Austin later told police he had fallen asleep accidentally after a night out and was unaware of the exposure or open door. Ring camera footage (provided to authorities) reportedly shows Henderson opening the door herself—contradicting her claim it was already ajar—though she maintains she only pushed it slightly to confirm the drop-off spot without fully entering. He filed a counter-report, arguing the filming was an unlawful intrusion into his private space.
Austin's filed complaint led to an investigation. On November 10 at 9:46 p.m., Henderson was arrested in Oswego County and booked on two Class E felonies under New York law:
She was released on bail, with a court date set for December 4, 2025. Each charge carries up to 4 years in prison if convicted, though first-time offenders often get probation or fines.c381b1 Police cited the Ring footage as key evidence showing she "opened the door" and filmed inside without permission, violating delivery protocols against entering homes.