Reaction: Nouman Ali Khan on Women's Leadership in Islam

[AMusee]

I criticize some statements from Nouman Ali Khan in the latest reaction video, but I also acknowledge in the same video that I respect NAK for his Arabic instruction program and how he has inspired millions to learn Arabic in order to connect with the Quran. His program is innovative and I appreciate the ingenuity. This is a major service he has done for the Umma.

I also distinguish NAK from other Compassionate Imams in that he does not try to cash in on cheap political participation. He doesn't march with the rainbow flag, have iftar with the turban hijabis, or shake hands with head zionists, etc. He could easily do that in the same way that others do, but he doesn't. He does not betray the Umma in the way that others regularly do.

This appreciation does not prevent us from criticizing problematic statements NAK has made in his lectures and ideas he has promoted. Sadly, he has flirted with the ideas of certain reformists and modernists and injected them into an otherwise positive message. We need to push back on this.

As I always offer with those I criticize, I am happy to host NAK on this channel to give him the chance to defend his statements and/or clarify.

- DH

 

[a_bilan]

What channel? You think NAK is going to come onto sspot?

 

[jemappelle]

What channel? You think NAK is going to come onto sspot?

- DH

 

[induction]

I criticize some statements from Nouman Ali Khan in the latest reaction video, but I also acknowledge in the same video that I respect NAK for his Arabic instruction program and how he has inspired millions to learn Arabic in order to connect with the Quran. His program is innovative and I appreciate the ingenuity. This is a major service he has done for the Umma.

I also distinguish NAK from other Compassionate Imams in that he does not try to cash in on cheap political participation. He doesn't march with the rainbow flag, have iftar with the turban hijabis, or shake hands with head zionists, etc. He could easily do that in the same way that others do, but he doesn't. He does not betray the Umma in the way that others regularly do.

This appreciation does not prevent us from criticizing problematic statements NAK has made in his lectures and ideas he has promoted. Sadly, he has flirted with the ideas of certain reformists and modernists and injected them into an otherwise positive message. We need to push back on this.

As I always offer with those I criticize, I am happy to host NAK on this channel to give him the chance to defend his statements and/or clarify.

- DH

heard he got caught spitting game in the dms of females

 

[a_bilan]

- DH

oh.. makes sense.

 

[TekNiKo]

Salafis are coming after Nouman Cali Khan now? Is there any decent Sheikh safe from their tongue?

 

[jemappelle]

Salafis are coming after Nouman Cali Khan now? Is there any decent Sheikh safe from their tongue?

 

[induction]

 

[Omar del Sur]

Salafis are coming after Nouman Cali Khan now? Is there any decent Sheikh safe from their tongue?

Haqiqatjou is not a Salafi.

 

[TekNiKo]

Hide the sins of your brother lest Allah exposes you on the DoJ. This could be scandalous photoshop

 

[jemappelle]

Hide the sins of your brother lest Allah exposes you on the DoJ. This could be scandalous photoshop

its public information and also warning people of listening to him

 

[jemappelle]

Hide the sins of your brother lest Allah exposes you on the DoJ. This could be scandalous photoshop

https://www.somalispot.com/threads/somali-model-exposes-sheikh-on-instagram.133278/page-8#post-3318952

 

[Awad]

What's wrong with his delts?

 

[Yaraye]

damn... he didn't even say salaam or anything nice. straight to the point with "hey you" and "be mine"

 

[Yaraye]

a lot of these sheiks are fake wallahi. I listen for educational purposes but we need to remember not to look at them as role models

 

[Periplus]

Nouman Ali Khan got me-too’d years ago.

No wonder @AMusee is talking about him.

 

[World]

why you sharing his private life? you exposing his sins is worse than what he done.

 

[Hamzza]

Haqiqatjou is not a Salafi.

Why is Haqiqatjou not Salafi? Who canceled him from Salafism?

 

[Omar del Sur]

Why is Haqiqatjou not Salafi? Who canceled him from Salafism?

It's not that some person "canceled him from Salafism". He just objectively is not a Salafi.



you can see clearly in the clip- he isn't even really pro-Salafi. I could go into more stuff on the topic but that's just off the top of my head and it's very blatantly obvious that he isn't a Salafi. but whether I dig into more material on the topic or not, he objectively is not a Salafi, independently of what myself or anyone says.

edit: this is another video worth watching on the subject



Haqiqatjou is basically some sort of ikhwani in terms of minhaj. it's very important that we distinguish Salafis from ikhwani types.