Speaker of the Senate Abdi Hashi calls for Banadir representation
- Thread starter bidenkulaha
- Start date
Woke1.4rm.Shibis
VIP
The leaders of lower house and upper house are very supportive of banadir state alhamdulilah add the PM and ofcourse president HSM.
Banadir state will be a thing within the next 2 years inshallah
Banadir state will be a thing within the next 2 years inshallah
bidenkulaha
GalYare
What are you gonna do if two years from now nothing happensThe leaders of lower house and upper house are very supportive of banadir state alhamdulilah add the PM and ofcourse president HSM.
Banadir state will be a thing within the next 2 years inshallah
I think HSM has softened. Early days we shall see. Inshallah he delivers despite PL calaacal
Woke1.4rm.Shibis
VIP
What are you gonna do if two years from now nothing happens
I think HSM has softened. Early days we shall see. Inshallah he delivers despite PL calaacal
I have faith in HSM, if he dont deliver I'll join the team qaran dumis and calcaal no more Governo wacesley ABG
bidenkulaha
GalYare
This is the best chance Banadir has got. It can’t be wasted. Strong FGS, HAG Pres + supportive speakers + easily controlled SL/GM/HS/KG MPs + weakened PL.I have faith in HSM, if he dont deliver I'll join the team qaran dumis and calcaal no more Governo wacesley ABG
Woke1.4rm.Shibis
VIP
All of Somalia wants a state for the resilient ppl of banadir the anti federalist ppl should be left alone to calacaal while the pearl of Indian ocean moves on .
Greater Banadir state is a matter of when not if
The problem with giving Banadir representation in the senate is directly linked to the fact that the constitution has not been amended and passed by both houses.
In order for Mogadishu to have representation in the Upper House these articles need to be amended:
Article 49 Sec. 6
Article 72 preamble
Article 72 Sec. b
These are changes that have to be made anyway since Galmudug also fails to fulfil the 2 state requirement and is not in compliance. Also the requirement that all states should have an equal number of senators was violated when Puntland & Somaliland received more representation, they are not in compliance.
By giving PL & SL more representation based on their size, parliament admitted that size & population play a role in determining how many senators a federal state can receive. If this formula is to be used nationwide, a census is necessary. Parliament is just estimating that Pl & SL deserve more representation, there is no legal basis.
Parliament knew in 2016, when it was dividing up senate seats, that Banadir would be left out until its situation was clarified. So to maintain the clan balance it gave Galmudug and Hiirshabelle 16 seats, when they should have gotten roughly 10 seats. Hawiye now control 16/54 or ~30% of the senate, so it is not underrepresented as a clan. Any new representation for Banadir would need to be taken from Galmudug & Hiirshabelle.
Trying to amend the constitution so that Banadir has representation would mean that the federal government has to amend 3 sensitive articles of the constitution at once. Hard to imagine this getting done.
In order for Mogadishu to have representation in the Upper House these articles need to be amended:
Article 49 Sec. 6
Article 72 preamble
Article 72 Sec. b
These are changes that have to be made anyway since Galmudug also fails to fulfil the 2 state requirement and is not in compliance. Also the requirement that all states should have an equal number of senators was violated when Puntland & Somaliland received more representation, they are not in compliance.
By giving PL & SL more representation based on their size, parliament admitted that size & population play a role in determining how many senators a federal state can receive. If this formula is to be used nationwide, a census is necessary. Parliament is just estimating that Pl & SL deserve more representation, there is no legal basis.
Parliament knew in 2016, when it was dividing up senate seats, that Banadir would be left out until its situation was clarified. So to maintain the clan balance it gave Galmudug and Hiirshabelle 16 seats, when they should have gotten roughly 10 seats. Hawiye now control 16/54 or ~30% of the senate, so it is not underrepresented as a clan. Any new representation for Banadir would need to be taken from Galmudug & Hiirshabelle.
Trying to amend the constitution so that Banadir has representation would mean that the federal government has to amend 3 sensitive articles of the constitution at once. Hard to imagine this getting done.
If banadir state is recognized then khatumo and Maakhir should also be recognized
BanShabelle state unloading
bidenkulaha
GalYare
Screenshot it. Unfortunately facebook links are broken for me
The post has been deleted what is it about?
I can't because of FB security policy but just go to the homepage here
They are coming for shabelle hoose
Last edited:
They are coming for shabelle dheexe
This gobol belongs to HAG
Since when
Dhexe or hoose?They are coming for shabelle dheexe
I mean hoose sorry
They will conquer by force
thiers nothing u can do aboutTrending
-
-
-
An caadan girl went to Afghanistan, where are the comments cussing her out?- Started by Dibleyy
- Replies: 22
