Somaliland farmers losing out to cheap food imported from Ethiopia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Factz

Factzopedia
VIP
beero.jpg


(ERGO) – Somaliland farmers are complaining that cheap imports of food from Ethiopia are driving prices down in the local markets and ruining their chances of recovery after the recent drought.


Mowlid Nur Omar, a farmer in Arro-Tuulka village in Gabiley, told Radio Ergo that he brought 200 kg of tomatoes to Gobanimo market in Hargeisa earlier this month. But after failing to sell any he watched the tomatoes rotting away.


On 14 August, he came back again to Gobanimo with 10 kg of maize and sorghum but could not sell the grain either.


Farmers say that one kilo of sorghum has fallen from 8,000 to 2,000 Somaliland shillings ($1 to $0.25) due to the market being flooded with produce, especially from Ethiopia.


Mowlid said he had invested $1,000 in his farm when he planted in the ‘gu rainy season and he had hoped for higher returns. He still has some maize and sorghum growing in the field: given the low prices he now plans to sell it off as livestock fodder to pastoralists.


Farmers in parts of neighboring Ethiopia had very good harvests this season and have been exporting surplus produced to Somaliland markets at low prices.


Mohamud Guled Ali owns a two hectare farm in Agamsaha village, 35 km west of Hargeisa. He took 100 kgs of tomatoes to the market in Arabsiya but had to sell off his produce for far less than he expected. He sold 10 kgs of tomatoes at $2, as compared to the price of $20 he used to get for the same amount.


He returned to his village without selling his maize.


He told Radio Ergo that he took his produce to market on 29 July and 11 August, but both trips were in vain. The sharp fall in prices meant he made a huge loss and could not recover his initial investment.


Mohamud took a loan of $500 to buy seeds and cultivate the land and cannot see how to meet the repayment due in October. He is also worried about the livelihoods of his nine children


Local farmers in Somaliland are bitter about the fact that farmers in Ethiopia get subsidies and transport assistance from the government to export their produce over the border.


The coordinator of the Ministry of Agriculture in Marodijeh, Abdirisaq Muhumed Gabobe, told Radio Ergo that local markets are facing very stiff competition. In addition, he estimated that local farm production this year has dropped by half.

News: https://www.radioergo.org/2018/08/2...to-cheap-food-imported-from-ethiopia/?lang=en

Bad move Somaliland. Now the farmers in Somaliland are losing their jobs since the markets in major cities prefer cheaper Ethiopian products. The government must invest in Somaliland farms and lend them with support. The key of civilization is to be self-sufficient.
 
Last edited:

Fahad Yasin

Duqbilow Nation
Sad reality, the cause of this dawlad la'aan. I consider Somaliland & Puntland Ethiopia's es, don't @ me:browtf:

Waryadaa get back at them. Flood their market with even cheaper produce, we be eating good from flooding Kenya's market with dirt cheap sugar.:damedamn:
 

Factz

Factzopedia
VIP
Time for protectonist somaliland first policies! Get to work, bixi.

Protectionist is how you spell it but I know what you mean. Somaliland really needs to start being more self-sufficient and stop being dependent on others, especially Ethiopia.
 

.279

VIP
Protectionist is how you spell it but I know what you mean. Somaliland really needs to start being more self-sufficient and stop being dependent on others, especially Ethiopia.

I make a lot of typos so get used to it, son
 

Ras

It's all so tiresome
VIP
Protectionism makes you enemies.

Adding tariffs for imported food would just increase the price if food for everyone since S.land was never self sufficient in the first place.

Since you can't price or farm yourself out of this then why protect the industry?

Somaliland less than 3% of the Ethiopian population.

Just build factories that import raw ingredients from Ethiopia and ship them back processed foods... Covers the lost jobs and ensures people can afford to buy food since you make 3x the profit or more now.
 

Crow

Make Hobyo Great Again
VIP
Since you can't price or farm yourself out of this then why protect the industry?
You're supposed to protect the industry to grow it. Ethiopia has a headstart because they have been farming for centuries but we never farmed much in northern Somalia. There's a ton of untapped potential and we are only scratching the surface. I mean just look at this.
Puntland is probably the driest part of the country. If we protect our agricultural industries from Ethiopia this should be the minimum that we can accomplish in every part of the country. Our farmers just need some room to breathe without having to worry about cheap goods flooding local markets. We also need to teach more people to farm.
 
Ethiopian farmers work in coops and anything they literally huddle in groups and funnel harvest up the supply chain. Many Somali farmers are lone wolves and don’t work together to maximize outputs and decrease inputs.

Northern Somalis can’t compete on commodities with Ethiopia unless technology is involved. We get the same sunlight, but not the same soil or irrigation.
 
Stupid people, if they stuck with Somalia then the could’ve imported from their Somali brothers while it benefits them.
 

Ras

It's all so tiresome
VIP
You're supposed to protect the industry to grow it. Ethiopia has a headstart because they have been farming for centuries but we never farmed much in northern Somalia. There's a ton of untapped potential and we are only scratching the surface. I mean just look at this.
Puntland is probably the driest part of the country. If we protect our agricultural industries from Ethiopia this should be the minimum that we can accomplish in every part of the country. Our farmers just need some room to breathe without having to worry about cheap goods flooding local markets. We also need to teach more people to farm.

If you put tarrifs on imported food then you'll have to make sure that the domestic supply can cover the demand within Somaliland.

Otherwise people would just smuggle it in or starve.

Where are you going to find enough water to irrigate hundreds of thousands of hectares that you'll need to feed the millions in Somaliland?

You do know how much water is required right?

If you can't feed the population yourself then pushing for tarrifs is just an ignorant idea.

Focus on other industries where you can realistically compete.
 
Tariffs can be good for other reasons than import regulation, maybe to take purchasing power from consumers to fund other things like healthcare or education.

Maybe food should be a little more expensive to fund healthcare and education?
 

Ras

It's all so tiresome
VIP
Tariffs can be good for other reasons than import regulation, maybe to take purchasing power from consumers to fund other things like healthcare or education.

Maybe food should be a little more expensive to fund healthcare and education?

For a lot of poorer families the cost of food takes up more than 40% of their income.

Another 60% goes to rent, schooling and basic utilities.

Any emergencies are paid through loans from family and friends.

A 5% food tarrif would mean that they won't be able to pay for medical emergencies or even school fees for their daughters.

10%+ would mean a lot of families would eat a lot less.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trending

Latest posts

Top