Social and Economic Developments in Pre-Islamic Somalia: Introducing African-Arabian-Mediterranean Interaction

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
source:

On the basis of linguistic comparisons, and to some extent archaeological and botanical accounts, the development of food production in the Horn has been rooted in grain cultivation and animal adoption that took place around 10,000 BP. Archaeologically, cultivation developed from an intensive collection of wild grains, which date back to 16,000 BP and earlier in the Nile Valley over the Sudanese–Egyptian border. Interrelated crop collection was generally practiced in the broad region of North and Northeast Africa together with the Near East, also known as the Fertile Crescent. Northeast Africa, particularly the Nile Valley, has been identified as the region in which grass collecting was first invented and from which its eventual spread occurred.


The main crops included sorghum, barley, wheat, daafi or teff, eleusine, chickpea, and bun or coffee, with their types naturally subject to climatic geography. It has been estimated that the African side of the Red Sea had a Mediterranean winter rainfall climate during the early period of crop collection. The cultivation of these crops is attributed to the rise of Afroasiatic societies, which used food production as a tool to expand over large parts of Africa and the Near East.

The timespan of Proto-Cushitic separation, as a branch of Afroasiatic, has been estimated at 6,000 to 10,000 BP. These developments led some researchers to postulate that the Horn of Africa is one of two primary candidates for being the ancestral home of Afroasiatic, the other being the Iraq–Levant area. In the Horn, the domestication of sorghum, daafi, chickpeas, and animal species has been attributed to the Cushites, while the domestication of eleusine has been linked to the Omotic. It remains uncertain whether this domestication was invented in the Horn or modeled from practices elsewhere.

Researchers recognize three main stages of domestication. The first is independent domestication of indigenous crops and animals, as with wheat, pea, and olive in the Near East around 12,000 BP, and sheep and goat around 10,000 BP. The second is importing the idea of domestication from primary or secondary origins, as with wheat in Egypt and the rest of Northeast Africa, and chickpeas in the Somali region, which are thought to have come from the Near East. The third is learned domestication leading to further local domestication, where the adoption of food producers such as sorghum and cattle may have encouraged the adoption of barley and camels, both raised in the Horn for thousands of years. It is still not known whether the earliest Cushitic and Omotic ancestors invented their domestication, or borrowed the idea from earlier cultures of the Near East or Lower Nile Valley, nor is it clear whether they were always native Africans or entered the Horn from the Levant.

In 1926, agronomist Nikolai Vavilov considered Somalia and the Horn of Africa as one of the world’s independent centers of agricultural development. He based his conclusion on the existence of more than sixty indigenous species of grain crops, vegetables, oil plants, spices, and stimulants in the region.

The first-known speakers in the Horn were not simply dependent on external influence for resource use. Linguistic comparisons, especially of economic vocabulary, provide valuable clues to complement archaeological knowledge. These comparisons help explore the time and location of Somali nationhood. Much of this lexical inventory was compiled by Christopher Ehret in 1995, though some lexemes are omitted here due to lack of clarity.

The purpose of these comparisons is to show how many agricultural and economic terms are shared across Somali, Arabic, and Egyptian. A few also appear in other branches of Cushitic such as Eastern Cushitic, Southern Cushitic, Northern Cushitic (Beja), and Central Cushitic (Agaw), but none occur in Chadic. In total, more than 57 lexemes are compared, of which 23 relate to grain production, 23 to animal adoption, and 3 to the use of metal. The last eight words suggest that Proto–Eastern Cushitic, at least, shared some practices of clothing, housing, and village formation with Egyptians and some Semitic speakers.


Lexical Comparisons:


  • Ber (farm): Somali beer; SC baar (grain); Egyptian pert (crop).
  • Adb (farmland): Somali adab; Egyptian adb.
  • Abur (cultivate): Somali abuur; HEC abuurto; Agaw baruw; SC burubure (cultivation ground).
  • Harqot (plough): Hadiya and Kambata harqota (ox); Oromo harkot; Somali harqot (qo’i, farmer); Saho aro’ut.
  • Qambar (yoke): EC (Sidamo) qambari; Oromo kambari; Somali qambari; Agaw (Chamira) qamara.
  • Nuw (to plough): Agaw nuw; Beja niu.
  • ‘Ar (cultivate): Somali ‘arra (soil, land); Egyptian arit (plough); Arabic ḥarth (cultivate).
  • Sarn (wheat): Somali sareen (also soor); Afar–Saho sareen; Hadiya serat (sorghum); Beja seram (barley); Egyptian sart (wheat, barley).
  • Masanga (sorghum): Somali masango; Oromo misinga; Hadiya masinka; Duley masinka; SC musange (grain); Omotic (Kafa) masingo.
  • Dr (sorghum): Chadic (Hausa) dawa; Dira dawro (pennisetum); Matkam dawn; Arabic ḋarra; Omotic (Chara) dara; Cushitic (Afar) daro (grain).
  • Daaf (food): LEC daafi; Somali dheef (food); Agaw taf, tab; Egyptian dfa (food); Omotic (Gimira tempo, Kafa teppo, wheat); Ethiopic tef; Chadic def (porridge); Arabic (Ḥadramawt) ṭahaf (local grain).
  • Baad (food): Somali baad; Egyptian pat.
  • Bur (flour): Arabic bur; Somali bur; Agaw (Chamira) bura (grits); Chadic (Bachama) burey (gruel).
  • Buḋ (flour): Somali buḋo (flour); Oromo–Konso buḋiina (bread); Chadic (Bole) budu (flour). The root appears related to Arabic bath. Somali also uses buḋo, biḋi, and bus (powder, dust).
 

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
  • Hr (grain): Beja harro (sorghum); Agaw ar (sorghum); Somali shura (porridge); Chadic: Bura vari, Sura war, Hwona yara (gruel).
  • Kbz (bread): Semitic khubz; Somali kimis/kimiz; Egyptian kebes (cultivate, sack for cereals).
  • Fut (soap, flour): LEC fuut/futa; Beja futi; Chadic: Banana futa, Ngizima epta (flour).
  • Mooye (wooden mill for grain): Somali mooye; Oromo mooye; Afar–Saho motoka.

The Proto-Cushitic people clearly knew the terms for farm, cultivate, and plough, and they shared some of these with Egyptians and, to a lesser extent, with Semitic speakers. Cushitic societies widely consumed sorghum, daafi (teff), barley, and wheat, and they processed these cereals into flour, porridge, or bread.

Although the term masanga for sorghum was dominant among Cushitics, it was elsewhere called dar, har, and other variations. Evidence suggests that Proto-Cushitic speakers domesticated daafi and were directly involved in the domestication of sorghum. Calibrated archaeological findings indicate that sorghum was cultivated by about 6,000 BP in the Sahel, stretching from central Sudan to Senegal. Further evidence shows that sorghum was grown by 8,000 BP near Khartoum in central Sudan.

The names of the four cereals—sorghum, daafi, barley, and wheat—were used flexibly among Cushitic, Omotic, Chadic, Egyptian, and Semitic societies. For example, the term sarn or sart referred at different times to wheat, barley, and sorghum. This interchange of crop names suggests that new domesticated products were adopted gradually over centuries, and when a society encountered a new crop, they often gave it a name already familiar to them. Of the eighteen agricultural production terms compared here, only ar and har for sorghum were not identified in Somali.

In the Eastern Horn, the high-altitude zone of Hargeysa–Harar–Bali is a candidate for the early cultivation of daafi, wheat, and barley, including the continued cultivation of barley into medieval times. Since lexemes for cattle, goat, sheep, and donkey were common across Cushitic languages and were shared with at least two other Afroasiatic branches, it is clear that Proto-Cushitic societies were breeding these animals.

Animal Lexemes:


  • Lo’ (cattle): Somali lo’; Afar la; Oromo loa; Werezi lo’o (cow); Chadic: Mubi la; Semitic: Akkadian lu (bull).
  • Sa‘ (cow): Somali sa‘ or se; Burji se; Beja sa/sha; Chadic: Hausa sa.
  • Ywo (bull): Southern Cushitic yawo; Beja yo; Egyptian yow (cow).
  • ‘Oot (livestock): Somali ‘oot; Egyptian ‘ot.
  • Soof/m (going to graze): Somali soof; Arabic soom.
  • Raa‘ (sheepherding): Somali raa‘; Arabic raa‘.
  • Har (donkey): Oromo hare; Saho hera; Agaw (Bilin) huwer; Dahalo (SC) hella (zebra); Semitic hamir. Somali damer may show a transition between Semitic and Cushitic.
  • Ar (goat/sheep): Somali ari (goat and sheep); Semitic: Southeast Arabian erin (goat/sheep); Arabic aram, ri’am (white deer); LEC ri’ (goat).
  • ‘Anz (young goat): Somali ‘enzan or ‘eesan; Arabic ‘anz; Akkadian ‘anzan.
  • Org (he-goat): Somali orgi; Oromo orge; Konso orket; Werezi orke; Burji yirga; Yaku org (male giraffe); Beja argin (ram); South Cushitic ogur. Somali agoor refers to a young he-camel.
  • Sanga: Somali and Afar sange (castrated stallion or he-goat); Oromo sanga (ox); South Cushitic sanga.
  • Ida (sheep, plural): Somali ido; Afar ida; Sumerian udu.
  • La (sheep, singular): LEC la; South Cushitic la (he-goat).
  • Beg (sheep): Agaw bega; Chadic (Fali) bega; Omotic (Kafa) baggo.
  • Rangena (ewe lamb): Beja rangana; South Cushitic rangina.
  • Yab (goat kid): Egyptian yb (kid); Beja ab (kid); South Cushitic af (goat).
  • Gamal (camel): Semitic gamal; LEC gaal (< gamal).
  • Awr (he-camel, bull): Somali awr; Afar awr (bull); Arabic thawr (bull).

Metal and Weapon Terms:


  • Bir (steel): LEC bir. Oromo lost the term and borrowed sibiil from Duley. Semitic (N and W) brzl. Sumerian an-bar.
  • Tum (metallurgy): All Lowland East Cushitic tum; Werezi of Duley tuu’.
  • Toor (dagger): Somali toori; Yaku toor; South Cushitic (Mbugu) toora; Omotic groups toora.
  • Bilawe (dagger): Macro-Somali bilaawe; Konso bilaawa; Oromo bilaa; Afar balade.
  • Waram (spear): Somali waram > waran (Bayso jeren); Oromo waran; Konso worana; Werezi woran; Afar maḥadha. Somali maḥaad refers to a long spike for weaving mats.
  • Samay (spear grip): Somali samay; Duley samay; Afar soomaya.
  • Gudum (axe): Somali gudum > gudin; Afar gudma; Arabic qaduma. Konso erka; Burji irka or yirgi; Omotic yere or yergi.
 

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
Household and Social Lexemes:


  • Gud (cut by knife): Somali gud, guz/gus; Omotic (Maji) kudz/khudz.
  • Dhis (build): Somali dhis; Afar dhis; Konso dhis (farm); Oromo dhis (extend).
  • Min / Man (house): Nearly all Eastern Cushitic min or man; Arabic manzil and maskan (from sakan); Somali sugan (settled).
  • Ghurf (house): Somali guri (house), guur (moving house), gurbi (picking up house things); Arabic ghurfa (room), ghurf (picking up house things).
  • Hoy / Hu (house/cloth): Somali hoy (house, living environment); Egyptian ho (living environment); Somali hu’ (clothes); Oromo–Konso u’ (clothes).
  • Ham (water or milk vessel): Somali ham > han; Egyptian hm.
  • Makhr / Bakhr (grain storage): Somali bakhar; Egyptian mkhr (grain storage).
  • Hap / Hab (system, order): Somali hab < hap?; Egyptian hp.
  • Wat / Wad (drive, road): Somali wat/wad (drive), wado (road); Egyptian wat/wad (drive).


In addition to the above economic comparisons, I also examined 207 core words compiled by Paul Black as a cognate comparison for 18 Eastern Cushitic languages. These include six macro-Somali members (Somali, Rendille, Bayso, Dasanech, Arbore, and Elmolo), four Oromo–Konso languages (Boran Oromo, main Konso, and two dialects), Afar–Saho, Gwada (a member of macro-Dullay), and Hadiya (a member of Highland Eastern Cushitic).

