Are Somalis Cushitic speaking Nilotes?

[Garaad diinle]

Who would you rather be Arab or Dinka?

Nah i'm not willing to play this game. Both are fine if they are muslims.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Khaem]

Nah i'm not willing to play this game. Both are fine if they are muslims.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I have to agree friend

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Som]

So if we are Genetically +50% Nilotic, does that mean we are language-shifted Nilo-Saharans?

Cushites themselves were part Nilotic like part west Eurasian . Cushitic is a language group
Our Nilotic like ancestry is not actually Nilotic, it's from a group that originated modern Nilotic peoples but horners got additional west Eurasian ancestry

 

[Som]

Who would you rather be Arab or Dinka?

Why do you have this inferiority complex? We are neither Dinka nor Arab, we are somalis period

 

[Som]

False

What's east African Hunter gatherer? Khoisan like people maybe?

 

[Dima&Damo]

What's east African Hunter gatherer? Khoisan like people maybe?

A dead group i would assume what with people love fest with nilotics are y'all that short that everyone here is hoping for a connection with those people

 

[Khaem]

What's east African Hunter gatherer? Khoisan like people maybe?

Yes the time of the Cushitic Expansion from its birthplace in Sudan down to the horn and as far south as tanzania was at the same time indo Europeans from Ukraine were wiping out the hunter gatherers of Europe or the Niger Congo expansion from their birthplace in southern Nigeria where they wiped out much of the hunter gatherers bar the Khoi-san remaining in South Africa after the bantu finnaly moved into South Africa after depopulating the already small Khoi-san population of South Africa and making it majority bantu. It was a time where pastoralits and farmers were genociding the hunter gatherers and wiping out countless races in the process and moving into their lands. It's why Europe has no pre indo European influences at all. Not a single word in any cadaan language has a pre indo-European word because of how utterly annihilated they were. Same thing probs happend in east Africa where pastoralit cushited from Sudan moved into east African and found khoi San like hunter gathers and because of the much larger population of the nomads and better technologies they were easily killed off.

 

[Som]

Yes the time of the Cushitic Expansion from its birthplace in Sudan down to the horn and as far south as tanzania was at the same time indo Europeans from Ukraine were wiping out the hunter gatherers of Europe or the Niger Congo expansion from their birthplace in southern Nigeria where they wiped out much of the hunter gatherers bar the Khoi-san remaining in South Africa after the bantu finnaly moved into South Africa after depopulating the already small Khoi-san population of South Africa and making it majority bantu. It was a time where pastoralits and farmers were genociding the hunter gatherers and wiping out countless races in the process and moving into their lands. It's why Europe has no pre indo European influences at all. Not a single word in any cadaan language has a pre indo-European word because of how utterly annihilated they were. Same thing probs happend in east Africa where pastoralit cushited from Sudan moved into east African and found khoi San like hunter gathers and because of the much larger population of the nomads and better technologies they were easily killed off.

Interesting. I think I've read somewhere habesha have more east African Hunter gatherer than us and it's especially high in other Ethiopians like omotic speakers. Some Ethiopians kinds remind me a little bit of Khoisans. Shorter , very curly hair light brown yellowish skin etc.
Also I think the basque language is one of the few if not the only pre Indo European language in Europe, somehow they are the only ones who survived probably thanks to their mountain area land between Spain and France

 

[Khaem]

Interesting. I think I've read somewhere habesha have more east African Hunter gatherer than us and it's especially high in other Ethiopians like omotic speakers. Some Ethiopians kinds remind me a little bit of Khoisans. Shorter , very curly hair light brown yellowish skin etc.
Also I think the basque language is one of the few if not the only pre Indo European language in Europe, somehow they are the only ones who survived probably thanks to their mountain area land between Spain and France

Yeah it would make sense that Ethiopians have more hunter gather than us if they mixed with neighbouring African who had higher amounts of it.
And I didn't know basque was pre indo European, thants cool. I believe that Finnish isn't indo European as well

 

[...j]

Yes the time of the Cushitic Expansion from its birthplace in Sudan down to the horn and as far south as tanzania was at the same time indo Europeans from Ukraine were wiping out the hunter gatherers of Europe or the Niger Congo expansion from their birthplace in southern Nigeria where they wiped out much of the hunter gatherers bar the Khoi-san remaining in South Africa after the bantu finnaly moved into South Africa after depopulating the already small Khoi-san population of South Africa and making it majority bantu. It was a time where pastoralits and farmers were genociding the hunter gatherers and wiping out countless races in the process and moving into their lands. It's why Europe has no pre indo European influences at all. Not a single word in any cadaan language has a pre indo-European word because of how utterly annihilated they were. Same thing probs happend in east Africa where pastoralit cushited from Sudan moved into east African and found khoi San like hunter gathers and because of the much larger population of the nomads and better technologies they were easily killed off.

Not a single word in any cadaan language has a pre indo-European word because of how utterly annihilated they were.

How can you so assuredly say something so wrong?

 

[...j]

How can you so assuredly say something so wrong?

Nevermind, misread lmao, I thought you said "Indo-European word" not pre Indo-European; my bad. However I do believe that there're still pre-PIE words still surviving (the root for the word apple is believed to be one, and Germanic languages (English for example) have a bunch of words theorized to not have originated from PIE and instead a time before it

 

[Khaem]

Nevermind, misread lmao, I thought you said "Indo-European word" not pre Indo-European; my bad. However I do believe that there're still pre-PIE words still surviving (the root for the word apple is believed to be one, and Germanic languages (English for example) have a bunch of words theorized to not have originated from PIE and instead a time before it

Yes @Som gave some examples of the few PIE languages that still exist.

 

[Man with a garuun]

Masai and Somali are related to each other. So are the Tutsis and Somalis. So are Afaras, Somalis, Rendile, and other Horners. We're just an ancient people.

 

[...j]

Masai and Somali are related to each other. So are the Tutsis and Somalis. So are Afaras, Somalis, Rendile, and other Horners. We're just an ancient people.

Do you have any proof? Also what you do you mean by "we"?

 

[Man with a garuun]

Do you have any proof?

Proof of what? Google is your friend. I don't like to prove anything to Internet characters.

 

[...j]

Proof of what? Google is your friend. I don't like to prove anything to Internet characters.

Proof that the Masai, Somali, and Tutsi are related to each other.

I don't like to prove anything to Internet characters.

And I don't like taking answers from Internet people without a source

 

[Man with a garuun]

Proof that the Masai, Somali, and Tutsi are related to each other.

And I don't like taking answers from Internet people without a source

That is fine by me.....You aint marking my papers nor are you paying me to do the search for you, so why do I bother to prove anything to a lazy guy like you? Do your own personal self study, sir.

 

[...j]

@Man with a garuun Furthermore, what did you mean by "we"? From what I've heard you have almost no genetic basis in being Somali

 

[...j]

That is fine by me.....You aint marking my papers nor are you paying me to do the search for you, so why do I bother to prove anything to a lazy guy like you? Do your own personal self study, sir.

"Personal self study" I have, and at no point did I come across Somalis being closely related to the Tutsis; had I not read about the genetic relations Somalis have I would most likely have just taken your word for it. This is the equivalent of going "uhh... my source?? why would I give you my source??", you made a claim and if that claim had anything backing it up you would most likely just provide it

 

[Man with a garuun]

@Man with a garuun Furthermore, what did you mean by "we"? From what I've heard you have almost no genetic basis in being Somali

Who said that? Looking at your pfp, all I see is a cadaan boy. Not sure why would a self-respecting Somali guy carry cadaan guy's pfp unless he is a questionable guy.