The only hope for Somalia is the Switzerland model

[Farm]

The federal council of Switzerland has 7 presidents, with one of the presidents representing the country and another one being VP it then rotates every year.

Somalia should have a federal council with just the 5 FMS presidents, using the same model... 99% of Somalia’s problems come from the so called FGS that is led by a stateless b00n that doesn’t represent anyone.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

Not a bad model

 

[Ras]

The only hope for Somalia is an extra spicy nuke.

Scrape up some dna samples and start all over again with single celled organisms.

The confederation model is great but you really think we won't use that to impede each other? Everything will be vetoed out of spite.

 

[Khadar999]

Why can’t you just say you want to be a independent country with a chest no need to hide

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

Why can’t you just say you want to be a independent country with a chest no need to hide

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Why should we be tied together like conjoined twins? Each region is responsible for running its affairs. On danta guud, we have a council with the presidency rotating. Its a fair system. If you neglect your region, you are on your own boowe. Independence is out of the question for now.

 

[EDsomali]

Federalism has worked great for so far, hasn't it?

We need more of it.

 

[PhySom]

It won't work in Somalia, clan based states will just start fighting each other like they do now.

 

[Farjano-Walad]

The federal council of Switzerland has 7 presidents, with one of the presidents representing the country and another one being VP it then rotates every year.

Somalia should have a federal council with just the 5 FMS presidents, using the same model... 99% of Somalia’s problems come from the so called FGS that is led by a stateless b00n that doesn’t represent anyone.

you are 100% right, the only model that will work is confederacy model like the swiss or UAE

i have been saying it for years, the swiss 14 cantons each 2 cantons get a president, 7 presidents, the swiss are landlocked but have an economy 11 times the GDP of Ethiopia,

the only thing we really need to share is central bank, defence and foreign policy, that should be the only realm of the federal states,

also the natural resources, i dont mind if the regional state keeps 60% and pass the other 40% to the so called federal gov where its shared with the less rich regional States,

but the 5 regional presidents, its doesn have to be 5 we can make more like khaatumo, anyways, the regional leaders will have veto on what the federal/con-federal gov can and will do,

so if puntland or jubaland doesn't like a certain foreign policy like sending an army with UN to some nation, we can veto it, so can the others,


let each nation look after her taxes, decide on education policy, etc,

issue is we have langabs who hate this decentralisation, but at the same time they dont want the nation to prosper and move ahead with an honest accountable gov, they want their cake to eat it whilst also having their cake,

the langabs are UN imaginative but deep down they want to loot the nation because their regions dont produce jack shit so they wish to loot the central government,

the model will expose those who are bad leaders who cannot fix their own regions, attract investment etc, so the spot light hits them hard,

this is why an OG or an MJ president will not be picked for somalia anytime soon because they will implement this in the first 100 days, its they who need it and the other tribes want to loot xamar, notice how no other somali wants an accountable gov except Mj or OG? because the rest waa tuugo who depend on the central gov for looting,


federalism is too weak, we need confederacy like the Swiss, where regions crack on with life except deal with foreign or defence or monetary/currency issues, but they have a veto,

this is also perfect for competition, if one region like Bern hits you with massive VAT tax, say 20%, you go to Geneva where its 7%

so many firms were relocating from EU to Switzerland due to lower taxes the EU banned the swiss stock market shares being purchased by EU residents unless the swiss increased their VAT to say 30 because little es like Belgium, Denmark, France where its very high were not able to compete, exposing their big fat nanny high tax low growth state

i want confederacy model for somalia or we go our won way, Jubaland was a kingdom under Sultan Ahmed Magan the Ogaden king before the white men forced us into somalia, we need to leave this shythole if the federal government will not allow us decentralisation,

because of bad leadership from xamar, mark my word, Mj and OG will leave somalia in 10 years time if this continues,

Jubaland Independence Movement JIM here we come insha Allah,

 

[Farjano-Walad]

Federalism has worked great for so far, hasn't it?

We need more of it.

what are you on about dude>?

federalism has not been tried in spirit or letter of the law, the monkeys in xamar have never ever respect it, neither do they wish to be held accountable,

has the FGS ever published how they spend the money? have they ever passed a single penny to the member states, all these money they borrow and get donations for, not a single penny,

heck they dont even publish how much farmajo and co can take as salary, so in theory he can take 100% of the entire nations money, which of course he does.

kulaha federalism failed, it has not even been practised for 1 hour, the dastuur has been totally ignored,

example, the constitution says federalism member state pick their own leader, xamar cannot get involved, what has hassan sheikh and farmao done in the last several years?