Should we Balkanize SomaliWeyne?

[The Somali Caesar]

I think we all naturally have a bias for or against Balkanisation it really depends on your tribe and what region you hail from.

Those bias are mostly from an emotional standpoint rather than a logical/rational stand point. My question is purely from a rational perspective would Somalis be better off/or not If it became Balkanized.

(please give your reasons and let’s have civil conversation thanks)

 

[FinestFaarax]

no need for balkanisation Asmara to Addis to Nairobi and everything btw will be inshaAllah called Ogadenia

 

[The Somali Caesar]

no need for balkanisation Asmara to Addis to Nairobi and everything btw will be inshaAllah called Ogadenia

I’m just going out on a limb here are you an Ogadeen

 

[Ras]

No

 

[Ras]

Right now there's a chance for reconciliation but once we split we'll have a million reasons to fight.

Borders, resources, control over JL etc.

That doesn't even include the many ways our enemies could set us against each other.

Current situation sucks but a balkanized Somalia will be 100x worse than the balkan wars.

 

[Maakahiil]

Somaliweyn is a myth

 

[Somali Napolean]

No, unlike the Balkans we are all the same ethnicity we are divided due to civil fallout. We just need to come together and talk without so much pride for a better future.

 

[Saeedlfc]

Yes, each major clan should have their own country.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

No, unlike the Balkans we are all the same ethnicity we are divided due to civil fallout. We just need to come together and talk without so much pride for a better future.

Not true

 

[abdullah233]

It seems to be happening sl wants ictraf pl wants ictraf nfd and k5 are not ours. It’s sad what Somalia has become

 

[abdullah233]

Not true

Darrod and hawiye kkk

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

Darrod and hawiye kkk

Lets celebrate our diversity is all im saying boowe.

 

[TheSayid]

you can't accurately balkanize most of somalia especially south and central

 

[Jiron]

No, because the division never stops there, the same cycle will repeat again but this time on sub sub clan level and so on. We all have to work together in order to come out of this misery

 

[Abdillahi]

No, unlike the Balkans we are all the same ethnicity we are divided due to civil fallout. We just need to come together and talk without so much pride for a better future.

Which is one of the major reasons why Somaliland won't get a seat on the U.N as a separate country. Pandora's box is what the west does not want to open.