Mayor Yusuf Madale collect tax from every business and house in Mogadishu but failed to provide vital services to the people and businesses

[XuseenS]

Discover Popular Videos | Facebook

Video is the place to enjoy videos and shows together. Watch the latest reels, discover original shows and catch up with your favorite creators.

www.facebook.com

This is disgusting wlhi

 

[bidenkulaha]

Banadir barely collects taxes, FGS takes the vast majority of revenue from Xamar so how is Madaale to blame?

Roads need drainage and that’ll take a long term investment

 

[XuseenS]

Banadir barely collects taxes, FGS takes the vast majority of revenue from Xamar so how is Madaale to blame?

Roads need drainage and that’ll take a long term investment

What does it matter, Somalia receives millions in aid, where does the money go?

It's absolutely ridiculous that a capital city can look like this every time it rains.

 

[Ximan iyo Xadeed]

Banadir barely collects taxes, FGS takes the vast majority of revenue from Xamar so how is Madaale to blame?

Roads need drainage and that’ll take a long term investment

The money the FGS takes goes to other HAG states security apparatus maybe Baidoa takes a cut but thats about it.

 

[bidenkulaha]

What does it matter, Somalia receives millions in aid, where does the money go?

It's absolutely ridiculous that a capital city can look like this every time it rains.

Well then blame the NGOs and international donors? Banadir budget has only just passed $50 million. Djibouti with a third of the population is $600 million. Attacking Madaale for this is just low IQ stuff.

A proper drainage and sewage system would cost tens of billions.

 

[bidenkulaha]

The money the FGS takes goes to other HAG states security apparatus maybe Baidoa takes a cut but thats about it.

It primarily goes to ministers/ parliamentarians/civil service which compromises all the states and the SNA.

 

[Aurelian]

This city was abandoned for long time, and on top of that it has a lot of corrupt politicians. Like look at that sea of garbage. That is a recipe for diseases.

 

[Ximan iyo Xadeed]

It primarily goes to ministers/ parliamentarians/civil service which compromises all the states and the SNA.

Federal institutions are funded by the IC usually. Outside of that cut minister salaries and give SNA a raise.

 

[Rationale]

Federal institutions are funded by the IC usually. Outside of that cut minister salaries and give SNA a raise.

I don't want to rant but before N&N it used to be 75% to the FGS and 25% to Banaadir but Farmaajo changed it, when Yariisow died and is today 85% to the FGS and 15% to BRA.

We will keep quiet during this crucial war against the Khwaarij scum, but.....Well once we secure the core, mighty karbaash is in order.

 

[Ximan iyo Xadeed]

I don't want to rant but before N&N it used to be 75% to the FGS and 25% to Banaadir but Farmaajo changed it, when Yariisow died and is today 85% to the FGS and 15% to BRA.

We will keep quiet during this crucial war against the Khwaarij scum, but.....Well once we secure the core, mighty karbaash is in order.

I believe whatever Xamar is taxed for should stay in the city and its environs

 

[Hilmaam]

xamar isn’t specially its welfare state like rest of Somalia

 

[Shaafici Mujaahid]

Banadir barely collects taxes, FGS takes the vast majority of revenue from Xamar so how is Madaale to blame?

Roads need drainage and that’ll take a long term investment

The more things change the more they stay the same. You screamed the same with Farmaajo along with other opposition leaders now you say the same. The fact of the matter is that we need a drainage system now. Farmaajo failed but HSM must not in this because all of the infrastructure will go to waste every rainy season. We cannot be killed by rain and drought in the 21st century.

 

[bidenkulaha]

The more things change the more they stay the same. You screamed the same with Farmaajo along with other opposition leaders now you say the same. The fact of the matter is that we need a drainage system now. Farmaajo failed but HSM must not in this because all of the infrastructure will go to waste every rainy season. We cannot be killed by rain and drought in the 21st century.

Yh of course we need to do something but it’s best we be realistic, blaming a mayor who’s been there months for the usual flooding isn’t it.

Hopefully we can sign some deals with countries for drainage once we start seeing foreign investment

 

[El Nino]

Nothing will change until the general population demands change and accountability.

 

[Shaafici Mujaahid]

Yh of course we need to do something but it’s best we be realistic, blaming a mayor who’s been there months for the usual flooding isn’t it.

Hopefully we can sign some deals with countries for drainage once we start seeing foreign investment

How much do you think it costs to build an effective drainage system along with a sewage system in Mogadishu?

 

[Calaami]

Federal institutions are funded by the IC usually. Outside of that cut minister salaries and give SNA a raise.

This is gonna sound coonish but maybe it’s better if IC actually administered the city leadership, at least until corruption is stamped out.

 

[Rationale]

xamar isn’t specially its welfare state like rest of Somalia View attachment 269246
View attachment 269253

These are super outdated but BRA and Somaliland are the only regions that receive(d) less aid than the revenue they collect.

In my opinion BRA can more than function on its own if it takes 50% of the revenue generated in Xamar, instead of the current 15%. Those projects were at their height 163million and more than 70% of that sum were meant for the IDPs in Banaadir camps.

Do you really think BRA can't operate with an annual budget of 110million? And if no tell me why and what sum do you think is necessary for BRA to be self-sufficient?

 

[Hilmaam]

These are super outdated but BRA and Somaliland are the only regions that receive(d) less aid than the revenue they collect.

In my opinion BRA can more than function on its own if it takes 50% of the revenue generated in Xamar, instead of the current 15%. Those projects were at their height 163million and more than 70% of that sum were meant for the IDPs in Banaadir camps.

Do you really think BRA can't operate with an annual budget of 110million? And if no tell me why and what sum do you think is necessary for BRA to be self-sufficient?

Maybe Xamar probably has best shot and is richest.The main source of FGS funds is Xamar, and more specifically customs duty at port. if all the aid is cut it will definitely have some impact on that 100M. That aid money recirculates multiple times in economy of all of somalia. Without it we will be poorer, less purchasing power and less imports.

110 million divided by 2.5 million mogaidshu citizens = $40 per citizen maybe it works but its very low standard of living. America top 100 cities spend around $2,600 per citizen. City should be funding police teacher roads public utiliites sewer water agricutlutre ... list goes

Mombasa which has population of 1.3 million has expenditure of $105,147,057.73 which is around $80 USD per citiezen.

Xamar can maintain and survive no matter what somalis resilient, its just a question of is goal to maintain or improve and become modern city which will need alot more money and investment