Makkah Imam (Sheikh Saleh Al Talib) jailed for 10 years: What’s Truth?

Omar del Sur

RETIRED
VIP

Jeddah – The dubious report about the arrest and 10-years imprisonment of Makkah Imam Sheikh Saleh Al-Talib by the Saudi authorities is trending on the social media. The report is based on anonymous sources, with the evident Muslim Brotherhood propaganda against the Kingdom.

The report comes from the infamous Muslim Brotherhood news networks namely Middle East Eye, Middle East Monitor (MEMO), pro-Qaeda social media network Documenting Oppression Against Muslims (DOAM), and their Iranian counterparts like Kayhan and Iqna.

According to MEMO, “The Saudi Court of Appeals has sentenced Sheikh Saleh Al-Talib, a prominent imam and preacher at the Grand Mosque in Makkah, to ten years in prison, a human rights organisation said yesterday”.

The source of information is “a human rights organisation”, which in itself is a highly speculative source. Obviously, such critical information can’t come from some random and unnamed “a human rights organisation”.

Further, the report stated that, Imam Al-Talib was arrested in 2018 “after he delivered a sermon on the duty in Islam to speak out against evil in public”.

The source is “social media” advocacy group Prisoners of Conscience (POC), which is a London-based pro-left human rights organization. Iranian born Diba Alikhani is one of the POC’s Trustees.

POC didn’t cite any official statement about the cause of the arrest. It’s been a mystery since 2018, how POC concluded that the Imam was arrested for delivering a sermon on the duty of Islam “to speak against evil in public”.

Interestingly, neither POC nor Muslim Brotherhood news channels, highlight the plight of the Ulema and scholars arrested and killed in the cold-blood by Taliban. For instance, Shaykh Sadar Wali Saquib was abducted and killed under Taliban last month, while dozens of Ulema are rotting in the Talib prisons.
Similarly, there’s no talk about the cases of Muslim scholars of Iran who are killed in the broad day light. For example, Molavi Abdushakour Kord Tarshabi, and a lot like him who are jailed and killed by the Mullah regime in the Baluchestan Province.
It’s as clear as a day that the news of Sheikh Saleh Al-Talib lack verification, and the purpose behind the vile Islamist propaganda is to stir the emotions of the Muslims against Saudi Arabia, King Salman, and Mohammed Bin Salman. In order to disturb the ongoing economic reforms aimed at making Kingdom a self-sufficient power-hub of the Arab civilization.
 

Omar del Sur

RETIRED
VIP
Al-Saluul didn't also reject the sheikh's arrest. It is obvious they're deflecting.

Well I think he definitely was arrested but it hasn't been verified as to why exactly why he was arrested. Verifying information is a pretty important thing in Islam and it's something that we're called to do in the Quran.
 
These people on twitter saying something doesn't make it so. There's no actual verification that he was arrested for the reason that is being alleged.

Do you think every colour and flavour of Muslim brother no matter what new name they use should all be arrested by the state since they are all supporters of Al-Shabaab/kawarij etc ideology ?
 

Omar del Sur

RETIRED
VIP
Do you think every colour and flavour of Muslim brother no matter what new name they use should all be arrested by the state since they are all supporters of Al-Shabaab/kawarij etc ideology ?

I think the group should be outlawed and the masses of people should be informed as to their danger. Many people think the ikhwanis are simply a group that wants the sharia and they don't understand the real nature of this group.

My view is there should be in-depth research and investigation into this criminal group, the public should be informed and the group should outlawed. Then anyone who still is involved with the group should be arrested.

They are a threat to Islam. They promote all kinds of weird reinterpretation of Islam while promoting an image of themselves as champions of Islam.

They are a threat to the national security of every Muslim country. Their ideology forms the basis of pretty much all the modern khawarij groups. They promote civil war and terrorism. They are also anti-patriotism. This is useful to their ideology because removing a person's sense of patriotism helps in making them willing to engage in activities that would destroy their own country.

Anyone who loves Islam and anyone who cares about their country should be wary of this group.

All this is not even mentioning their connection to Freemasonry. They have basically the same ideology as Freemasonry except they just dress it up to make it sound Islamic.
 
Top