The goal was to identify from Black’s collection the vocabularies that could be considered Afroasiatic, confirmed by comparison with non-Cushitic Afroasiatic languages, avoiding any clear cases of borrowing. Arabic was fully available for this comparison, and Egyptian was used wherever surviving records permitted.

In total, there are 57 words that can be considered Afroasiatic cognates. Since the detailed data are in Black’s work, and I documented them elsewhere, I only list these 57 words in English here:

all, back, breast, call, catch, die, dog, dust, earth, eat, fall, far, finger, go, grass, green, hair, he, hear, hit, I, kill, know, meat, milk, moon, mountain, mouth, neck, nose, pull, red, river, road, scratch, see, seven, sing, sky, smoke, sun, tail, three, throw, tie, two, water, we, what, who, wipe, you.

This set represents two-thirds of Black’s 207 core words.

In detail, the Somali–Egyptian cognates include: all, dog, hair, nose, moon, river, road, sky, sing, sun, tie, and water. Three of these (all, nose, and water) are also shared with Arabic. Altogether, Somali–Arabic cognates number 26 words, which is about one-quarter of the 207-word core list.

Almost all Eastern Cushitic languages share 20 cognates with Arabic, including catch, he, I, nose, scratch, seven, three, we, who, and you. Either Afar–Saho or Oromo–Konso adds eight more (far, grass, mouth, red, see, sun, tie, and what). Thus, the non-Somali Lowland Eastern Cushitic languages share 29 of the 26 Somali–Arabic cognates. Finally, Gawada of Dullay contributes at least one more (call).

The big difference between Somali and other Eastern Cushitic (EC) languages in their cognation with Arabic and Egyptian may partly reflect knowledge bias, since the present author can more readily ascertain Somali than the other Cushitic languages. However, this ascertainment can still temporarily serve as an indication of what may be expected in the cognation between Cushitic and the two other branches.


It is true that pre-Islamic Arabic loanwords may sometimes disguise themselves as cognates. Yet this does not necessarily favor a southern origin, since the Northerners were not themselves from the south. A forthcoming revised study suggests that the relationship between Somali and Arabic is far deeper than usually assumed—covering lexical, phonological, morphological, and grammatical comparisons. The Somali–Egyptian cognation also appears to be at an unexpected level.


For instance, why is Somali the only Cushitic language that shares with Egyptian the word for dog (Somali ay, Egyptian ayu)? All other Lowland Eastern Cushitic languages call the animal karre, a word absent in main Somali. This is but one example among many [ref: 𞟟].


Taking the economic lexemes and the Black core lexemes together, it becomes clear that Somali does not contain a substratum. The Somali language did not lose contact with Arabic and Egyptian, nor was it exposed to any earlier or stronger culture that might have replaced such connections. Its residence in a wide peninsula, surrounded inland by related languages, helped it sustain a relative closeness to Proto-Afroasiatic.
 

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
I highly recommend everyone to read the full publication; I just posted a snippet to attract attention, funny enough, we have all come to similar conclusions. I'll be keeping an eye on Said M. Shidad Hussein's future publications.
 

cunug3aad

3rdchild · Timo gaaljecel
The Somali–Egyptian cognation also appears to be at an unexpected level.


For instance, why is Somali the only Cushitic language that shares with Egyptian the word for dog (Somali ay, Egyptian ayu)? All other Lowland Eastern Cushitic languages call the animal karre, a word absent in main Somali. This is but one example among many [ref: 𞟟].


Taking the economic lexemes and the Black core lexemes together, it becomes clear that Somali does not contain a substratum. The Somali language did not lose contact with Arabic and Egyptian, nor was it exposed to any earlier or stronger culture that might have replaced such connections. Its residence in a wide peninsula, surrounded inland by related languages, helped it sustain a relative closeness to Proto-Afroasiatic.
The researchers are slowly waking up :banderas:
 

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
International trade in Somalia dates back nearly 5,000 years, with different nations participating at different times. These included the Arabs, Egyptians, Sumero-Akkadians, Phoenicians, Israelites, Persians, Indians, Greeks, and Romans. As Heeren observed, Somalia’s products, its location, and its trade-oriented culture sustained the popularity of its markets.


