Do You Think Sharia Law is Good?

[Odious Delirium]

Well that isn’t realistically gonna workout is it? No one is gonna let anyone watch them have s*x are they? Besides can witnesses be ppl that u told that u r having intercourse or they have to actually witness the act?

That's the whole point sharia isn't out to get anyone. in the prophet's time less then a handful of people received the punishment and that was because they came out and admitted to it of there own accord. No one was ever actually caught in the act and to realistically be caught you have to basically be doing this publicly.

Mā‘iz ibn Mālik al-Aslami (may Allah be pleased with him) went to the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) while he was in the mosque and confessed to having committed adultery. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) turned away from him, hoping that he would retract his statement and repent to Allah in secret. Yet, Mā‘iz was angry with himself, and he was determined to purify his soul through the prescribed punishment. Hence, he went to face the Prophet from the other side and again confessed to having committed adultery. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) once more turned his face to the other side, and he kept doing so until Mā‘iz confessed to having committed adultery four times. Afterwards, the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) asked him if he was suffering from any form of insanity, and he answered in the negative. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) then asked his family about the state of his mind, and they said that he was fine. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) then asked him if he was (currently or previously) married or a virgin, as the punishment of the virgin does not amount to stoning. He told him that he was married. Furthermore, the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) asked him if he had committed complete adultery, and not merely touching or kissing, but the man admitted to having committed complete adultery. After the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) had made sure of the veracity of all of those conditions which require the implementation of the legal prescribed punishment, he ordered his Companions to take the man and stone him to death. They took him to Baqī‘ al-Gharqad [a place where the funeral prayer is performed in Madīnah] and stoned him.

 

[Odious Delirium]

Thnxs for clarifying. What about the punishment for feminine presenting men & masculine presenting women?

That's doesn't have a haad prescribed to it so it more so at the discretion of the ruler/soical law but nothing major. Probably will be banned so they will be told to change there attire or fined basically it's based on what kind of fitna it causes and where you do this and in what way. There will be repercussion but nothing like on the level of commiting zina. There is however punishment from Allah in the hearafter for presenting that way.

 

[Hamzza]

Thnxs for clarifying. What about the punishment for feminine presenting men & masculine presenting women?

I'm not sure. They will be ordered to act like a proper men and women. I'm not aware of any punishment or ruling about them.

 

[Hamzza]

Wrong place to ask this question, they'll all say yes but will never live in one ruled by sharia.

Muslims loving/appreciating their religion and Allah's commandments is hurting you.

There's a special place in hell for people like you.

 

[Odious Delirium]

Basically @Barni sharia is very complicated and complex and there are many things that are put in place so people are not punished for example spying and setting up someone is haram and invalidates the validity of the witnesses (you need minimum 4) since they are no longer considered upright individuals which is a condition for your testimony to be accepted there case is thrown out. And if someone accuses you of committing it you can take an oath that you haven't and that will invalidate the accusation aswell so technically unless someone has intercourse of any kind gay or straight in a public building or park there will be no situation were one get punished unless they admit to it.

The west has just done a good job into making people perceptions of islam seem barbaric and just about chopping heads and hands off for stealing apples when that's not even islamically possible or allowed and there is this weird hyperfocus on haad which is just an aspect of sharia. Sharia is a way of life and is every aspect of law not just punishments.

 

[Internet Nomad]

Sharia is a great benefit to humanity and is a preventative cure for many of societal ills.
I wish there to be a proper sharia nation like the one which brought the islamic golden age to the world.

 

[Lebron James]

Muslims loving/appreciating their religion and Allah's commandments is hurting you.

There's a special place in hell for people like you.

I stand against hypocrisy, since its the month of forgiveness i won't hold this comment against you

 

[killerxsmoke]

That's the whole point sharia isn't out to get anyone. in the prophet's time less then a handful of people received the punishment and that was because they came out and admitted to it of there own accord. No one was ever actually caught in the act and to realistically be caught you have to basically be doing this publicly.

