I feel ANRGY that….

[niggaibnh]

We weren’t talking about the country at all. We all know Somalia didn’t exist. We’re talking about the Somali ethnic group. Now you’re trying to change the goal post.

I don’t know much about digils since they’re a bit different to other Somalis due to being of farmer origins. But do you have any proof to illustrate that they didn’t identify as Somali?

Ain’t digils and Rahanweyn the same thing ? Rahanweyn are farmers as well

 

[Khaem]

Samaale didn't exist for more than 2k years ago so that's illogical, there hasn't been any genetic studies. Mixture varies from family to family as I've explained before, a result from a family that are full gibil cad with no history of mixing with gibil madows other than possibly their ancestors having concubines would vary from a family that's been mixed for a few generations.

Nearly all modern ethnic groups didn't exist 2,000 years ago wtf.

If not Modern Somali it would've been Proto somali tribes that would become somali of today.

 

[Juke]

Don’t talk to me about Somali culture because as of right now Caraab Salax are seen as Somalis from Puntland. You’d be laughed at for claiming they’re not Somali. So why don’t you follow Somali culture and stop this nonsense. Only on this dumb low IQ forum do people talk about Caraab Salax not being Somali. Go to Puntland, in fact go to your local miqaayad and I’d be interested to see how that conversation goes down. Are you going to patronize older Somali odeys who know more about Somali culture when they laugh at your absurdity?!

Stop speaking for us MJs. Meheri are seen as Arab in Puntland. Vice versa with the MJ in Yemen/Oman.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Ain’t digils and Rahanweyn the same thing ?

Rahanweyn are from digil

 

[niggaibnh]

Stop speaking for us MJs. Meheri are seen as Arab in Puntland. Vice versa with the MJ in Yemen/Oman.

Nigga that’s cap
They ain’t seen as meheris in puntland

 

[Khaem]

Who else lived there other than Reer xamars?

Since the 1300s at most where ibn Battuta stated those from Mogadishu to zelia were if the same stock.

Reer Xamar are literally a mixed race people of Indian, arab, Persian, Bantus mixed with Somali. You literally don't exist without the Somali who make up the chunk of your genome dumbass.

 

[Angelina]

Stop speaking for us MJs. Meheri are seen as Arab in Puntland. Vice versa with the MJ in Yemen/Oman.

Since when are Caraab Salaaxs seen as not Somali? Get out of here with your nonsense. I can’t take you seriously.

 

[Angelina]

Nigga that’s cap
They ain’t seen as meheris in puntland

I’ve had enough of the liars on this forum. They need to get with reality.

 

[Juke]

Since when are Caraab Salaaxs seen as not Somali? Get out of here with your nonsense. I can’t take you seriously.

You don't speak for us

 

[Juke]

Nigga that’s cap
They ain’t seen as meheris in puntland

Do you have any Meheri family like I do?

 

[Angelina]

You don't speak for us

And you don’t speak for anyone. I don’t need to speak for you or other MJs. I can literally ask an MJ odey and he’ll say the same thing. Move with your nonsense.

 

[niggaibnh]

Do you have any Meheri family like I do?

Close friend can be counted as family ? Both our families are close before we was born

 

[Juke]

And you don’t speak for anyone. I don’t need to speak for you or other MJs. I can literally ask an MJ odey and he’ll say the same thing. Move with your nonsense.

Delusional ting, you've never been part of a MJ shir.

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Nearly all modern ethnic groups didn't exist 2,000 years ago wtf.

If not Modern Somali it would've been Proto somali tribes that would become somali of today.

So you don't believe in oral history of your people and reject it? There's no specific meaning for "proto somalis" it's just thrown around alot and made to mean something. Samaale was obviously from a tribe that's not known anymore, what do you think happened his tribesmen?

No evidence of ancient tribes like Tiiriyaat and Maadanle being related to samaale's for them to be proto somali

 

[Angelina]

Delusional ting, you've never been part of a MJ shir.

I doubt you’ve been in any shir. Too busy having a dog in your house.

 

[niggaibnh]

Close friend can be counted as family ? Both our families are close before we was born

@𐒁𐒚𐒒𐒂𐒘𐒂𐒗 𐒎𐒚𐒗𐒗𐒒

You’re puntlander yourself right ?
Are caraab saalax seen us Somali or mehris in puntland ?

 

[Khaem]

So you don't believe in oral history of your people and reject it? There's no specific meaning for "proto somalis" it's just thrown around alot and made to mean something. Samaale was obviously from a tribe that's not known anymore, what do you think happened his tribesmen?

No evidence of ancient tribes like Tiiriyaat and Maadanle being related to samaale's for them to be proto somali

Oral history mixed with scholarly studies is what I believe.

Samaale was a cushite man. It's not hard.

Proto somali is a thing. Are you dense?

Somalis didn't pop out the ground. We have a lineage. Modern Somalis are from a group of lowland east Cushtiic tribes.

 

[Cush]

Does that mean that the Prophet s.a.w wasn’t an Arab?

They the Caraab Salax didn’t marry within themselves. Only a tiny group came and they all ended up intermarrying with MJs. Hence their DNA is literally mostly just MJ.


Don’t talk to me about Somali culture because as of right now Caraab Salax are seen as Somalis from Puntland. You’d be laughed at for claiming they’re not Somali. So why don’t you follow Somali culture and stop this nonsense. Only on this dumb low IQ forum do people talk about Caraab Salax not being Somali. Go to Puntland, in fact go to your local miqaayad and I’d be interested to see how that conversation goes down. Are you going to patronize older Somali odeys who know more about Somali culture when they laugh at your absurdity?!

I personally know an carab salax dude and he always embraces the Arab culture and visits Arab countries and he looks Arab

And yes the Prophet SAW is still Arab, why? Because the whole of his tribe the Ismaili Arabs were among the Arabs practicing their culture for thousands of years ARAB IS A CULTURAL IDENTITY NOT AN ETHNICITY OR RACE, IT LITERALLY MEANS NOMAD AND IS USED FOR ANYONE WHO SPEAKS ARABIC

Also Ibrahim AS came from Akkadia and Akkadia is a combination of two words, Akk and Caad, due to being descended from the people of Ad who were the ancient Arabs and so yes he is still Arab even if Arab was an ethnicity which it is not since now Arabs are just a bunch of Turks, Indo Europeans, Persians and Abysinians all bundled together

 

[Juke]

I doubt you’ve been in any shir. Too busy having a dog in your house.

Speak on behalf your banadir Hawiyes and Benadiri.

Stop talking on behalf of MJ

 

[Khaem]

I personally know an carab salax dude and he always embraces the Arab culture and visits Arab countries and he looks Arab

And yes the Prophet SAW is still Arab, why? Because the whole of his tribe the Ismaili Arabs were among the Arabs practicing their culture for thousands of years ARAB IS A CULTURAL IDENTITY NOT AN ETHNICITY OR RACE, IT LITERALLY MEANS NOMAD AND IS USED FOR ANYONE WHO SPEAKS ARABIC

Also Ibrahim AS came from Akkadia and Akkadia is a combination of two words, Akk and Caad, due to being descended from the people of Ad who were the ancient Arabs and so yes he is still Arab even if Arab was an ethnicity which it is not since now Arabs are just a bunch of Turks, Indo Europeans, Persians and Abysinians all bundled together

Arab is basically a cultural identity yes. Even prophet Muhammad's tribe was recently Arabised by the time of his birth only from a few generations.