Among these nations, ancient Egypt is seen as the first and most involved trading partner. The evidence is mostly indirect, based on the location of the Land of Punt in Egyptian records. For the last two centuries, most Egyptologists and historians have identified Punt with Northern Somalia, which uniquely fits the descriptions of the homeland of rare products that the Egyptians desired. The Puntite connection in Egyptian history may date as far back as the pre-dynastic period, but the recorded trade covered approximately 4,500–3,000 years BP, during Egypt’s greatest era.

Recent archaeology at Marsa Gawassis, near the Red Sea, has confirmed the traditional belief that Egyptians sailed from there to Punt. Excavations revealed well-preserved remains of seagoing ships, rigging ropes, timbers, anchors, and cargo boxes. Some boxes carried inscriptions such as “wonderful things from Punt,” including references to Pharaoh Amenemhat IV.

Given the religious dimension of Egyptian trade, Puntite supplies were not only valued commercially but also spiritually. Egypt even called Punt the “land of the gods.” Products like gold, ebony, dogs, frankincense, and myrrh were considered sacred. Myrrh, frankincense, and cinnamon were especially prized. Egyptian records mention Punt for nearly two millennia, suggesting that the name may sometimes have been generalized for different areas in Northeast Africa. Still, there was a “Punt proper”, defined by its unique exports and symbolic value.

One of the earliest recorded missions was dispatched by Pharaoh Sahure (c. 4,400 years BP), bringing back incense, gold, silver, and ebony. Nearly a thousand years later, Queen Hatshepsut’s famous expedition (c. 3,500 years BP) to Punt returned with myrrh, incense, gold, ebony, cosmetics, monkeys, dogs, and leopard skins.


Incense, frankincense and myrrh were central to Egyptian ritual and burial practices. Archaeological finds confirm its use as early as 3,800 years BP. The tomb of Tutankhamen (c. 3,300 years BP) still retained the fragrance of Puntite frankincense at its discovery, later confirmed to be a Somali variety (Boswellia neglecta), superior to Arabian alternatives. Ancient writers such as the author of the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea and Herodotus also noted that Northern Somalia and Southeast Arabia were the only exporters of true incense.

Cinnamon, though debated in origin (Southeast Asia or Somalia), was widely distributed through Somali ports. Greco-Roman and Israelite sources repeatedly cited it as a Somali specialty. Strabo described the interior of Cape Guardafui (Qarfuuna) as the land of cinnamon, frankincense, and myrrh, while Pliny the Elder (d. 79 CE) and Dioscorides identified Somali cities such as Mosyllum (likely Ceelaayo or Bosaso) as cinnamon-exporting hubs. The Periplus further detailed ports like Berbera, Mosyllum, Caluula, Tabai, and Xaafuun, highlighting their distinct aromatic and spice trades.

The Egyptian, Greek, and Roman traditions interwove with Somali trade. For example, Pliny referred to Zaylac as the “Port of Isis,” reflecting Egyptian cultural links. Laasgeel rock art depicting ankle rings resembles the adornments of Puntite rulers described in Hatshepsut’s records, suggesting cultural continuity.

Egyptian involvement in Somali trade may have sparked wider international interest in Somali markets. The Sumero-Akkadians traded with Melukhkha (identified with Somalia) in the 3rd–2nd millennium BCE, while King Solomon’s expedition to Ophir (10th century BCE) is believed to have reached Northern Somalia. Phoenicians, who led Solomon’s expedition, may have already been active in the Horn, and Herodotus later reported Phoenician sailors reaching Xaafuun under Pharaoh Necho (c. 600 BCE).

The Sabaeans of Yemen soon became key intermediaries, importing Somali aromatics for re-export to the Levant and Mesopotamia. This period coincided with the rise of the Arabian caravan trade. The famous story of the Queen of Sheba’s visit to King Solomon reflects the shared commercial and cultural exchanges of this era.

Somali evidence also shows Yemeni connections. Recently discovered monumental Sabaean inscriptions on seven stone blocks near Qarfuuna and Xaafuun, dated by epigraphers to the 1st millennium BCE, record a Yemeni king’s naval expedition to Somalia. These inscriptions combine religious devotion with testimony of commercial contact, further proving the depth of Somali–Arabian trade relations.
 

