Garaad diinle
Ah yes here we go again. I guess our inherent biases are bubbling up again. Samale was arab? Really? Well what arab clan did he came from? What sort of genetic population does samale cluster with in the arabian peninsula? Samale parent is name abroone is this an arab name? What is this about the destruction of the original inhabitants of somalia? Somalis are genetically and linguistically related to other cushitic people in the horn, oh wait don't tell me that these cushitic people are also arabs who came after the destruction of the original inhabitants? These sort of narratives are disingenuous and fictitious. You might as well say that somalis came from the moon while your at it.
Arabs were arabs before islam they didn't suddenly turn into a single nation with fabricated clans when islam came to be. Banu hashim trace origin to a man named hashim. He was not muslim and lived in the jahiliyah period. If we're going to use examples we should use the right ones.
Wallahi i can't believe that what i'm saying is controversial now. Samale is not arab and they existed before islam. The samale clans are the clans that these who claim arab origin married into and became somalisized in the process. This means the somali identiy lay within the sab and samale clans.
The sab somalis are genetically related to the samale clans more so than any other cushitic people in the horn and they share a common ancestor. The claim that they came into somalia from arsi is a baseless claim. If you have evidence please share them with us. One can present examples analogies and narrative till their hearts content but nothing beats hard cold evidence. How about we let the real somalis of the past explain to us who were the somalis who lived in somalia before islam.
I usually don't like to speak about such stuff because it encourages the somali gaals to act up but history is history no matter what. A lot of people hate the name somali and considered a recent invention. Well we have sab iyo samale instead who are the somalis who lived in somalia before islam.
Arabs were arabs before islam they didn't suddenly turn into a single nation with fabricated clans when islam came to be. Banu hashim trace origin to a man named hashim. He was not muslim and lived in the jahiliyah period. If we're going to use examples we should use the right ones.
Wallahi i can't believe that what i'm saying is controversial now. Samale is not arab and they existed before islam. The samale clans are the clans that these who claim arab origin married into and became somalisized in the process. This means the somali identiy lay within the sab and samale clans.
The sab somalis are genetically related to the samale clans more so than any other cushitic people in the horn and they share a common ancestor. The claim that they came into somalia from arsi is a baseless claim. If you have evidence please share them with us. One can present examples analogies and narrative till their hearts content but nothing beats hard cold evidence. How about we let the real somalis of the past explain to us who were the somalis who lived in somalia before islam.
I usually don't like to speak about such stuff because it encourages the somali gaals to act up but history is history no matter what. A lot of people hate the name somali and considered a recent invention. Well we have sab iyo samale instead who are the somalis who lived in somalia before islam.
Last edited: