@Step a side
You've yet to provide any evidence to counter except for your own word. I put the history down in front of you so bring your own receipts and we can talk.
You learned who cerulli is today
View attachment 348987
30000 harti ghost soldiers

I don’t want to derail this thread any further. This will be my last reply on this topic
Saxib your history starts with Siyaad Baree. Ahmed Gurey, Amir Nur and Mahfuz were all Karanle. The books (several), the geographical landscape (highland Karanle nomads built for war strategem), the settlements around Harar (from Hara"maya" of the northwest to Erer Hawiya in its southeast), the trade (slaves and coffee trade were biggest in Imay's civilisation to Harar), the political influence (every colonialist traveller confirms the superiority of Karanle in character and power in the region) and the religiosity (the tariqa of Harar followed Karanle Salihiya and excerpts of the Muslims of Sidamo, Bale and Nagayle show religious indoctrination from Hawiye) all point to this. There is not a single known MX leader buried in Harar in the last thousand years. You have no historical anecdotes about Amir Nur or how he lived or about his father and brother mentioned in the Futuh while there are videos of the Sixawle Ugaas today who knew the location of where Ahmed Gurey use to give his weekly sermons and where they use to train their horses and fight. You are the Hoteps who cannot explain how a random MX pops up among the list of long ruling families like the Karanle, the Walashma etc while the people of Hobat and Mogadishu are recorded to have been at war with Abysinnia since atleast the 1300s. Even an Abyssinian islamised ex slave once took power in Harar and his son inherited him and replaced him. Do you think Marexaan kursi jecle would just come and go as if they wouldn't seek to take the opportunity? Even the Isaaq sultan of Zeila Haji Shermarke once attempted to make Harar capitulate to his feet.
There is evidence of an outbreak of war between Selassie and the Karanle during the 60s when the French came to visit Galbeed to extract resources on the state's behalf, there is evidence of Karanle involvement in the Bale Revolt, there is evidence of war between Ras Makonnen/Menelik the ancestors of Selassie and the Hawiye tribe during the invasion of Harar. Selassie was born and raised in a Hawiye part of Harar and in Ejersa Goro settled by Xaskul Hawiye as a consequence of the historical conflicts. He was the same emperor who went to war against a majority Hawiye army in 64 and got humbled and forced to sign a ceasefire. A Karanle (Murusade) Colonel wiped out 300 of his soldiers in one battle that the Emperor had never forgotten in a famous story resulting in 2 gold medals for that Colonel. Search up Elmi Nuur. The famous Murusade officer who spoke Amharic due to the amount of time he spent on the field and dealt with military intelligence. History is one of continuity!