That doesn’t mean Dir came from Yemen 3000 years ago where does it say that Dir specifically came from Yemen“The Somali T comes from serious Semitic stock probably related to Eblaite peoples or one of those influential groups in the Syrian region, regardless, essentially a native lineage of that region since the Neolithic and Chalcolithic to Bronze Age. Then they lived in Arabia between 800 to a couple of thousand years (because not sure when T-Y45591 migrated to the Arabian Peninsula between 6800-2800 years BP (guessing 1000-2000 years, maybe due to later so-called BA Collapse?)), and then they came to the promising northern Somali shores some 2000 years ago”
Dirs fall under hapalgroup TThat doesn’t mean Dir came from Yemen 3000 years ago where does it say that Dir specifically came from Yemen
Somalis have been tracking their lineage for hundreds of years please don’t say thatScience > Somali fairytales story
where are the historical accounts that say Dir as a qabil came from Yemen Dir didn’t even exist 3000 years agoDirs fall under hapalgroup T
Somalis isn’t a thing before islamSomalis have been tracking their lineage for hundreds of years please don’t say that
If dir are yemeni wouldnt that make their hawiye siblings yemeni too?Somalis have been tracking their lineage for hundreds of years please don’t say that
That’s the whole pointwhere are the historical accounts that say Dir as a qabil came from Yemen Dir didn’t even exist 3000 years ago
We have been an ethnicity for a long time though imagine saying after the year 610 Somalis came into existenceSomalis isn’t a thing before islam
One thing we know 3000 years ago dirs came from Arabian Peninsula
Dirs and haiwye ain’t relatedIf dir are yemeni wouldnt that make their hawiye siblings yemeni too?
dir aren’t AjnabiThat’s the whole point
Dirs fall under haplogroup T which shows they came from Yemen to northern Somalia around 2000-3000 years ago .
Dirs existed but they wasn’t called dirs
Whats your tribe?Dirs and haiwye ain’t related
Haiwye are Ev32 while dirs are T
They intermarry each other hence why the autosomali isn’t different between them
@Step a side explain to themWe have been an ethnicity for a long time though imagine saying after the year 610 Somalis came into existence
we barely share landsDirs and haiwye ain’t related
Haiwye are Ev32 while dirs are T
They intermarry each other hence why the autosomali isn’t different between them
3000 years ago ? Ofc they’re but now ? Nodir aren’t Ajnabi
KaranleWhats your tribe?
I don’t know how this thread derailed to this I could care less about haplogroups I genuinely don’t care .@Step a side explain to them
I can’t explain to you because I don’t know enough what was Somalis before islam
Those T people who came from Arabia as you said were not dir that’s not how it works3000 years ago ? Ofc they’re but now ? No
Their autosomali is the same as any other Somali
Isn’t big of a dealI don’t know how this thread derailed to this I could care less about haplogroups I genuinely don’t care .
What makes u say that ? (also it’s semetic group but not arab )Those T people who came from Arabia as you said were not dir that’s not how it works