NidarNidar

♚kṯr w ḫss♚
VIP
1757634684406.png


At approximately 2160 BP, other sites also yielded inscriptions, which reveal that the Sabaeans heavily depended on Somali products for their large trade in incense. A Sabaean inscription consisting of only four letters on a stone block, which is part of a tomb, was also observed near the coastal town of Shal‘aw, 25 km southwest of the ancient port of Xiis. Two stone blocks recently found at Xaafuun also carry Sabaean inscriptions.


The date of the Abdixan inscriptions was about two centuries after the visit of the Queen of Saba to King Solomon. This may serve as evidence for the inspired judgment of Cosmas Indicopleustes, who journeyed through the northern coast of Somalia around the sixth century CE.

In 525 CE, Cosmas Indicopleustes stated that the Queen of Saba “brought to Solomon spices from this very Barbaria [Somalia], which lay near Saba on the other side of the sea.” It is noteworthy that in 545 CE, when Cosmas completed his book, Somalia was still believed to be the home of these products, even by a knowledgeable Egyptian merchant who traveled as far as Sri Lanka. His nickname, Indicopleustes, expressed his experience in India.


The unique role of Somalia in the Horn of Africa for regional trade was also noted by Claudius Ptolemy around 150 CE. He singled out the country for being a commercial partner of Yemen with the largest number of trade centers.


Trade between Somalia and Arabia must have existed long before and after the inscriptions. Agatharchides, writing around 150 BCE, noted an increase in Yemeni presence in Somalia. Describing the Sabaeans and Phoenicians as the richest nations in the world, he reported that the Sabaeans traveled and had settlements in the land of aromatics. This mention of the Aromatic Land reflects a period when the Greeks were struggling to join the commerce of the Qarfuuna region.


Agents of the Greek king of Egypt, Ptolemy Euergetes (d. 221 BCE), were said to have reached Mosyllum. Meanwhile, the Greeks sent a traveler named Ariston to Somalia, who named northern Somalia after the Greek sea idol Poseidon. A Greek tradition also mentioned that some travelers led by Yambul were captured in northern Somalia. A non-Greek sailor, possibly from the region, also led Greeks to Qarfuuna and further to India around 299 BCE.


The information provided by Agatharchides (150 BCE) and Artemidorus (100 BCE) suggests that Greek-Egyptian merchants were visiting ports in the Qarfuuna region by this time.


Strabo’s report from about 20 BCE indicates the immediate Roman interest in Somali trade. This interest was directed toward the region of aromatics, as it had taken the Greeks nearly four centuries to reach the southern Somali coast after they began dealing with the northern one. Strabo explained the geography and commercial importance of the Qarfuuna region, noting: “Large fleets are dispatched as far as India and the extremities of Aethiopia, from which the most valuable cargoes are brought to Egypt and thence sent forth again to the other regions.” At that time, the extremities of Aethiopia referred to the Qarfuuna region, which he himself called the “Southern Horn.”


A Roman ruler of the Moroccan coast, Juba (d. 23 CE), also reported on the region, though he confused Boosaaso with Qarfuuna. Pliny clarified Juba’s mistake, noting: “Juba holds that at Cape Mossylites begins the Atlantic Ocean, navigable with a north-west wind along the coast of his kingdom of Mauretania.” Juba seemed to have some knowledge of the Horn, differentiating northern Somalia from the southern coast, calling the latter the “Atlantic,” and imagining it immediately connected to Mauretania.


Pliny’s remarks reconcile Strabo and Juba, as he added: “Some writers place one Aethiopian town on the coast beyond this point [Mosyllum].” However, Xaafuun marked the limit of the Greco-Roman known world, as they had no knowledge of southern Somalia. Strabo further explained: “After doubling this cape toward the south, we have no more descriptions of harbors or places, because nothing is known of the seacoast beyond this point.”


Knowledge of the southern Somali coast would have to wait until the author of the Periplus of the Erythraean Sea, who followed in the footsteps of the Yemenis.
 
I highly recommend everyone to read the full publication; I just posted a snippet to attract attention, funny enough, we have all come to similar conclusions. I'll be keeping an eye on Said M. Shidad Hussein's future publications.
Does he publish in somali? Where can I get his works?
 

Trending

Top