lol. Maybe we are the product of the mixing of the groups from Arabia and the ones in the horn. Idk I'm not acqainted with this genetics stuff.
The North Africa to horn is more popular theory
 
Arabs are claiming us because they want our federal state leaders to believe we are Arabs, so they could sighn off all the lucrative oil and gas deals off to them ☺
 

Hamzza

VIP
Al-Tamimis coping

Not coping, he is only praising banu Tamim by citing the Hadith:
"I have continued to love Banu Tamim after I heard three things concerning them from Allah's Messenger: "They will be the sternest of my Ummah against the Dajjal," one of them was a captive owned by Aisha, and he said: "Free her, for she is a descendant of Ismail," and when their zakat came, he said: "This is the zakat of our people," or "of my people"​
 

El Nino

Cabsi cabsi
VIP
Okay so supposedly E-V12 originates in Egypt 12k years ago then E-V32 forms 9700 years ago in Arabia before going to the Horn of Africa

View attachment 236792

View attachment 236793

How can we be Arab over something 10 centuries ago lol. Maybe we are the product of the mixing of the groups from Arabia and the ones in the horn. Idk I'm not acqainted with this genetics stuff.

The North Africa to horn is more popular theory

We originated from Sudan, which is kinda not North Africa.
 

Juke

Asagu/Asaga
VIP
Not coping, he is only praising banu Tamim by citing the Hadith:
"I have continued to love Banu Tamim after I heard three things concerning them from Allah's Messenger: "They will be the sternest of my Ummah against the Dajjal," one of them was a captive owned by Aisha, and he said: "Free her, for she is a descendant of Ismail," and when their zakat came, he said: "This is the zakat of our people," or "of my people"​
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

Trending

Top