I feel ANRGY that….

[Cush]

Oral history mixed with scholarly studies is what I believe.

Samaale was a cushite man. It's not hard.

Proto somali is a thing. Are you dense?

Somalis didn't pop out the ground. We have a lineage. Modern Somalis are from a group of lowland east Cushtiic tribes.

Samaale was not a Cushite do you know how absurd this is? Let me put it into perspective

80% Of Somalis are from E-Y18629 the rest are T-M70 which entered recently

E-Y18629 is 2600 years old

If Somalia is so ancient how did 1 man birth a whole nation? This shows he originated from Arabia, since the rest of our cousins who match us are in Saudi and Egypt

 

[Angelina]

Speak on behalf your banadir Hawiyes and Benadiri.

Stop talking on behalf of MJ

I’ll talk about MJs if I want to.

None of y’all know what tribe I am anyways. I’m deffo not MJ though that’s for sure.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Since the 1300s at most where ibn Battuta stated those from Mogadishu to zelia were if the same stock.

Where the same Arab tribes residing in both mogadishu and zaylac?

Reer Xamar are literally a mixed race people of Indian, arab, Persian, Bantus mixed with Somali. You literally don't exist without the Somali who make up the chunk of your genome dumbass.

Again you're confused. Intermixing between gibil cads and gibil madows was something recent. there's gibil cads that didn't mix with samaales same way there's samaales on the coast that didn't mix with native gibil cads

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

You don't speak for us

Their land being part of Somalia is enough for them being Somali

 

[niggaibnh]

Online reer xamar don’t consider bendiris as Somali
Online MJ don’t consider caxaab S as Somali

The people of xamar consider them bendiris somali
The mjs in punt consider caraab S as Somali

It’s always the online

 

[Juke]

I’ll talk about MJs if I want to.

None of y’all know what tribe I am anyways. I’m deffo not MJ though that’s for sure.

Seek help

 

[Khaem]

Samaale was not a Cushite do you know how absurd this is? Let me put it into perspective

80% Of Somalis are from E-Y18629 the rest are T-M70 which entered recently

E-Y18629 is 2600 years old

If Somalia is so ancient how did 1 man birth a whole nation? This shows he originated from Arabia, since the rest of our cousins who match us are in Saudi and Egypt

One man didn't literally birth a whole tribe. There are all sorts of ethnic groups in the world who claim to be of one man and have this story about him.

But if Somalis are Cushitic and the progenitor of the Somali tribe isn't that what does that make us? Obviously samaale isn't a single man who birthed a whole tribe but still..

 

[Juke]

Their land being part of Somalia is enough for them being Somali

They don't have any land, they live on our territory, like we live on theirs back in Arabia.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Oral history mixed with scholarly studies is what I believe.

So you don't trust what your elders say

Samaale was a cushite man. It's not hard.

I didn't say he's not

Proto somali is a thing. Are you dense?

Clearly your dense you just rushed to reply without reading that I said it's used for the wrong meaning

Name the tribes that fall under "proto somali"

Somalis didn't pop out the ground. We have a lineage. Modern Somalis are from a group of lowland east Cushtiic tribes.

Are all those modern Somalis from samaale like your oral history claims?

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

They don't have any land, they live on our territory, like we live on theirs back in Arabia.

The land they built is their territory it's not like they're renting out land

 

[Khaem]

Where the same Arab tribes residing in both mogadishu and zaylac?

Again you're confused. Intermixing between gibil cads and gibil madows was something recent. there's gibil cads that didn't mix with samaales same way there's samaales on the coast that didn't mix with native gibil cads

What Arab tribes? He stated they were dark skinned. Had they spoken Arabic he would've noted that down also but he didn't.

You recon a morrocan would write about his fellow arabs but instead he saw not light brown skinned people but Black skinned curly haired Cushitic Somali.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Online reer xamar don’t consider bendiris as Somali
Online MJ don’t consider caxaab S as Somali

The people of xamar consider them bendiris somali
The mjs in punt consider caraab S as Somali

It’s always the online

Either you're confused or high

Reer xamar are banadiri themselves. Xamar is part of Banaadir coast. Banaadir coast is currently part of Somalia

 

[Juke]

The land they built is their territory it's not like they're renting out land

Projecting your little insecurities to another community now

Rest assure MJ and Meheri have a long standing brotherly alliance in Somalia and Arabia

 

[niggaibnh]

Either you're confused or high

Reer xamar are banadiri themselves. Xamar is part of Banaadir coast. Banaadir coast is currently part of Somalia

Reer xamar has two meaning
-they consider any qabil that lives in xamar (could be haiwye or bendiris )
-aimed at benadiris so people when they say reer xamar they mean them.

 

[Cush]

One man didn't literally birth a whole tribe. There are all sorts of ethnic groups in the world who claim to be of one man and have this story about him.

But if Somalis are Cushitic and the progenitor of the Somali tribe isn't that what does that make us? Obviously samaale isn't a single man who birthed a whole tribe but still..

All the major tribes have taken DNA tests which includes Raxanweyn, Darood, Dir and Hawiye

All of them either fall under a branch of T-M70 which is only 1500 years old! Which is fucking younger than even E-Y18629!!!! Existing at the time of the Prophet SAW's great great grand father probably

Then we have E-Y18629 which is only 2600 years old, these 2 haplogroups count as roughly 95% of the country and all their closest relatives are in Arabia!

How could they have been Puntites when the only Somalis left are 2600 years old! We all literally come from 2 guys

Now with your logic since you don't believe we are Arabs, 2 guys fertilized a whole region in Africa

But logically this is absurd, what makes sense is that we are from Adnani tribes since they are our closest cousins and we migrated into Somalia because where were "Samaale's" cousins? Uncles? Brothers? If your theory was true the Somali population would be 350 million since we'd be ancient but this is not the case we are only 15 million

95% Of Somalis are under these haplogroups! The rest are foreign recent arrivals!

This shows the recent migrations are true

 

[Khaem]

Either you're confused or high

Reer xamar are banadiri themselves. Xamar is part of Banaadir coast. Banaadir coast is currently part of Somalia

Benedir coast is Somali. Reer Xamar are a group of People with mixed Somali-Indian-Arab-Persian heritage. All the land and cities are of the Somali tribe

 

[Cush]

Are all those modern Somalis from samaale like your oral history claims?

@Idrus See, If Samaale was actually Somali and was a Puntite then he'd have a tribe, or a city, or a kingdom with people related to him who speak our language and today we'd be 100 million+ but this isn't the case we are literally 1 clan

ALSO E-Y18629 IS 2600 YEARS THE EXACT TIME ADNAAN WAS BORN

Thsi is clear

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

What Arab tribes? He stated they were dark skinned. Had they spoken Arabic he would've noted that down also but he didn't.

There weren't any samaales in mogadishu at the time , Arabs and persians both resided in both cities at the time, Arabic was spoken not just in mogadishu but throughout banaadir coast

You recon a morrocan would write about his fellow arabs but instead he saw not light brown skinned people but Black skinned curly haired Cushitic Somali.

No mention of the word somali or cushitic in his works

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

@Idrus See, If Samaale was actually Somali and was a Puntite then he'd have a tribe, or a city, or a kingdom with people related to him who speak our language and today we'd be 100 million+ but this isn't the case we are literally 1 clan

ALSO E-Y18629 IS 2600 YEARS THE EXACT TIME ADNAAN WAS BORN

Thsi is clear

He does have a tribe it's just not known, lineage preservance wasn't a big deal back then

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Reer xamar has two meaning
-they consider any qabil that lives in xamar (could be haiwye or banadiris )
-aimed at banadiris so people when they say reer xamar they mean them.

Reer xamar has only one meaning. Reer xamar tribes are known only the hawiyes of xamarweyne and shingaani are reer xamar .

Banadiris of xamar are reer xamar shouldn't be hard to understand