what are your thoughts on punishment for apostasy in islam

[Lily]

Please don't troll. I don't wana read hate filled comments about my diin... dhaaanks >,,<


I don't know how to feel about it


I have a friend who became christian. I enjoy her company. Not only does she work hard, but she somewhat makes life seem simple. She has that just do it attitude. The other day we were trying to eat lunch at this new place. We assumed the food was halal because my other friend also bought lunch from there (hes mulims). She quickly disappeared and when she came back she told me how she felt bit dodgy about the place and went to find out if the food was really halal and it turned out to be not. She eats anything. I was touched at how she went out of her way to find it out for me.


She would prolly be executed for leaving the diinta and it would really upset me... or maybe I understood it wrong?... i dunno what to think.... usually I mind my own business... I judge no one.... and I have nothing to do with whatever any person wants to do...

 

[Baraf]

you both don't live in a muslim country so why bother with the idea in the first place?

 

[Khathead]

Whats her ethnicity? I'm a Christian convert too

 

[RoyalSomali]

punish me that will be kinky

 

[Masaasbaa]

Whats her ethnicity? I'm a Christian convert too

out of all the things in the world you could have become, from a pretentious atheist to an an AJ you picked Christianity, are you sure it wasn't group pressure or trying to ''fit in'' that made you convert.

 

[Baraf]

out of all the things in the world you could have become, from a pretentious atheist to an an AJ you picked Christianity, are you sure it wasn't group pressure or trying to ''fit in'' that mad you convert.

he converted for his habesha girlfriend

 

[Masaasbaa]

he converted for his habesha girlfriend

Ilaahow i hanuuni asagana hanuuni. ameen

 

[Zak Jingo]

To be honest, I don't get Muslims who convert to Christianity, it's just those kind of people who just want to fit in, and get away from how bad muslims are portrayed today. But ex Muslim to atheist is something I can understand, just one of those confused fellows.

 

[Rooble]

Christianity out of all things. The holy trinity. The father, the son and the holy spirit. Bunch of lost people.

Islam is the most practiced religion

Lily there is no compulsion in religion and you're friend doesn't seem to hate Islam or strive against it.

 

[Samawada]

Lily there is no compulsion in religion and you're friend doesn't seem to hate Islam or strive against it.

Exactly. Lakum diinakum waliiya diin. Despite the mental gymnastics used by pro-beheaders, the Quraan made it simple. IMHO of course.

 

[BigGus]

you both don't live in a muslim country so why bother with the idea in the first place?

So, if they were talking about a Muslim country, it would be fine by you to kill them?

 

[JohnDoe]

Exactly. Lakum diinakum waliiya diin. Despite the mental gymnastics used by pro-beheaders, the Quraan made it simple. IMHO of course.

"'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.'" Sahih Bukhari (4:52:260)

No mental gymnastics required mate.

 

[Zak Jingo]

So, if they were talking about a Muslim country, it would be fine by you to kill them?

Commoners can't take such a matter in their own hands.

 

[BigGus]

Commoners can't take such a matter in their own hands.

But, if the Imam, tribal leader or the state does, it's still okay? So, it's still moral to kill someone who has a different belief than you if they are not harming anyone?

 

[Inactive]

I hope my atheist brothers and sisters in the backwards, impoverished and hellhole Ummah nations make their way to safety in the West.

Let those bastards kill each other. We are all protected in the West

 

[Samawada]

"'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.'" Sahih Bukhari (4:52:260)

No mental gymnastics required mate.

There is no compulsion in religion - The Quraan.

Gtfoh.

 

[BigGus]

There is no compulsion in religion - The Quraan.

Gtfoh.

It's a sahih Hadith - "`Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn `Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "

So you're one of those people who only believes in the Quran and not the hadiths? Or you pick and chose, like a buffet.

 

[Hafez]

They live in the West. The law of the land in the West is not the Shariah law. If your friend lived in an Islamic state, then it's a different story. There's no point in bringing up these hypothetical scenarios in the first place. What benefit does it serve?

 

[Hubble]

It's a sahih Hadith - "`Ali burnt some people and this news reached Ibn `Abbas, who said, "Had I been in his place I would not have burnt them, as the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'Don't punish (anybody) with Allah's Punishment.' No doubt, I would have killed them, for the Prophet (ﷺ) said, 'If somebody (a Muslim) discards his religion, kill him.' "

So you're one of those people who only believes in the Quran and not the hadiths? Or you pick and chose, like a buffet.

Choosing Allah's infallible words over a fallible hadith which contradicts the Quran is not against Islam, Muslims are required to think for themselves.

 

[BigGus]

Choosing Allah's infallible words over a fallible hadith which contradicts the Quran is not against Islam, Muslims are required to think for themselves.

Then, since the hadiths are not accurate according to you, I'm guessing you don' take them serious. So, you're one of those Quranist?