Mā‘iz ibn Mālik al-Aslami (may Allah be pleased with him) went to the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) while he was in the mosque and confessed to having committed adultery. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) turned away from him, hoping that he would retract his statement and repent to Allah in secret. Yet, Mā‘iz was angry with himself, and he was determined to purify his soul through the prescribed punishment. Hence, he went to face the Prophet from the other side and again confessed to having committed adultery. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) once more turned his face to the other side, and he kept doing so until Mā‘iz confessed to having committed adultery four times. Afterwards, the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) asked him if he was suffering from any form of insanity, and he answered in the negative. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) then asked his family about the state of his mind, and they said that he was fine. The Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) then asked him if he was (currently or previously) married or a virgin, as the punishment of the virgin does not amount to stoning. He told him that he was married. Furthermore, the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) asked him if he had committed complete adultery, and not merely touching or kissing, but the man admitted to having committed complete adultery. After the Prophet (may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him) had made sure of the veracity of all of those conditions which require the implementation of the legal prescribed punishment, he ordered his Companions to take the man and stone him to death. They took him to Baqī‘ al-Gharqad [a place where the funeral prayer is performed in Madīnah] and stoned him.

Damn

 

[dekiteshim]

Within the current global climate, Sharia is not and will likely never be put into praxis the way it is theorised. When countries attempt to and it goes awry and people end up oppressed - it’s supporters will utter similar words to communists: “That’s not real Sharia!”.

You also have to take into account the means of which it will be achieved. Unless 100% of the populace supports it (which is impossible), then dissenters must be crushed. This is often manifested in extreme violence and persecution

 

[notinuse.]

Sharia is a great benefit to humanity and is a preventative cure for many of societal ills.
I wish there to be a proper sharia nation like the one which brought the islamic golden age to the world.

What's up with muslim men and trying to get approval from random white men on the streets? lmao If sharia was the right solution for a well structured and prosperous nation we would have at least seen a view Islamic nations thriving but there is not even one Islamic nation that follows sharia and Isn't a 2/3rd world shit hole and don't come here mentioning gulf nation them cowards are as westernized as it can be and use Islam simply for aesthetic and cultural purposes.

 

[Internet Nomad]

What's up with muslim men and trying to get approval from random white men on the streets? lmao If sharia was the right solution for a well structured and prosperous nation we would have at least seen a view Islamic nations thriving but there is not even one Islamic nation that follows sharia and Isn't a 2/3rd world shit hole and don't come here mentioning gulf nation them cowards are as westernized as it can be and use Islam simply for aesthetic and cultural purposes.

Muslims don't need approval from anyone besides Allah(SWT). What he is doing is dawah?

So are we just going to ignore 1400 year history of Islamic sharia empires being a powerhouse on the world stage?

Its funny when it comes to this topic murtads forget all the foreign intervention that happens in muslim lands by the west to purposely destabilise us.

 

[Shaafici Mujaahid]

Sharia means law. Islamic sharia means Islamic law. Muslims nowadays have been fooled. In the past, the ottomans, Abassids, and Ummayids had their own distinct laws and codes. Saying that the Quran is your constitution is only a thing in Afghanistan. Even Iran and Saudi have their own.

 

[Man with a garuun]

I like having the right to live.

Xagee hogaanku kuugu go'ay.

 

[Internet Nomad]

Wrong place to ask this question, they'll all say yes but will never live in one ruled by sharia.

https://muslimskeptic.com/2022/10/30/latest-arab-youth-survey/

Even muslims in muslim nations are turning to sharia for a answer.

The young generation who are meant to be the most progressive have turned their backs on democracy.

 

[Al hashimi]

Sharia law bc it brings order and paves the way for a blossoming fantastic civilisation.

 

[Yaraye]

You’re qawmu lesbian, not qawmu luud. It’s not the same thing. Idk why you keep attaching yourself to those niman. If God in heaven made a distinction, you take that deal and run with it.

Lesbians need a new PR team

hvbswdebgviuewbidv! how did you come up with this?!

 

[Boxer03]

my opinion is that Sharia law is far too cruel no person deserves to get their hands cut of or killed for any crime.

 

[Yaraye]

I would never live somewhere that has sharia law not because I don't believe in them. but because many of these muslim countries can't separate sharia and their culture

 

[AMusee]

Anyone who thinks the Shariah of Allah swt is not "good" is a Kafir.

It is like saying the Quran is not "good".

It would have been simpler if you did a poll of how many non-Muslims are on this forum.

 

[AbrahamFreedom]

Anyone who commits any crime or a moral wrong, minor or major, should be shot dead. This includes littering, public spitting, extreme anger, and divorce. They are of no use to society (and in fact have no respect for society) and are a virus that will infect others. People like that shouldn't breed and their line extinct.