How to Implement Sharia in Somalia

[Ismail99]

It's sad seeing a country who says they're 100% muslim and still refer to laws made by those who colonised us. Some might say we should the change the system from within like the Muslim Brotherhood and make the whole parliament clerics the spokesman the judge everything. But sadly it didn't work for the MB as we saw in Egypt with Morsi. So how can we implement it.

@Dawo @Tsar Lexenkar I @akaA2 @Omar del Sur

 

[Muzaffer]

It's sad seeing a country who says they're 100% muslim and still refer to laws made by those who colonised us. Some might say we should the change the system from within like the Muslim Brotherhood and make the whole parliament clerics the spokesman the judge everything. But sadly it didn't work for the MB as we saw in Egypt with Morsi. So how can we implement it.

@Dawo @Tsar Lexenkar I @akaA2 @Omar del Sur

There are two ways to reach an Islamic nation.

1- by force like the Taliban

2- by-election and political parties like MBH

now the first one is very risky and mostly not very good because of the bloodbath that will follow its path and it's not always successful.

Afghanistan was a special case because its conservative traditional nation from the beginning secondly its saw a religious revival during the jihad against the soviet and after that during the warlord's era the people especially Kandahar region looked for hero to save them from the warlords and bandits and that hero is Mullah Muhammed Omar RA.

so these points cant be found in the rest of the Islamic world.

the second way is easier but it will take longer. and for Egypt, I personally think that the Arab Spring was a revolution for freedom but at the same time it was a trap to find and open the books of all revolutionary political groups and heads of these parties, the people of Egypt overthrow Mubarak but they didn't overthrow his government, for example, the ministry of defense and the ministry of the information didn't change so when MBH took power these two fought them and disobey their orders.

 

[Sandvaer]

How about to implement peace first?

 

[Muzaffer]

How about to implement peace first?

you can do both

 

[Ismail99]

How about to implement peace first?

Go and make your own thread about it don't derail mine.

 

[mr steal your naag]

Sharia is peace

Dude nobody wants to live in a country were if a kid steals a apple his hand will get cut off.

 

[Muzaffer]

Dude nobody wants to live in a country were if a kid steals a apple his hand will get cut off.

Kids aren't adults

 

[Ismail99]

Dude nobody wants to live in a country were if a kid steals a apple his hand will get cut of.

And who wants to live there?

 

[Ismail99]

@mr steal your naag there is a reason why I didn't mention you caruur baa tahay don't derail my thread.

 

[Ismail99]

There are two ways to reach an Islamic nation.

1- by force like the Taliban

2- by-election and political parties like MBH

now the first one is very risky and mostly not very good because of the bloodbath that will follow its path and it's not always successful.

Afghanistan was a special case because its conservative traditional nation from the beginning secondly its saw a religious revival during the jihad against the soviet and after that during the warlord's era the people especially Kandahar region looked for hero to save them from the warlords and bandits and that hero is Mullah Muhammed Omar RA.

so these points cant be found in the rest of the Islamic world.

the second way is easier but it will take longer. and for Egypt, I personally think that the Arab Spring was a revolution for freedom but at the same time it was a trap to find and open the books of all revolutionary political groups and heads of these parties, the people of Egypt overthrow Mubarak but they didn't overthrow his government, for example, the ministry of defense and the ministry of the information didn't change so when MBH took power these two fought them and disobey their orders.

Yeah but the second one is very hard to achieve and the enemy won't sit still and let it happen.

 

[Hali]

What a shame I wasn’t tagged can’t participate

 

[Muzaffer]

Yeah but the second one is very hard to achieve and the enemy won't sit still and let it happen.

Maybe but for somalia it has very good chance.

 

[Muzaffer]

What a shame I wasn’t tagged can’t participate

 

[BigBreak]

The problem is that there's different interpretations on what is Sharia and how to implement it

 

[Ismail99]

What a shame I wasn’t tagged can’t participate

I forgot you next time InshAllah

 

[Ismail99]

The problem is that there's different interpretations on what is Sharia and how to implement it

Didn't stop Somalis from having communism/federalism even tho there are different interpretations

 

[Muzaffer]

The problem is that there's different interpretations on what is Sharia and how to implement it

Well this job is for the uluma to sit down and discuss it.

But we are taking about how to apply it.

 

[BigBreak]

Didn't stop Somalis from having communism/federalism even tho there are different interpretations

Yeah but they are man made ideas created by gaalo (certainly communism)

 

[BigBreak]

Well this job is for the uluma to sit down and discuss it.

But we are taking about how to apply it.

You have many ulema who are against al kebab

 

[Ismail99]

Yeah but they are man made ideas created by gaalo (certainly communism)

Yeah exactly so saying we can't implement because we have different interpretations is a weak argument. Secondly Somalis waa shaafiici so that won't be a problem.