Chaseyourdreamzz
VIP
This is just for educational purposes and anybody curious about the seat allocation in Somalia
How the 275 parliament seats were divided
- Thread starter Chaseyourdreamzz
- Start date
This is just for educational purposes and anybody curious about the seat allocation in Somalia
Chaseyourdreamzz
VIP
Yusuf Abdi Ali Rashid
King of Prussia
mirifle/digil yajuj majuj confirmed
It's incomprehensible that a massive amounts of citizens in Mogadishu straight up don't have representatives. Taxation without adequate representation.
Puntland got robbed
how come we similar numbers with galnus??
0117
Reborn
If I were to politically fix Somalia it would be to run a nationwide census.
From that census create parliamentary constituencies (area) based on population (50K).
This would elimate tribalism as people will think about their immediate constituencies as you could face a scenario where you have siblings competing for the same seat!
This will force people to open their eyes and vote beyond the tribal lense and instead focus on their needs.
Also this is justice for Mogadishu who need actual parliamentary representation.
For example 73/650 MPs in the UK represent London constituencies!
You can leave the tribal quota for the Upper House.
From that census create parliamentary constituencies (area) based on population (50K).
This would elimate tribalism as people will think about their immediate constituencies as you could face a scenario where you have siblings competing for the same seat!
This will force people to open their eyes and vote beyond the tribal lense and instead focus on their needs.
Also this is justice for Mogadishu who need actual parliamentary representation.
For example 73/650 MPs in the UK represent London constituencies!
You can leave the tribal quota for the Upper House.
Daroods seats are split between puntland and jubbaland.Puntland got robbed
Originally concocted in Salbalaar, then formally adopted in Arta, later revisited in Eldoret and Embagathi, the division of seats was not based upon population size, regions, FMSs or administrations, but tribes where each of the 4 major tribes had been allocated 61 seats each, with the 5th tribe (amalgamation of minorities) was allocated 31 seats.
The 5 seats are for Banaadiri ethnic groups, not for Banadir, as no seats have been allotted for Xamar, for the clans in Xamar are accounted as part of the 4 major tribes.
Addendum:
The Upper house was based upon the 18 regions of 1991 where each region was designated 3 seats, hence the 54 Senators.
The 5 seats are for Banaadiri ethnic groups, not for Banadir, as no seats have been allotted for Xamar, for the clans in Xamar are accounted as part of the 4 major tribes.
Addendum:
The Upper house was based upon the 18 regions of 1991 where each region was designated 3 seats, hence the 54 Senators.
0117
Reborn
Clan federalism imported by Zenawi through Puntland caused this tribal lense which will forever put Somalia in a limbo talking about clans and politics till the end of times.
MPs should be elected through areas (50K population example) instead of entire regions.
You can look at Somaliland that's been doing this 1m1v for 20 years yet people are still talking about clans in politics and inflaming tribalism.
Somalia can't afford to replicate the failed voting system in Somaliland. Move conversations away from clans and towards development and prosperity as a national agenda.
Banadir should have the same amount as South West
This is not true statement, and I think like most you are mistaking the venue of the original discussion for the architects of the 4.5 formula, which was then considered a temporary solution out of the then quagmire, which served its purpose, but must have been decommissioned, as originally intended.
Are these the new allocation or the old ones?
So you're telling me clans that don't live in Somalia get 8 while mine get 4. The worst qaybsi
We should at least get 2 seats in Bari and 1 in JL
Chaseyourdreamzz
VIP
1m1v will sort everything out correctly 2026 will be a game changer
Chaseyourdreamzz
VIP
These are the recent seats allocations
mohamedismail
Reewin. Lixda Gobol ee Maayland unii leh!
The reason why South west state gets so much seats is because majority of the 61 D&M seats are concentrated in SWS. Whereas Daarood seats are divided into Puntland, Jubbaland and Galmudug. Hawiye seats are divided into Galmudug, Hirshabeele, Banaadir and SWS. Dir seats are divided into basically all states as well.
I am personally not a fan of this. I think more Digil iyo mirifle seats should of been transferred to jubbaland to even it out a bit.
I am personally not a fan of this. I think more Digil iyo mirifle seats should of been transferred to jubbaland to even it out a bit.
How is Marehan getting crumbs in GM?
Is this offset by upper seats or something?
Most Dir seats are in Somaliland. Isaaq alone got like half at 28, Sameroon 9, Cisse 8 that's 45 out of 61 in whole of Somalia. The last 16 is scattered everywhere.
Raxanweyne have the most representation but their politicians are utterly powerless and most of their territory owned by Al-Shabaab.
Trending
-
-
-
Madow talks about why athletes prefer caadan women over madow women- Started by Dibleyy
- Replies: 96
