Is PL a copycat of SL?

Even the name “Puntland” comes from a ancient voyage made to Saylac (a city in SL). PL looks up and admires SL and wants to be like them so bad. It’s safe to say that PL is the daughter of SL.

6EFDD425-5445-4EB4-95CF-7AE9F9F299F6.jpeg
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
Statehood was not invented by a population that uses khat at a 90% rate. So whether it is in
  1. Literacy rate
  2. Primary school completion rate
  3. Labour force participation
  4. Access to water
  5. Access to sanitation
  6. Per capita income
Puntland performs better.

World Bank Poverty Profile 2017

The poverty profile presents the first Somaliwide assessment of welfare conditions.


Somaliland in numbers
  • Weighted unemployment rate is 50 - 80% (depends on the sources)
  • Youth unemployment is 75%
https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/report/94285/somalia-unemployment-fuels-youth-exodus-somaliland

Literacy rate is 58% (see the World Bank report).

Puntland measures better than Somaliland in all those metrics. An IDP in Bosaso makes more than the average worker in Hargeisa.

"In comparison to Hargeisa, Bosasso residents enjoy a higher standard of living if we compare average daily incomes. While urban residents of Hargeisa earn, on average, about $1 a day, Bosasso residents earn over $4. Naturally, with respect to Bosasso, IDPs earnings are far lower. Most IDP households in Bosasso earn a daily wage of a little over a $1".

 

Bernie Madoff

Afhayeenka SL
VIP
Statehood was not invented by a population that uses khat at a 90% rate. So whether it is in
  1. Literacy rate
  2. Primary school completion rate
  3. Labour force participation
  4. Access to water
  5. Access to sanitation
  6. Per capita income
Puntland performs better.

World Bank Poverty Profile 2017

The poverty profile presents the first Somaliwide assessment of welfare conditions.


Somaliland in numbers
  • Weighted unemployment rate is 50 - 80% (depends on the sources)
  • Youth unemployment is 75%
https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/report/94285/somalia-unemployment-fuels-youth-exodus-somaliland

Literacy rate is 58% (see the World Bank report).

Puntland measures better than Somaliland in all those metrics. An IDP in Bosaso makes more than the average worker in Hargeisa.

"In comparison to Hargeisa, Bosasso residents enjoy a higher standard of living if we compare average daily incomes. While urban residents of Hargeisa earn, on average, about $1 a day, Bosasso residents earn over $4. Naturally, with respect to Bosasso, IDPs earnings are far lower. Most IDP households in Bosasso earn a daily wage of a little over a $1".

Why are you guys keep using the same 2017 world bank report which they admittedly said they did a mistake in it by not doing a proper survey. You are not fooling anyone sxb :mjlol:

61C361A1-9FCD-4637-8C6E-4EA12AAFCA3E.jpeg
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP

Bernie Madoff

Afhayeenka SL
VIP
I knew I was going to get a reply like this. They assessed the North East figures more cause of the anecdotal evidence and look what they got.

View attachment 166352

Again you are using 2017 world bank report where the they knowingly admitted to mistake and said ur region are poorest. What I posted was an update after they wrote that report. How about we post 2019 poverty map and the latest world bank report not one from 4 years ago :mjlol:

17B4FC85-0B37-4D27-8529-E268648D38F0.png
 

repo

Bantu Liberation Movement
VIP
Again you are using 2017 world bank report where the they knowingly admitted to mistake and said ur region are poorest. How about we post 2019 poverty map and the latest world bank report not one from 4 years ago :mjlol:

View attachment 166354
That's not the latest poverty study. That's Estimation of Poverty in Somalia Using Innovative Methodologies, it covers how the Wave 2 worked.

This is what they said about it.

"Despite methodological innovations, field team training, and a stringent security protocol (section 3.2), some challenges with data collection persisted in certain geographic areas. These were mainly related to human resource capacity constraints and remote monitoring to ensure the quality of the data. Specifically, in the Jubbaland and rural North‐East regions, the information collected turned out to be only representative of a very small, idiosyncratic part of the population or did not consistently meet the survey’s high‐quality standards."

It's not reliable according to its own writers. You should try reading what you post.

:snoop:
 

Thegoodshepherd

Galkacyo iyo Calula dhexdood
VIP
Puntland is doing things that every states does. Creating a regional flag, a regional security force, adopting a state constitution, holding elections etc... are things every modern state is expected to do. Anyone who thinks they are exclusive to Somaliland is a retard. Somaliland simply started to build a modern state earlier than Puntland did. Puntland’s constitution, written before any elections in Somaliland, tells the president to hold local and statewide elections as quickly as possible.

Puntland is very different from Somaliland. It has a unicameral parliament without clan elders. It has never claimed to be an independent country, it is less centralized, its governors have real power in their regions, and many other such differences in political structure.
 
Puntland is doing things that every states does. Creating a regional flag, a regional security force, adopting a state constitution, holding elections etc... are things every modern state is expected to do. Anyone who thinks they are exclusive to Somaliland is a retard. Somaliland simply started to build a modern state earlier than Puntland did. Puntland’s constitution, written before any elections in Somaliland, tells the president to hold local and statewide elections as quickly as possible.

Puntland is very different from Somaliland. It has a unicameral parliament without clan elders. It has never claimed to be an independent country, it is less centralized, its governors have real power in their regions, and many other such differences in political structure.
You’re right ever state does, so all states are the children of SL (1991)
 

Trending

Top