Democracy will destroy Somalia

[Geeljire Sandheer]

Democracy is haraam it goes against the rulings of the shariah it is classed a major shirk to follow the law of mankind over the law of Allah. Okay so how will this affect somalia ? Along with economic growth & democracy = basically liberalism do what you want lifestyle will become the norm. What you guys are shocked about in the west will be the norm in Somalia in about 30 years we will have feminism movements and women arguing to partake in government equal pay jobs etc then we will have gays and lesbians all forms of degenerate lifestyles will be the norm in our nation because the leaders have accepted to rule by the law of democracy/ liberalism do what you want lifestyle dont say I didn’t warn you

 

[Tukraq]

it neither goes against shariah nor is shirk, where do you guys come up with these things, khulufa arrashidin were merit based and elected through shura council, democracy just increases the number of people that has a vote from small number to everyone which isn't adding anything new sharia wise, its monarchies like the Umayyad and say Saudi Arabia right now doing the bidia by having non merit based lineage based leadership with out elections

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

it neither goes against shariah nor is shirk, where do you guys come up with these things, khulufa arrashidin were merit based and elected through shura council, democracy just increases the number of people that has a vote from small number to everyone which isn't adding anything new sharia wise, its monarchies like the Umayyad and say Saudi Arabia right now doing the bidia by having non merit based lineage based leadership with out elections

The scholars disagree with your opinion

 

[Samira]

Democracy is haram until our leaders say it's halal. "It was always halal until extremists took over and made it haram," they will then tell us. But then it will be haram again when the wrong person is elected. "These hadiths clearly say it is haram!" they will cry. Of course, all the scholars who haven't read the latest memo will be imprisioned by then

 

[Tukraq]

View attachment 79789 The scholars disagree with your opinion

whats the shura council then? and isn't monarchies a man made system and against the shariah of how the khulafa arrashidin came to power?

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

Democracy is haram until our leaders say it's halal. "It was always halal until extremists took over and made it haram," they will then tell us. But then it will be haram again when the wrong person is elected. "These hadiths clearly say it is haram!" they will cry. Of course, all the scholars who haven't read the latest memo will be imprisioned by then

Democracy is haraam s just choose to ignore

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

whats the shura council then? and isn't monarchies a man made system and against the shariah of how the khulafa arrashidin came to power?

They were haraam they did shirk if ashura council jump off a cliff should you also jump?

 

[Tukraq]

Democracy is haraam *******s just choose to ignore

its not if khulafa arrashidin were merit based elected by a shura council, not through lineage based monarchies

 

[Tukraq]

They were haraam they did shirk if ashura council jump off a cliff should you also jump?

that was the khulufa arashidin and sahaaba your talking about

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

that was the khulufa arashidin and sahaaba your talking about

Reject democracy its the greatest form of shirk if ashurra did shirk doesn’t mean we should also fall into it the only law system we should follow is Shariah law

 

[Tukraq]

Reject democracy its the greatest form of shirk if ashurra did shirk doesn’t mean we should also fall into it the only law system we should follow is Shariah law

sub your sounding very dumb the shariah is based on how the khulufa arrashidiin were elected since the prophet didn't leave us with a system, following the path of abubakr Omar and uthman is not shirk I'm sorry, merit based rulers not lineage based is the true way islamiclly, monarchies came after and are unislamic

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

sub your sounding very dumb the shariah is based on how the khulufa arrashidiin were elected since the prophet didn't leave us with a system, following the path of abubakr Omar and uthman is not shirk I'm sorry, merit based rulers not lineage based is the true way islamiclly, monarchies came after and are unislamic

Did i say we need merit based or lineage rulers if the ruler is not following by shariah the nation will fall off your just adding in your own two cents of bullshit sxb

 

[General Asad]

Fundamentalism>>>>>> democracy

 

[Tukraq]

Did i say we need merit based or lineage rulers if the ruler is not following by shariah the nation will fall off your just adding in your own two cents of bullshit sxb

and what is the sharia? is it not a shura council of electing based on merit which essentially is the same thing as democracy?

 

[Apollo]

Democracy is haraam it goes against the rulings of the shariah it is classed a major shirk to follow the law of mankind over the law of Allah. Okay so how will this affect somalia ? Along with economic growth & democracy = basically liberalism do what you want lifestyle will become the norm. What you guys are shocked about in the west will be the norm in Somalia in about 30 years we will have feminism movements and women arguing to partake in government equal pay jobs etc then we will have gays and lesbians all forms of degenerate lifestyles will be the norm in our nation because the leaders have accepted to rule by the law of democracy/ liberalism do what you want lifestyle dont say I didn’t warn you

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

God bless iran

 

[Geeljire Sandheer]

and what is the sharia? is it not a shura council of electing based on merit which essentially is the same thing as democracy?

Just cos you think that doesn’t make it the same thing we know the only reason you’re defending your jaahil leaders is because they are the same tribe as you kulaha democracy is the same thing as sharia law kkk

 

[tyrannicalmanager]

@Geeljire sanbuur isn't somaliland a democracy? why are complaining about system which won't come somalia in next decade while somaliland had for a 2 decades?

 

[Abdurahman_somali]

The Shariah contains of every law that we as Muslims derive from the Quran and the Sunna of the prophet SCW. Shariah is not a finished constitution, but the BASIS of every constitution. By that I mean every Muslim country is free to make it's own constitution, but not a single law of this constitution should be in contradiction to the Shariah. For exampe, if Somalia decides to pass a law where interest is permissible to increase the economy, this law would be against the Shariah.

Democracy or any other system is not haram per se. Democracy means 'the rule of the people' and can be interpreted by every society differently. We can have democratic elections, the Shariah doesn't defines a special law to elect a leader. However, western democracy with liberal laws is haram as yiu correctly stated out, since many of the liberal laws are against Islam. So democracy in it's western version is haram.

By the way the provisional constitution of Somalia and the constitution of Somaliland have both written in their constitution, that any law that is against the Shariah, shall be dismissed.

 

[fox]

Now I'm not advocating for democracy but nonsense like this cements Somalia's average IQ estimate.