Does anyone have a more detailed answer ?
From the recent videos Al-Shabaab released, a few of their fighters made thousands of SNA soldiers flee without fighting. And it also looks like the SNA hasn't done any significant progress since 2022, even worse, they're losing all their gains.
SNA forces outnumber Al-Shabaab more than 2 to 1 but only 8000 out of 24000 SNA troops are trained by the US and Turkey (Danab & Gorgor).
An important factor which is severly lowering SNA troops morale are unpaid salaries, their salaries are already low for such a small army but in addition I've seen multiple reports saying that thousands of soldiers go months without pay. In one report, the UN claimed troops weren’t paid for six months, causing protests and low morale. Another Reuters report from Middle Shabelle revealed entire units vacated their bases after four months without salary. Some even go more than a year without salaries.
The Ministry of Defence still hasn't spoken out about this recurring issue and I'm pretty sure the Ministry of Planning and Finance has pointed out the unprofessionalism of the Ministry of Defence back in 2018. Come to think of it, it's the only Ministry which hasn't made any significant progress or milestones, probably the least transparent as well.
When the US exposed corruption within the Somali army, the Ministry of Defence promised suspensions and arrests but no updates were made and sources are saying no arrests happened : https://thesomalidigest.com/ministr...theft-lacks-substance/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
I know rampant corruption and underpaid soldiers are at the core of this failure, but the more I read about it the more I notice the SNA has literally always been useless the whole time, the 2022 offensive was won greatly thanks to clan militias who are more motivated to defend their lands and don't run at the first sign of a black flag. FGS is so desperate they recently got exposed for stealing Macwisley Ws.
Somalia now has Attack helicopters and Combat drones but air superiority means nothing if you have no land army.
When you look at this map, it would seem like the SNA or any modern army could easily isolate and encircle Galmudug Shabab as to cut them off from their Southern counterparts, yet nothing has happened for years.
I initially thought Al-Shabaab was a really powerful and coordinated force but after seeing their failed incursions into Ethiopia it's clear that any modern army could defeat them.
The recent events in Puntland reinforced this view and showed us what a real competent army and motivated troops were like, in less than a year most of ISIS was totally crushed by Puntland forces.
By now, it's evident the Somali National Army is highly dysfunctional and in urgent need of total reform. What do you think could realistically be done to fix what may be the most ineffective military force of this century and raise morale/discipline of their soldiers ? Help me understand this better.
Only serious and realistic answers please.
From the recent videos Al-Shabaab released, a few of their fighters made thousands of SNA soldiers flee without fighting. And it also looks like the SNA hasn't done any significant progress since 2022, even worse, they're losing all their gains.
SNA forces outnumber Al-Shabaab more than 2 to 1 but only 8000 out of 24000 SNA troops are trained by the US and Turkey (Danab & Gorgor).
An important factor which is severly lowering SNA troops morale are unpaid salaries, their salaries are already low for such a small army but in addition I've seen multiple reports saying that thousands of soldiers go months without pay. In one report, the UN claimed troops weren’t paid for six months, causing protests and low morale. Another Reuters report from Middle Shabelle revealed entire units vacated their bases after four months without salary. Some even go more than a year without salaries.
The Ministry of Defence still hasn't spoken out about this recurring issue and I'm pretty sure the Ministry of Planning and Finance has pointed out the unprofessionalism of the Ministry of Defence back in 2018. Come to think of it, it's the only Ministry which hasn't made any significant progress or milestones, probably the least transparent as well.
When the US exposed corruption within the Somali army, the Ministry of Defence promised suspensions and arrests but no updates were made and sources are saying no arrests happened : https://thesomalidigest.com/ministr...theft-lacks-substance/?utm_source=chatgpt.com
I know rampant corruption and underpaid soldiers are at the core of this failure, but the more I read about it the more I notice the SNA has literally always been useless the whole time, the 2022 offensive was won greatly thanks to clan militias who are more motivated to defend their lands and don't run at the first sign of a black flag. FGS is so desperate they recently got exposed for stealing Macwisley Ws.
Somalia now has Attack helicopters and Combat drones but air superiority means nothing if you have no land army.
When you look at this map, it would seem like the SNA or any modern army could easily isolate and encircle Galmudug Shabab as to cut them off from their Southern counterparts, yet nothing has happened for years.
I initially thought Al-Shabaab was a really powerful and coordinated force but after seeing their failed incursions into Ethiopia it's clear that any modern army could defeat them.
The recent events in Puntland reinforced this view and showed us what a real competent army and motivated troops were like, in less than a year most of ISIS was totally crushed by Puntland forces.
By now, it's evident the Somali National Army is highly dysfunctional and in urgent need of total reform. What do you think could realistically be done to fix what may be the most ineffective military force of this century and raise morale/discipline of their soldiers ? Help me understand this better.
Only serious and realistic answers please.
Last edited:
