I cant have a serious conversation with you if you become emotional. You think me saying they are the same people have anything to do with Israel. You have a derangement syndrome. Remove Israel from the picture entirely for a second and pretend they dont exist and go back to the topic. You are getting emotional and unable to talk about it objectively. Perhaps you are Arab or have family there. My apologies if I came across rude or insensitive. But in this forum we can discuss Somali topics, tribes, wars where I know many people directly related to me that died in without losing my shit. Hell I know people related to ne directly who died in Yemen and some who live there now. I have family in Ethiopia as well. My uncle was butchered during Black Hawk Down and I can engage in that conversation without losing my shit and getting upset.Once you started spewing the ignorance, claiming Egyptians and Jordanians are the same people as Palestinians, is when you lost the plot, perpetuating Zionist talking points, and still try to present yourself as a reasonable actor in this conversation with this two-stepping, shifty act. You know they are different, but then say, "Why can't they go there, they're all Arabs and the same (or similar enough), after all?" No rational person has time for that dishonest peddling, favoring the Israeli Zionist genocidal language that only seeks to strengthen the Israeli expansion. I don't have anything more to say to you. I already stated Jordan absorbs so many Palestinians that they are half of the population, and you still double down. But that is not their native land, nor is Egypt, an even more distinct area. I don't have time for this nonsense, and end it here.
I am discussing how they are the same people without it having anything to do with that being used to undermine Palestinians have a state. Its two separate conversations. And assuming I am some zionist is literally insane. Be serious.
Somalia people live in northern Kenya and in Ethiopia Galbeed. Would it be wrong for me so say they are thr same ethnically to us? It is a known fact that the people who lived in Palestine prior to any creation of Israel are the same ethnically to Jordan. This is not even up for debate. This is like saying Pakistani and Indians never shared a land. Insane.
Jordan has different tribes of people but they share Arabic language, history etc. There are some genetic differences. Chances are they are a mix of the many different groups that always lived in the area. The reason thr term indigenious is confusing is because these regions have colonized many times. This isnt the Americas. Similarly, who is indigenious in Somalia? A place that has many tribes, nomads and different empires? Americas was unusual because they were isolated from the world before waves of people started going there.
If you cannot discuss this without being emotional than do not reply as I do not want to upset you further. I would prefer we discuss this without venturing into the conflict/genocide/war of the times we are in. Or any land claims as I have said I have no skin in the gane who owns that land.