Universal Truth Weak Federalism Is A Cancer

[DR OSMAN]

A-lot of Somalis when they argue for their politiical idealogy support, it's usually one dimensional or compare with foreign experiment which do not fully capture multi-dimensional whether it's wise or unwise. The Hawiye who promote centralism, do not answer the faults of a weak federalism. They argue now 4 a centralized federalism that will lead to more power towards the center or mogadishu and is federalism in name only but in practise is centralism.

Answer these multi dimensionals points against your federalism in name only idealogy presented by Puntland.

1. Historical experience with civilian-kacaan govt and power abuses and regional economic isolation
2. Copying foreign models just leads to the same outcome on how we copied colonial foreign model with no local consideration or crafting to local realities or Somali characteritics.
3. How does it address civil war era that led to mistrust of govt
4. How does it address our cultural values of clan independence

If all that historical experience isn't enough, let your eyes see the four current powers delegated to the SFG is showing the same symptoms of power abuses, international aid allocation embargo on regions, corruption, nepotism, all these symptoms from the past are representing itself in the SFG.

If u can't manage the delegated tasks currently how can you argue with a straight face for more centralism? the only conclusion some have reached is political disagreement is a smoke screen only used to protect 91 loot interest so no political settlement and a strong govt thru diversity emerges.

 

[DR OSMAN]

War hamar bay mamuli karin waxayna shacabka kalsooni ku gaban shabab, war villa somalia iyo hareerahisa bay joggan kkkkk, ma dalka dhan ayaa loo dhiibi kara dawlad noocasi with low local public confidence and even international community is holed in shipping containers at halane.

Hell no. War hawshi yareed loo dhibtay bay masuq, ku takri fal awoood, corruption, nepotism bay ku samayeen welina mid kale ayay radinayan in loo dhiibto and more centralisation, gee nimankan hadi aan dalka laga gaban, somali meel fog ba laga radin doona sida SSC-Garhajis ku noqdeen SL.

 

[DR OSMAN]

War hawadi ayaa loo dhiibay a small pilot task to test their competence, isbaaro isla marki bay uu dhigteen gedo, if they did this to them, they can do this to all. Every task given to the SFG shows why more centralism is only going to lead to tyranny, and power abuses, isbaaro, war, corruption, nepotism on whatever tasks their given.

They are already showing the symptoms Somalis fear re-emerging from central govt experiments during civilian and kacaan. Loose confederation or hybrid federalism is the only answer, less power to the SFG and making it symbolic and ceremonial(xaflad jog only) no power or tasks over any aspect in Somalia state structure for at least 100 years and then it must be slow, incremental, careful review stage and then harmonization from confederation to federation or hybrid federation to federation .

 

[DR OSMAN]

Puntites must tell the world the SFG was only recognized after the federal constitution was developed in garowe 1 and 2 in 2012 and then the transition ended and official recognition came in 2016-2020 in HSM era,. If the SFG-Parliament-Court work outside that constitution it has to lose it's recognition as a federal govt immediately becuz it's recognition was dependent on a federal constitution, especially about pre-existing states and their status/relationship with the federal govt.

All agreements signed by any past leaders are null and void becuz wasn't ratified and put before the parliament of puntland to ascend into law, nor is the constitution even complete, so anythiing PL/SFG sign is null/void by default due to the constitution and only a photo-op or igu sawir.

PL/SFG status and relationship will not and cannot and legally speaking is invalid any agreement between them becuz of the constitution status and not being harmonized in Puntland parliament. 2 nin oo qol isku xiray such as GM/HS status kama talin karan ayaha puntland legally speaking.

PL status ka wayn labo niin ama parliamentka hamar, dasturka ayayba ku qoran tahay maqaamkeeda, iyo hadad diido, adaa'ba aqoonsiga dawladada waayi doontid ileen dawlad waxad ku tahay recognition of your constitution FIRST and the world only recognizes u after-wards not before.

Wax kasto hamar taal ama ha noqotee dawlad, maxkamad, parliament ama hayad kasto dasturka federalka taabanayso anaga nama quseeyso waa sharciga dasturka ileen dasturka lama dhamaystirin, xitaa nidaamki loo mari lahaa dhamaystirkeeda the SFG ma marin mana uu eeka inay maraysa dawladani shuftada ah oo mooda in somalia ayaaheeda 2 niin go'amin karan. Waqtiga umada haka qaadin haran ku naax yahow ee mara jidki aadi laha garowe.