Garoob

Would you be willing to marry a garoob M/F

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 25.0%
  • No

    Votes: 12 75.0%

  • Total voters
    16
Status
Not open for further replies.

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
Wikipedia is not a credible source.

Also, if he indeed tried to marry again doesn't negate the fact that at 25 he married a twice married woman who was his favourite wife, and is one of the 4 greatest women in islam along with Fatima, Asiya and Maryam.

Wikipedia post the references at the bottom and this is the Seerah of the Prophet pbuh
 
Wikipedia post the references at the bottom and this is the Seerah of the Prophet pbuh

I don't take wikipedia as a source. Only islamic books written by credible scholars or islamic websites posted by credible scholars.

Any tom can edit wiki and post fake hadiths ect.
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
That has nothing to do with a 2nd wife, nor does it negate that she was his first wife and his favourite.
Read the entire Sura. Allah swt is reminding the Prophet pbuh of all the blessings he gave him. The Prophet pbuh said if you can not afford marriage, then fast. The Prophet pbuh was too poor to marry Khadijah let alone a second wife
 

IstarZ

A mere finger can’t obscure the sun.
Also, since when did he define them as such??

Islamically there are different ruling for non virgins and virgins so of course he had to differentiate them.

Importance was given to chastity.

Someone can be a virgin but unchaste. Someone can be chaste but not a virgin (divorcee, widow/er)

These guys are very immature in their thinking and only see things in black and white.
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
Importance was given to chastity.

Someone can be a virgin but unchaste. Someone can be chaste but not a virgin (divorcee, widow/er)

These guys are very immature in their thinking and only see things in black and white.

The lengths that some of you go to defend s is something else. What an oxymoron:mjlol:
 
Read the entire Sura. Allah swt is reminding the Prophet pbuh of all the blessings he gave him. The Prophet pbuh said if you can not afford marriage, then fast. The Prophet pbuh was too poor to marry Khadijah let alone a second wife

Walaal, we are not scholars so we cannot speculate.

Ibn Kathir usually explains ayahs and I have not seen that explanation before from him or any other classical scholar.

After Islam the prophet S.A.W became very poor because the people of mecca were trying to boycott him. For 15 yrs he lived with Khadijah before Islam and I have not read that he was poor then.
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
Walaal, we are not scholars so we cannot speculate.

Ibn Kathir usually explains ayahs and I have not seen that explanation before from him or any other classical scholar.

After Islam the prophet S.A.W became very poor because the people of mecca were trying to boycott him. For 15 yrs he lived with Khadijah before Islam and I have not read that he was poor then.

Your talking about scholars when you have an ayah in the Qur'an saying the Prophet pbuh was poor :comeon:
 
Your talking about scholars when you have an ayah in the Qu'ran saying the Prophet pbuh was poor :comeon:

You are linking that ayah with him not getting a 2nd wife. Where is your scholarly input?

You are speculating that if he had money he would have married again whilst with her. Who said such a thing???
 

IstarZ

A mere finger can’t obscure the sun.
The lengths that some of you go to defend s is something else. What an oxymoron:mjlol:

Look up the meaning of chaste. Meeshaa adiga oogu doqonsan. What makes you worse than the others is you twist the religion to try and support your misogynistic, racist and jahiliyya ways.
 
Importance was given to chastity.

Someone can be a virgin but unchaste. Someone can be chaste but not a virgin (divorcee, widow/er)

These guys are very immature in their thinking and only see things in black and white.
The definition of chastity according to English dictionary


Screenshot_20190612_191526_com.dictionary.jpg
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
You are linking that ayah with him not getting a 2nd wife. Where is your scholarly input?

You are speculating that if he had money he would have married again whilst with her. Who said such a thing???
The Prophet pbuh in a famous hadith said to marry a fertile women so he can be proud of our numbers on qiyama. The purpose of marriage is to have as many children as possible and the Prophet pbuh married 9 wives at once.

The Prophet pbuh as well as all the Prophets except Yahya pbuh were polygamists. Yahya pbuh did not marry at all
 

IstarZ

A mere finger can’t obscure the sun.
The definition of chastity according to English dictionary


View attachment 73969

Chaste is the moral and physical purity. Not being indecent at all. There is a subtle difference.

Virginity only refers to the penetrative act of intercourse. Someone can claim to be a virgin but engage in other sexual acts. They are not chaste even though they are virgin.
 
The Prophet pbuh in a famous hadith said to marry a fertile women so he can be proud of our numbers on qiyama. The purpose of marriage is to have as many children as possible and the Prophet pbuh married 9 wives at once.

The Prophet pbuh as well as all the Prophets except Yahya pbuh were polygamists. Yahya pbuh did not marry at all

Speculation upon speculation what does that have to do with the fact that he was only married to Khadijah during her lifetime or that ayah?

You are trying to link the unlinkable.

Khadijah despite being 40+ when he married her was the only one out of his wives that bore him children. 7 kids.

We are talking about that ayaah.
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
Speculation upon speculation what does that have to do with the fact that he was only married to Khadijah during her lifetime or that ayah?

You are trying to link the unlinkable.

Khadijah despite being 40+ when he married her was the only one out of his wives that bore him children. 7 kids.

We are talking about that ayaah.

This is the inability of modern Somalis today that they need someone to read the Qur'an and hadith for them.

Allah swt made the Qur'an easy to understand and an obligation for the individual to study it and analyse it. The Ayat and hadith i posted are all part of the bigger picture which you choose to run away from
 
This is the inability of modern Somalis today that they need someone to read the Qur'an and hadith for them.

Allah swt made the Qur'an easy to understand and an obligation for the individual to study it and analyse it. The Ayat and hadith i posted are all part of the bigger picture which you choose to run away from

We are laymen and need the help of scholars. We follow madhabs and take the rulings of people of knowledge for a reason.
 

Samaalic Era

QurboExit
We are laymen and need the help of scholars. We follow madhabs and take the rulings of people of knowledge for a reason.

You are supposed to study the Qur'an yourself and ask scholars after when it comes to certain laws.

Islam is not Christianity
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trending

Top